Russia in 1917 and China in 1920 were not big governments. They did nothing for the majority of the population and relied on cheap labor from peasants who were near starvation. They invested little in infrastructure, education or healthcare. The wealthy flourished
That is when their big government started to murder their own people moron.......
Both of those governments were a result of small governments which exploited peasant workers to the point of revolt
Your Nazi Germany example is the complete opposite. They exploited nationalism and scapegoating and a split electorate to seize power. Much like Trump in 2016
Boy...that was stupid.....the national socialist government did exactly what you say you want....they controlled the entire economy.......exactly as you want, they controlled every aspect of life, just like you want......and they murdered about 12 million Europeans to do it.....
Odd...who ever said anything about controlling the economy?
Doing things for people is not socialism
The difference between social democracy that is used in every developed nation on earth and socialism is who owns the production. In social democracy the private sector generally controls the production and it also allows people to have property rights....
Socialism
- No private property
- No control of the production
-Little political power at the level of the people on the norm.
Social democracy in which every nation that is well developed is
-Private property
-The private sector controls the vast % of the production.
-The people can vote
Another difference is the size of the public sphere...Socialism everything is done and shared within the politic sector but social democracy only things that everyone enjoys like infrastructure, education and in some cases healthcare are within this sphere.
Pure capitalism as you conservatives are fighting for would just allow the rich and the upper class to become barons again and do as they wish. As they wish in this case is to take it all and stash it and mistreat the rest of the country.