Having to have a government photo issued ID does not and will NOT STOP any illegal voting, if they got registered by the State, in the FIRST PLACE.
That's a different issue and has no bearing on the discussion at hand.
Requiring an ID at the poll allows the state to verify that the person at the poll is who he claims to be.
So, what argument do you have against the suggestions in the OP?
Why require it, if there is no problem in the first place? Why increase gvt power over us, when it is not necessary? WHY?
Who said it is not necessary?
How does requiring you to show you are who you say your are when you try to vote increase government power over anyone?
Pretty please M 14, just spend a few minutes of critical thinking and analysis and plain ole common sense on this....let's think it through together to come up with the scenario of someone trying to vote in someone elses place....
-Is this person that wants to commit voter fraud and vote in your Name at the polls a neighbor or a stranger?
*IF a neighbor, and a citizen, why wouldn't they just vote in their own name? And if they want to steal your vote so that they got 2 votes, don't you think he would be afraid of getting caught at the same polling place that he votes at regularly by the poll worker recognizing him, or that YOU would actually have beaten him there and voted just a few minutes earlier and getting caught that way? AND would this neighbor truly commit a felony at the moment he has to sign your name on the voter roster, and RISK his entire career and life by forever being identified as a con or ex con felon?
I think logic says this scenario could be taken off the table as an option...it's just so highly unlikely.
-So, let's go with it being a Stranger.... where did they get your name and address? How do they know you are a registered voter and how do they know what party affiliation you are? In Massachusetts and here in Maine, neither State had any or have any ID laws to vote when I voted....well you did not just have to give the poll worker your name.... it was required of them to ask for your name, your address and what party you were registered....
OK, this stranger in a state with no gvt photo id required, that is trying to steal your vote by impersonating you at the voting place, has to be an INSIDER.... he has to have access to voter rolls, to the names and addresses and party affiliation...and randomly picked you to impersonate....OR maybe he did this because he also had access to your voting record....and could see that you had not voted in elections frequently?
IF this is the case, this stranger works for one of the Parties imo. and IS NOT going to risk this fraud for just you and your vote, this would be a case of impersonating hundreds or thousands of voters if in a metropolitan area....ENOUGH to change the outcome of the vote....whatever that hurdle is.....
The ''Stranger'', the ''insider'' is not going to hire hundreds or thousands of people to go out and vote in person by impersonating other voters....the RISK is too high that a few of them get caught, due to poll workers recognizing them as not the person they claim, or the grandma of wife are the poll workers at the voting place, or the person they are trying to impersonate just happened to have already voted, or just 1 of the hundreds hired had loose lips that sinks ships....and it leads back to the stranger with the list....
THIS TOO all seems like it is too high risk, so I would rule this out as unlikely as well....
Maybe this stranger would use this voter list and voter information to vote absentee ballot? Seems like this would be more likely, and less of a risk.... but even with that, there are some hurdles....the towns mail out the absentee ballots for their citizens that request them....at least I believe that is who sends the ab ballots out? I just requested one today....the first time in Maine in the 7 years living here....off the internet... They asked me my name, and my town name that I voted in, my address AND the address I wanted them to send my ballot to...it could NOT be a P.O. Box.
This ''stranger/insider'' has to come up with addresses to have the absentee ballots mailed to, in order to get them....so they would not use your address, because then you would get it and they wouldn't and this would flag that something is wrong in your head and also defeat the stranger's purpose, which is voter fraud....in a big big way.... so let's say they have a 2nd insider that works in the office that sends out the absentees....but again, I think this is done by each voting district, so the stranger could need 50 insiders to get the absentee ballots?
Gosh, that scenario doesn't work either...?
OK OK, then maybe it is DEAD PEOPLE still on the voter rolls that they would impersonate???
BUT THE SOLUTION to this possibility would be to have the State Dept of Health notify the elections board of all the people they have issued death certificates for and REMOVE THEM from the voter roster, done!
-------------------------------------------------
you are welcome to add scenarios I may have missed, but as it stands....
Government issued Photo ID's being mandatory to vote is SIMPLY NOT NECESSARY to solve or prevent voter fraud at the polls....
So I ask AGAIN, why are you even supporting such a charade?
Is it that you want to make it more difficult to vote for the sect of citizens that do not have a government issued photo id and easier for the sect of citizens that drive?
Is it because YOU think minorities are too dumb to go through the trouble of getting ID's as conservatives are claiming is the case with liberals, and THIS would help the Cons win the elections or at least give cons a better chance at getting conservatives elected?
Is it because your Party told you, that you should insist on these gvt issued photo id's? Do you always do what your party asks, without thinking things through?
Is it because you believe that every citizen should have a gvt issued photo id, not just for voting, but a mandatory National ID Card and this is the BACK DOOR WAY of getting this made in to law?