Thread for Zionists who Deny the Existence of the Palestinian Christians and Muslims

[P F Tinmore]

Chaim Weizmann
Feisal Ibn al-Hussein.

Were either of them Palestinian?

 

[Hollie]

Well gee whiz. The Monty has dredged up his entire library of cut and paste articles and YouTube videos. It's interesting see that his attempt at argument consists of a handful of articles that he endlessly cuts and pastes across multiple threads.

 

[Hollie]

Chaim Weizmann
Feisal Ibn al-Hussein.

Were either of them Palestinian?

"Pal'istanian" was never a nationality.

You still suffer from "Befuddled Syndrome" thinking your invented "country of Pally'land" was anything more than a geographic area controlled by the Turk Islamists.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Chaim Weizmann
Feisal Ibn al-Hussein.

Were either of them Palestinian?

"Pal'istanian" was never a nationality.

You still suffer from "Befuddled Syndrome" thinking your invented "country of Pally'land" was anything more than a geographic area controlled by the Turk Islamists.

It was until the Treaty of Lausanne ceded the territory to Palestine and the Palestinians became citizens of Palestine.

 

[Hollie]

Chaim Weizmann
Feisal Ibn al-Hussein.

Were either of them Palestinian?

"Pal'istanian" was never a nationality.

You still suffer from "Befuddled Syndrome" thinking your invented "country of Pally'land" was anything more than a geographic area controlled by the Turk Islamists.

It was until the Treaty of Lausanne ceded the territory to Palestine and the Palestinians became citizens of Palestine.

So.... back to your invented "country of Pally'land"

What a hoot.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Chaim Weizmann
Feisal Ibn al-Hussein.

Were either of them Palestinian?

"Pal'istanian" was never a nationality.

You still suffer from "Befuddled Syndrome" thinking your invented "country of Pally'land" was anything more than a geographic area controlled by the Turk Islamists.

It was until the Treaty of Lausanne ceded the territory to Palestine and the Palestinians became citizens of Palestine.

So.... back to your invented "country of Pally'land"

What a hoot.

OK, but it was invented by treaty and international law.

 

[Indeependent]

Chaim Weizmann
Feisal Ibn al-Hussein.

Were either of them Palestinian?

"Pal'istanian" was never a nationality.

You still suffer from "Befuddled Syndrome" thinking your invented "country of Pally'land" was anything more than a geographic area controlled by the Turk Islamists.

It was until the Treaty of Lausanne ceded the territory to Palestine and the Palestinians became citizens of Palestine.

You mean the Treaty that never was.

 

[Ria_Longhorn]

Palestinesi = Palestinians. English translation is innaccurate.

"Martiri palestinesi nell’Occidente latino."

Martiri palestinesi nell’Occidente latino. I casi della Passio Theodosiae virginis (BHL 8090) e della Passio Romani monachi (BHL 7298)

Vecchio, come here (in sotto voce): Eusebius' original work was not even composed in Latin or Italian. This is the second time I'm explaining it to you. Didn't you even read your own link? Eusebius makes no mention of any "Palestinians" in the Martyrs in Palestine, but he does mention Jews in Lud. Here's Eusebius in his other work, (Praeparatio Evangelica 10.5.), were he writes of "Hebrews who inhabited the country adjacent to Phoenicia, which was itself called Phoenicia in ancient times but afterwards Judaea, and in our time, Palestine."

 

[Ria_Longhorn]

"Coming back to the Bedouins, they are as ancient as the land itself and can trace their movement in the region over generations and even back to biblical times, as they are often referenced in, or even central to, narratives of biblical myth The indigenous Palestinians are an amalgamation of all the people, civilizations, tribes, and religious groups escaping the persecution of powers that left their imprint on the landscape. However, we must maintain that the original and most ancient inhabitants of Palestine are the Canaanites, while everyone else is a historical passer-by in the land. Today’s Palestinians are not pure Canaanites, for no one can assert a purity of lineage, but at the same time this does not mean that they have no critical and sustained presence on the land to claim the ownership of it. The Bedouins of the Negev are rightfully living on their land, and the Israeli state, through its apartheid laws and policies, can’t alter this fact. For anyone desiring “peace” in the region, the starting point is the setting aside of the biblical text and the theology of dispossession, and the recognition in word and deed of the Palestinians as indigenous people of the land. Then, and only then, can we have a discussion of what can be done to solve the specific context emerging from the theology of dispossession."

The Indigenous Palestinians | Harvard International Review

Vecchio, there are genetic studies that show that the Bedouins & the "indigenous Palestinians" come from the Arabian Peninsula.

