If
gipper refers to
Roudy as being a radical Zionist, aka a Nazi, it's because he defends and propagates genocide, ethic-cleansing, racial dogmas and hate towards other people and religions, plus the irrational self-declared territorial demand towards a Jewish homeland based onto Palestine - as such
gipper is absolutely correct.
Now in reference to the topic;
After this Gaza genocide ends, Palestinians will Not be free. Since Israel aka the Zionist government will never commit itself in earnest to come to a two State solution. they want ALL the land, plus they already annexed illegally other countries territories - which were already formulated by Zionists, way before 1948.
The chant - "from the river to the sea" is the Palestinian (PLO) reaction. stemming from the 60'ies,
opposing as to what the Zionists had factually done since 1948. And the Zionist are playing people for stupid - via falsely claiming that the Palestinians would demand, as to what Israel has and is still doing - occupying and promoting ethic cleansing. The chant refers to the exact opposite.
As such a moderate Israeli government "factually interested in a peaceful solution" - that orients itself towards the UN 1947 Partition plan, is the primary requisite in any discussion pertaining to this matter. One can't expect, that the Palestinians will simply acquit to the present "remains" of the West-Bank. - and the Zionist are fully aware of that.
From the River to the Sea
A Jewish website!!
Adam Johannes presents a short history of the slogan “from the river to the sea…” and its vicissitudes through different…
www.jewishvoiceforlabour.org.uk
In the late 1960s, the PLO put forward a visionary idea of Arab-Jewish coexistence in one democracy, arguing for Israel and the Occupied Territories to become “one secular, democratic state of Palestine” based on one person, one vote, where Arabs, Jews, Muslims and Christians would enjoy full equality.
In 1969 the PLO had formally declared its goal “to establish a free and democratic society in Palestine for all Palestinians whether they are Muslims, Christians or Jews”. The idea was revolutionary at the time, an implicit challenge to the Arab regimes in the region that were neither free nor democratic. It was also revolutionary in making an offer to share the land as equal citizens with the people who had driven the Palestinians from their land and placed them under military occupation.
In 1974, Yasser Arafat, PLO leader, in his famous speech to the UN General Assembly would once again offer a vision of Israel and the Occupied Territories transcended by Arab-Jewish coexistence in a shared democracy from the river to the sea,
However soon afterwards the PLO began to abandon the vision. The idea of Palestine-Israel becoming one state had found little uptake from Israeli Jews, except tiny socialist groups like Matzpen, and the PLO could neither build the power, nor develop the political strategy to achieve their goal.