Bootney Lee Farnsworth
Diamond Member
The real test is doing a Texas Brisket.I just bought a Traeger Ironwood 885. Im shocked by how easy it is to use and how effective it is. I made pulled pork with an 8 pound bone in pork shoulder. I had never smoked anything in my life, yet that pulled pork was as good or better than anything ive ever eaten at any legit BBQ joint. The next day i made babyback ribs which turned out absolutely perfect. They may have been the best ribs ive ever had.
Who else is smoking around here? What smoker do you have? Do you have any good recipes?
Here is a pic of my brand new smoker...
![]()
Brisket is the most challenging cut to properly smoke, because one wrong move will make it tougher than a leather motorcycle jacket or sandpaper dry.
If that smoker will hold a steady temp or 225º to 250º and keep the meat moist with a good 1/4 to 3/8 inch smoke ring, it passes.
But, I am not a fan of pellet smokers. It has a slightly different taste, in my opinion.
Just this week, I smoked a 12lb brisket on this cheap-ass Masterbuilt charcoal smoker.

Lowe's--$62
The key is time and temp. I achieved accurate, steady temp using this:

Amazon - $40
I keep the smoker temp in the 225º-250º range, use large wood chunks at the bottom of the charcoal pan (don't throw them on top--bad flavoring--scientifically proven), and use the Minion Method (Minion Method), low and slow internal temp increase to between 195º and 203º, and post-smoke slow resting in foil until the internal reaches 140º before cutting and serving. Skipping one of those steps will cause the meat fibers to remain "hard" (not relaxed and soft) or will cause the moisture to evaporate or leak out, making the meat nearly worthless.
Cheap charcoal smokers take a little more tuning to keep steady (vent adjustments and charcoal placement/ignition), but once you have them dialed in, they hold steady and the flavor cannot be duplicated/imitated.
All who have tasted my brisket have confirmed that it is better than most local and national BBQ vendors (Sonny Brian's Smokehouse being the lone exception, likely because most bbq joints can't afford to pay people to babysit a brisket for 12 hours).
My question is what about that pellet smoker makes it superior to other methods, particularly given the price point? I don't understand the benefits.
.