Wait...so torture is necessary to get vital information but the ability to descript phones isn't?
Torture of Americans? Absolutely unacceptable (and doesn't happen). Torture of filthy muslims who are
not protected by the U.S. Constitution? Hell yes it is vital.
I'm not sure why you find this so perplexing. The U.S. government has no authority over the American people outside of what is described in the U.S. Constitution. So demanding the ability to access my phone, computer, etc. without a warrant - major violation of the 4th Amendment. Torturing idiot muslims? Ok. Even encouraged (by intelligent, informed, patriotic Americans).