The Trump peace plan is doomed to fail

[georgephillip]

srael controls the Gaza border because Hamas has been launching terror attacks against Israeli civilian targets for decades. They built walls to keep the terrorists out and Hamas dug terror tunnels under those walls.

Hamas is a legitimate national self-defense organization fighting against an illegal 58 occupation by Israeli terrorists.

End the Zionist pursuit of Greater Israel and Hamas will have no reason to exist.

 

[georgephillip]

The Palestinians "displaced" in 1948 could have returned to Israel following the Israeli victory! The only thing that kept that from happening was their refusal to accept Israel as a sovereign nation. 150,000 Palestinian Arabs remained in Israel and became Israeli citizens. How many Jews were allowed to stay in Gaza?

Hundreds of thousands Palestinians were denied the right of return in 1949 while their homes, farms, and businesses were given to immigrant Jews from around the world.

GoogleAI Overview:

Yes, Palestinians were denied the right of return in 1949. Although the UN General Assembly's Resolution 194 (December 1948) called for refugees to return home or be compensated, Israel consistently rejected the idea of a right of return for Palestinian refugees. By 1949, Israel had also reiterated its position that the refugee problem must be solved through resettlement in other countries, not through their return to Israel.

• UN Resolution 194:
  This resolution was adopted by the UN General Assembly on December 11, 1948. It stated that refugees "wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbors should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date". It also called for compensation for those who did not return.
  
  
• Israel's position:
  Israel, even before the resolution was passed, stated its position that a return of refugees was not a solution. This was reiterated in a letter to the UN on August 2, 1949, which stated that the Palestinian refugee problem should be resolved through resettlement in other states.
  
  
• Admittance to the UN:
  While the UN General Assembly admitted Israel as a member state in May 1949, Israel's representative had previously promised that the state would honor its obligations under resolutions like 194. However, this promise was not upheld regarding the right of return.
  
  
• Impact:
  This denial, along with the dispossession of land, has led to the ongoing issue of Palestinian refugees and their descendants who continue to demand their right of return to this day.
  

• Palestinian right of return - Wikipedia
  Since the birth of the refugee problem, Israel has consistently rejected the idea that Palestinians would have any inherent "right...
  
  
  
  Wikipedia
  
  
  
  
  
  
• A Forgotten Detail: The Right of Return was a ... - Opinio Juris
  Mar 11, 2024 — When discussing the ongoing hostilities in Gaza, which many deem to be a genocide, most commentators seem to forget th...
  
  
  
  Opinio Juris
  
  
  
  
  
  
• About the Nakba - Question of Palestine - the United Nations
  As early as December 1948, the UN General Assembly called for refugee return, property restitution and compensation (resolution 19...
  
  Welcome to the United Nations
  
  
  
  
  
  
• Show all

 

[Man With A Plan]

Hundreds of thousands Palestinians were denied the right of return in 1949 while their homes, farms, and businesses were given to immigrant Jews from around the world.

GoogleAI Overview:

Yes, Palestinians were denied the right of return in 1949. Although the UN General Assembly's Resolution 194 (December 1948) called for refugees to return home or be compensated, Israel consistently rejected the idea of a right of return for Palestinian refugees. By 1949, Israel had also reiterated its position that the refugee problem must be solved through resettlement in other countries, not through their return to Israel.

• UN Resolution 194:
  This resolution was adopted by the UN General Assembly on December 11, 1948. It stated that refugees "wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbors should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date". It also called for compensation for those who did not return.
  
  
• Israel's position:
  Israel, even before the resolution was passed, stated its position that a return of refugees was not a solution. This was reiterated in a letter to the UN on August 2, 1949, which stated that the Palestinian refugee problem should be resolved through resettlement in other states.
  
  
• Admittance to the UN:
  While the UN General Assembly admitted Israel as a member state in May 1949, Israel's representative had previously promised that the state would honor its obligations under resolutions like 194. However, this promise was not upheld regarding the right of return.
  
  
• Impact:
  This denial, along with the dispossession of land, has led to the ongoing issue of Palestinian refugees and their descendants who continue to demand their right of return to this day.

• Palestinian right of return - Wikipedia
  Since the birth of the refugee problem, Israel has consistently rejected the idea that Palestinians would have any inherent "right...
  View attachment 1175944
  Wikipedia
  
  View attachment 1175942
  
  
• A Forgotten Detail: The Right of Return was a ... - Opinio Juris
  Mar 11, 2024 — When discussing the ongoing hostilities in Gaza, which many deem to be a genocide, most commentators seem to forget th...
  View attachment 1175943
  Opinio Juris
  
  View attachment 1175946
  
  
• About the Nakba - Question of Palestine - the United Nations
  As early as December 1948, the UN General Assembly called for refugee return, property restitution and compensation (resolution 19...
  
