Israel's Independence Day!

[P F Tinmore]

Why do you go through all these monkey motions to prove Israel's BS talking point that there was no Palestine.

Palestine is a territory defined by international borders. They have a nationality and citizenship.

They had a functioning society and culture.

They had a functioning economy with a positive balance of trade in international markets, i.e. they were making money.

But they (and by 'they', I mean the Arab Palestinians) had no government and no ability to enter into relations with other states. So they were not a state, by definition. Until Israel formed. Israel had a defined territory with international borders, nationality AND a government and international relationships. That is what made them a state and what continues, to this day, not to make Arab Palestine a state.

Israel had a defined territory with international borders,

Then why does every map of Israel show it inside fake border armistice lines (that were specifically not to be political or territorial boundaries) instead of real borders?

If Israel’s armistice lines are fake and not designed to be Political or Territorial Israel doesn’t have to abide by them

Indeed, but then there are those pesky Palestinian international borders.

 

[rylah]

Why do you go through all these monkey motions to prove Israel's BS talking point that there was no Palestine.

Palestine is a territory defined by international borders. They have a nationality and citizenship.

They had a functioning society and culture.

They had a functioning economy with a positive balance of trade in international markets, i.e. they were making money.

But they (and by 'they', I mean the Arab Palestinians) had no government and no ability to enter into relations with other states. So they were not a state, by definition. Until Israel formed. Israel had a defined territory with international borders, nationality AND a government and international relationships. That is what made them a state and what continues, to this day, not to make Arab Palestine a state.

Israel had a defined territory with international borders,

Then why does every map of Israel show it inside fake border armistice lines (that were specifically not to be political or territorial boundaries) instead of real borders?

If Israel’s armistice lines are fake and not designed to be Political or Territorial Israel doesn’t have to abide by them

Indeed, but then there are those pesky Palestinian international borders.

And sovereignty over all of that land was vested with the Jewish nation by an act of international law.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Why do you go through all these monkey motions to prove Israel's BS talking point that there was no Palestine.

Palestine is a territory defined by international borders. They have a nationality and citizenship.

They had a functioning society and culture.

They had a functioning economy with a positive balance of trade in international markets, i.e. they were making money.

But they (and by 'they', I mean the Arab Palestinians) had no government and no ability to enter into relations with other states. So they were not a state, by definition. Until Israel formed. Israel had a defined territory with international borders, nationality AND a government and international relationships. That is what made them a state and what continues, to this day, not to make Arab Palestine a state.

Israel had a defined territory with international borders,

Then why does every map of Israel show it inside fake border armistice lines (that were specifically not to be political or territorial boundaries) instead of real borders?

If Israel’s armistice lines are fake and not designed to be Political or Territorial Israel doesn’t have to abide by them

Indeed, but then there are those pesky Palestinian international borders.

And sovereignty over all of that land was vested with the Jewish nation by an act of international law.

It was not. The Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship. Immigrant Jews were to get Palestinian citizenship.

Define immigrant?

 

[rylah]

But they (and by 'they', I mean the Arab Palestinians) had no government and no ability to enter into relations with other states. So they were not a state, by definition. Until Israel formed. Israel had a defined territory with international borders, nationality AND a government and international relationships. That is what made them a state and what continues, to this day, not to make Arab Palestine a state.

Israel had a defined territory with international borders,

Then why does every map of Israel show it inside fake border armistice lines (that were specifically not to be political or territorial boundaries) instead of real borders?

If Israel’s armistice lines are fake and not designed to be Political or Territorial Israel doesn’t have to abide by them

Indeed, but then there are those pesky Palestinian international borders.

And sovereignty over all of that land was vested with the Jewish nation by an act of international law.

It was not. The Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship. Immigrant Jews were to get Palestinian citizenship.

Define immigrant?

How does that change the fact that sovereignty over the whole of the land was vested with the Jewish nation since 1920 by an act of international law?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Then why does every map of Israel show it inside fake border armistice lines (that were specifically not to be political or territorial boundaries) instead of real borders?

If Israel’s armistice lines are fake and not designed to be Political or Territorial Israel doesn’t have to abide by them

Indeed, but then there are those pesky Palestinian international borders.

And sovereignty over all of that land was vested with the Jewish nation by an act of international law.

It was not. The Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship. Immigrant Jews were to get Palestinian citizenship.

Define immigrant?

How does that change the fact that sovereignty over the whole of the land was vested with the Jewish nation since 1920 by an act of international law?.

What about all of those Palestinians who had citizenship before the immigrants arrived?

Define immigrant?

 

[rylah]

If Israel’s armistice lines are fake and not designed to be Political or Territorial Israel doesn’t have to abide by them

Indeed, but then there are those pesky Palestinian international borders.

And sovereignty over all of that land was vested with the Jewish nation by an act of international law.

It was not. The Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship. Immigrant Jews were to get Palestinian citizenship.

Define immigrant?

How does that change the fact that sovereignty over the whole of the land was vested with the Jewish nation since 1920 by an act of international law?.

What about all of those Palestinians who had citizenship before the immigrants arrived?

Define immigrant?

What does immigration have to do with sovereignty?

 

[rylah]

 

[Weatherman2020]

Why do you go through all these monkey motions to prove Israel's BS talking point that there was no Palestine.

Palestine is a territory defined by international borders. They have a nationality and citizenship.

They had a functioning society and culture.

They had a functioning economy with a positive balance of trade in international markets, i.e. they were making money.

But they (and by 'they', I mean the Arab Palestinians) had no government and no ability to enter into relations with other states. So they were not a state, by definition. Until Israel formed. Israel had a defined territory with international borders, nationality AND a government and international relationships. That is what made them a state and what continues, to this day, not to make Arab Palestine a state.

Israel had a defined territory with international borders,

Then why does every map of Israel show it inside fake border armistice lines (that were specifically not to be political or territorial boundaries) instead of real borders?

If Israel’s armistice lines are fake and not designed to be Political or Territorial Israel doesn’t have to abide by them

Indeed, but then there are those pesky Palestinian international borders.

What in the hell is an international border?

Do try to make your lies not so funny.