 

[P F Tinmore]

"Coming back to the Bedouins, they are as ancient as the land itself and can trace their movement in the region over generations and even back to biblical times, as they are often referenced in, or even central to, narratives of biblical myth The indigenous Palestinians are an amalgamation of all the people, civilizations, tribes, and religious groups escaping the persecution of powers that left their imprint on the landscape. However, we must maintain that the original and most ancient inhabitants of Palestine are the Canaanites, while everyone else is a historical passer-by in the land. Today’s Palestinians are not pure Canaanites, for no one can assert a purity of lineage, but at the same time this does not mean that they have no critical and sustained presence on the land to claim the ownership of it. The Bedouins of the Negev are rightfully living on their land, and the Israeli state, through its apartheid laws and policies, can’t alter this fact. For anyone desiring “peace” in the region, the starting point is the setting aside of the biblical text and the theology of dispossession, and the recognition in word and deed of the Palestinians as indigenous people of the land. Then, and only then, can we have a discussion of what can be done to solve the specific context emerging from the theology of dispossession."

The Indigenous Palestinians | Harvard International Review

Vecchio, there are genetic studies that show that the Bedouins & the "indigenous Palestinians" come from the Arabian Peninsula.

Well, that warrants a big so what.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Chaim Weizmann
Feisal Ibn al-Hussein.

Were either of them Palestinian?

"Pal'istanian" was never a nationality.

You still suffer from "Befuddled Syndrome" thinking your invented "country of Pally'land" was anything more than a geographic area controlled by the Turk Islamists.

It was until the Treaty of Lausanne ceded the territory to Palestine and the Palestinians became citizens of Palestine.

You mean the Treaty that never was.

It was the Treaty of Sevres that was never ratified. It was followed by the Treaty of Lausanne that was ratified.

You need to keep up.

 

[Hollie]

Chaim Weizmann
Feisal Ibn al-Hussein.

Were either of them Palestinian?

"Pal'istanian" was never a nationality.

You still suffer from "Befuddled Syndrome" thinking your invented "country of Pally'land" was anything more than a geographic area controlled by the Turk Islamists.

It was until the Treaty of Lausanne ceded the territory to Palestine and the Palestinians became citizens of Palestine.

You mean the Treaty that never was.

It was the Treaty of Sevres that was never ratified. It was followed by the Treaty of Lausanne that was ratified.

You need to keep up.

The treaty of Lausanne doesn't make a single reference to your invented "country of Pally'land.

Your invention of "hysterical" events is a hoot.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Were either of them Palestinian?

"Pal'istanian" was never a nationality.

You still suffer from "Befuddled Syndrome" thinking your invented "country of Pally'land" was anything more than a geographic area controlled by the Turk Islamists.

It was until the Treaty of Lausanne ceded the territory to Palestine and the Palestinians became citizens of Palestine.

You mean the Treaty that never was.

It was the Treaty of Sevres that was never ratified. It was followed by the Treaty of Lausanne that was ratified.

You need to keep up.

The treaty of Lausanne doesn't make a single reference to your invented "country of Pally'land.

Your invention of "hysterical" events is a hoot.

It didn't mention any of the new states.

You are just shoveling Israeli shit again.

 

[Hollie]

"Pal'istanian" was never a nationality.

You still suffer from "Befuddled Syndrome" thinking your invented "country of Pally'land" was anything more than a geographic area controlled by the Turk Islamists.

It was until the Treaty of Lausanne ceded the territory to Palestine and the Palestinians became citizens of Palestine.

You mean the Treaty that never was.

It was the Treaty of Sevres that was never ratified. It was followed by the Treaty of Lausanne that was ratified.

You need to keep up.

The treaty of Lausanne doesn't make a single reference to your invented "country of Pally'land.

Your invention of "hysterical" events is a hoot.

It didn't mention any of the new states.

You are just shoveling Israeli shit again.

Ahh, I see. So.... your invented "country of Pally'land" just magically appeared.... because you say so.

Is this the "hysterical" version of events that you learned at the madrassah?

 

[P F Tinmore]

It was until the Treaty of Lausanne ceded the territory to Palestine and the Palestinians became citizens of Palestine.

You mean the Treaty that never was.

It was the Treaty of Sevres that was never ratified. It was followed by the Treaty of Lausanne that was ratified.

You need to keep up.

The treaty of Lausanne doesn't make a single reference to your invented "country of Pally'land.

Your invention of "hysterical" events is a hoot.

It didn't mention any of the new states.

You are just shoveling Israeli shit again.

Ahh, I see. So.... your invented "country of Pally'land" just magically appeared.... because you say so.

Is this the "hysterical" version of events that you learned at the madrassah?

No, I get it from reading a lot of history.

Evidently you do not.