  Welcome to the United Nations
  
  View attachment 1175945
  
  
• Show all

For some reason you think the UN's opinion on Israel should count for something...

 

[Man With A Plan]

Hundreds of thousands Palestinians were denied the right of return in 1949 while their homes, farms, and businesses were given to immigrant Jews from around the world.

GoogleAI Overview:

Yes, Palestinians were denied the right of return in 1949. Although the UN General Assembly's Resolution 194 (December 1948) called for refugees to return home or be compensated, Israel consistently rejected the idea of a right of return for Palestinian refugees. By 1949, Israel had also reiterated its position that the refugee problem must be solved through resettlement in other countries, not through their return to Israel.

• UN Resolution 194:
  This resolution was adopted by the UN General Assembly on December 11, 1948. It stated that refugees "wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbors should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date". It also called for compensation for those who did not return.
  
  
• Israel's position:
  Israel, even before the resolution was passed, stated its position that a return of refugees was not a solution. This was reiterated in a letter to the UN on August 2, 1949, which stated that the Palestinian refugee problem should be resolved through resettlement in other states.
  
  
• Admittance to the UN:
  While the UN General Assembly admitted Israel as a member state in May 1949, Israel's representative had previously promised that the state would honor its obligations under resolutions like 194. However, this promise was not upheld regarding the right of return.
  
  
• Impact:
  This denial, along with the dispossession of land, has led to the ongoing issue of Palestinian refugees and their descendants who continue to demand their right of return to this day.

• Palestinian right of return - Wikipedia
  Since the birth of the refugee problem, Israel has consistently rejected the idea that Palestinians would have any inherent "right...
  View attachment 1175944
  Wikipedia
  
  View attachment 1175942
  
  
• A Forgotten Detail: The Right of Return was a ... - Opinio Juris
  Mar 11, 2024 — When discussing the ongoing hostilities in Gaza, which many deem to be a genocide, most commentators seem to forget th...
  View attachment 1175943
  Opinio Juris
  
  View attachment 1175946
  
  
• About the Nakba - Question of Palestine - the United Nations
  As early as December 1948, the UN General Assembly called for refugee return, property restitution and compensation (resolution 19...
  
  Welcome to the United Nations
  
  View attachment 1175945
  
  
• Show all

I'm curious, Georgie...is Google AI for people who need to find sources that agree with their world view whether or not that world view is completely bogus?

 

[westwall]

How many Israeli infants died on 7 October 2023?
How does that number compare to the number of Palestinian infants decapitated or burned alive since that time by the heroic Jews of Israel?

GoogleAI Overview:

"On October 7, 2023, two infants were killed in the Hamas-led attacks on Israel. This was confirmed by an Agence France-Presse (AFP) tally of minors who died in the attacks.

"The story of beheaded babies that circulated widely in the aftermath of the attacks has been debunked by journalists and investigators."

When your ham-ass heroes murdered those civilians why did you remain silent?

 

[Lisa558]

The Jews withdrew settlers and their occupation troops but maintained control of six of seven Gazan land borders, all of Gaza's airspace and coastal waters, along with Gaza's population registry; thereby, effectively occupying the Gaza Strip.

If you're still confused ask yourself who built and guards the fence around Gaza, Jews or Hamas?

And you don’t think Israel NEEDS a fence to keep the HAMAS savages from hunting down Jewish babies and cutting their heads off?

The Jews are not dealing with normal people. They are dealing with deprived Islamic terrorists.

 

[Lisa558]

When your ham-ass heroes murdered those civilians why did you remain silent?

Doesn’t fit his antisemitic narrative where Jews are bad and HAMAS savages are “a legitimate government.”

 

[JoeB131]

Pick me! Pick me! (Waves hand up….)

Because if they don’t, we get another Oct 7. And another, and another. And another.

Then they should get the hell out of Palestine.

Move somewhere that people don't want to kill them

 

[Robert W]

Then they should get the hell out of Palestine.

Move somewhere that people don't want to kill them

Your way favors the Hamas of Gaza.

 

[JoeB131]

Your way favors the Hamas of Gaza.

No, Hamas isn't the problem.

Israeli occupation of Palestine is.

Like all Colonial States, it will fall, eventually.

