- Oct 31, 2012
- 54,069
- 53,104
- 3,605
Brought to you by the Democrat party.
All this talk about rejecting a Supreme Court nominee got me digging into some history.
Did you know that there are only 11 nominees to the Supreme Court that were rejected by the Senate?
Here is a list of the last 4:
1. Robert Bork (1987) Appointed by Reagan
2. G Harrold Carswell (1970) Appointed by Nixon
3. Clement Haynsworth Jr. (1969) Appointed by Nixon
4. John Parker (1930) Appointed by Herbert Hoover
All of these rejected nominees were submitted by Republican Presidents. Yay! In fact, you have to go all the way back to 1894 to see a Supreme Court justice rejected by the Senate that was appointed by a democrat.
Some interesting info,
Bork was rejected mainly because he was viewed as possibly wanting to overturn Roe vs. Wade which seems to have become an acceptable litmus test to see if they are qualified Justice. Meanwhile, Court members like Hagan have never been a judge but in terms of being qualified, she is just fine anyway.
Other Republican nominees that were rejected, such as Harrold Carswell and John Parker, were rejected because they were seen a racists. I'm not sure of the dirt they dug up on Carswell, but I can tell you what they dug up on Parker. Parker was nominated by Herbert Hoover and rejected in 1930 on the basis of this comment, "The participation of the Negro in politics is a source of evil and danger to both races and is not desired by the wise men in either race."
So all well and good, don't vote for the Republican nominated Parker, but just a few years later FDR appoints Hugo Black.
Who is Hugo Black you ask?
Hugo Black had been associate justice of the Supreme Court for less than a month when the news broke. In September of 1937, an exposé by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette found proof of Black’s membership in the Ku Klux Klan. He had joined in September of 1923, and resigned in July, 1925, as one of his first moves before running for one of Alabama’s U.S. Senate seat. Ironically, the smoking gun was Black’s resignation letter, written in legible longhand on Klan stationery, which appeared on the paper’s front page.
Franklin Roosevelt, who nominated Hugo Black, was implicated in the scandal, which threatened to have far-reaching consequences for the president’s New Deal image. What was once seen as shrewd politics — the New Deal-friendly textualist was confirmed with a 63–16 vote — had become a disgrace. “Millions of Americans,” wrote one Indiana newspaper, “will not forget this sole tangible accomplishment of President Roosevelt’s attempted ‘liberalization’ of the Supreme Court.”
Yea, sounds about right.
Just one more interesting fact, after Carswell's name and reputation had been destroyed by Leftists, Nixon then appointed Harry Blackman to take his place and was nominated 94-0, and overwhelming favorite for both parties. He then went on to author Roe vs. Wade. Yay GOP!
As for the current justices, all the democrat justices got well over 60 votes to be nominated from both parties. However, all the Republican picks got under 60 votes EXCEPT John Roberts who later upheld Obamacare. Yay GOP!
Here are the votes from the Senate each received:
Here is a list of the Democrat appointments
Sotomayor (67-29)
Kagan (63-29)
Ginsburg (96-3)
Breyer (87-9)
And now the lowly evil Republicans, except Roberts, of course
Roberts (78-22)
Thomas (52-48)
Alito (58-42)
Gorsuch (54-45)
You can always spot a conservative Justice backstabber like Roberts cuz they will always get more than 60 votes from the Senate.
All this talk about rejecting a Supreme Court nominee got me digging into some history.
Did you know that there are only 11 nominees to the Supreme Court that were rejected by the Senate?
Here is a list of the last 4:
1. Robert Bork (1987) Appointed by Reagan
2. G Harrold Carswell (1970) Appointed by Nixon
3. Clement Haynsworth Jr. (1969) Appointed by Nixon
4. John Parker (1930) Appointed by Herbert Hoover
All of these rejected nominees were submitted by Republican Presidents. Yay! In fact, you have to go all the way back to 1894 to see a Supreme Court justice rejected by the Senate that was appointed by a democrat.
Some interesting info,
Bork was rejected mainly because he was viewed as possibly wanting to overturn Roe vs. Wade which seems to have become an acceptable litmus test to see if they are qualified Justice. Meanwhile, Court members like Hagan have never been a judge but in terms of being qualified, she is just fine anyway.
Other Republican nominees that were rejected, such as Harrold Carswell and John Parker, were rejected because they were seen a racists. I'm not sure of the dirt they dug up on Carswell, but I can tell you what they dug up on Parker. Parker was nominated by Herbert Hoover and rejected in 1930 on the basis of this comment, "The participation of the Negro in politics is a source of evil and danger to both races and is not desired by the wise men in either race."
So all well and good, don't vote for the Republican nominated Parker, but just a few years later FDR appoints Hugo Black.
Who is Hugo Black you ask?
Hugo Black had been associate justice of the Supreme Court for less than a month when the news broke. In September of 1937, an exposé by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette found proof of Black’s membership in the Ku Klux Klan. He had joined in September of 1923, and resigned in July, 1925, as one of his first moves before running for one of Alabama’s U.S. Senate seat. Ironically, the smoking gun was Black’s resignation letter, written in legible longhand on Klan stationery, which appeared on the paper’s front page.
Franklin Roosevelt, who nominated Hugo Black, was implicated in the scandal, which threatened to have far-reaching consequences for the president’s New Deal image. What was once seen as shrewd politics — the New Deal-friendly textualist was confirmed with a 63–16 vote — had become a disgrace. “Millions of Americans,” wrote one Indiana newspaper, “will not forget this sole tangible accomplishment of President Roosevelt’s attempted ‘liberalization’ of the Supreme Court.”
Yea, sounds about right.
Just one more interesting fact, after Carswell's name and reputation had been destroyed by Leftists, Nixon then appointed Harry Blackman to take his place and was nominated 94-0, and overwhelming favorite for both parties. He then went on to author Roe vs. Wade. Yay GOP!
As for the current justices, all the democrat justices got well over 60 votes to be nominated from both parties. However, all the Republican picks got under 60 votes EXCEPT John Roberts who later upheld Obamacare. Yay GOP!
Here are the votes from the Senate each received:
Here is a list of the Democrat appointments
Sotomayor (67-29)
Kagan (63-29)
Ginsburg (96-3)
Breyer (87-9)
And now the lowly evil Republicans, except Roberts, of course
Roberts (78-22)
Thomas (52-48)
Alito (58-42)
Gorsuch (54-45)
You can always spot a conservative Justice backstabber like Roberts cuz they will always get more than 60 votes from the Senate.