 

[georgephillip]

For some reason you think the UN's opinion on Israel should count for something...

Possibly because you're provided no logical reason why the UN's opinion on Israel isn't more informed than yours.

GoogleAI Overview:

"The UN has passed numerous resolutions against Israel, most notably those demanding an end to the occupation of Palestinian territory, calling for an end to settlement activity, and calling for a ceasefire and the unimpeded flow of humanitarian aid into Gaza.

"Recent resolutions, such as those from the General Assembly in September 2024 and September 2025, have demanded a 12-month withdrawal timeline and affirmed the two-state solution.

"However, the UN Security Council has seen resolutions vetoed, particularly those calling for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza as the US has used its veto power against them."

 

[georgephillip]

I'm curious, Georgie...is Google AI for people who need to find sources that agree with their world view whether or not that world view is completely bogus?

AI is for people who aren't afraid to learn about the lies and mythologies that prop up their world.

A land without a people for a people without a land - Wikipedia

GoogleAI Overview:

"Key (UN) demands in recent resolutions

• "End the occupation:
  A 2024 General Assembly resolution demanded that Israel end its 'unlawful presence' in the Occupied Palestinian Territory within 12 months.
  
  
• • "Cease settlement activity:
    Resolutions have called for Israel to immediately cease all new settlement activity and dismantle the separation wall in the West Bank.
  • "End the Gaza blockade:
    The 'unlawful blockade' on the Gaza Strip and all forms of collective punishment are demanded to be lifted.
  • "Permit humanitarian aid:
    Resolutions call for unimpeded access for humanitarian aid, including food, water, and medical supplies.
  • "Allow evacuations:
    Resolutions have called for the medical evacuation of Palestinians from Gaza and access for emergency medical teams.
  • "Support a two-state solution:
    The General Assembly has voted to urge Israel to commit to a Palestinian state as part of a two-state solution."

 

[Lisa558]

The only thing the antisemite above is proving is that the U.N. is an anti-Israel, anti-Jew body with way too much Arab influence.

In fact, all his quotes - cited or not - are just all U.N. propaganda.

Finally, we all know that the U.N. was imbedded with HAMAS terrorists who participated in the savage massacre of Oct 7. I suspect this anti-Israel propagandist is affiliated or being compensated by the U.N. or an affiliate.

 

[Man With A Plan]

Possibly because you're provided no logical reason why the UN's opinion on Israel isn't more informed than yours.

GoogleAI Overview:

"The UN has passed numerous resolutions against Israel, most notably those demanding an end to the occupation of Palestinian territory, calling for an end to settlement activity, and calling for a ceasefire and the unimpeded flow of humanitarian aid into Gaza.

"Recent resolutions, such as those from the General Assembly in September 2024 and September 2025, have demanded a 12-month withdrawal timeline and affirmed the two-state solution.

"However, the UN Security Council has seen resolutions vetoed, particularly those calling for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza as the US has used its veto power against them."

I hate to break this to you, Georgie but the UN is about as influential as Kamala Harris these days! Just saying...

 

[georgephillip]

And you don’t think Israel NEEDS a fence to keep the HAMAS savages from hunting down Jewish babies and cutting their heads off?

The Jews are not dealing with normal people. They are dealing with deprived Islamic terrorists.

Hamas never decapitated babies or burned infants alive like your heroic IDF has done with US bombs and shells over and over again during the last two years?

Many Israeli Jews are not normal people.
They believe they are "chosen."
Do you?

 

[Lisa558]

Hamas never decapitated babies or burned infants alive like your heroic IDF has done with US bombs and shells over and over again during the last two years?

Many Israeli Jews are not normal people.
They believe they are "chosen."
Do you?

Anti-Israel and Jew-hating UN propagandist ^^^ still at it. He must be being paid by the post.

 

[gipper]

Anti-Israel and Jew-hating UN propagandist ^^^ still at it. He must be being paid by the post.

Yeah because no one should oppose the Zionist apartheid regime committing genocide. The ‘chosen people’ have a God given right to mass murder and steal land.

 

[westwall]

AI is for people who aren't afraid to learn about the lies and mythologies that prop up their world.

A land without a people for a people without a land - Wikipedia

GoogleAI Overview:

"Key (UN) demands in recent resolutions

• "End the occupation:
  A 2024 General Assembly resolution demanded that Israel end its 'unlawful presence' in the Occupied Palestinian Territory within 12 months.
  
  
• • "Cease settlement activity:
    Resolutions have called for Israel to immediately cease all new settlement activity and dismantle the separation wall in the West Bank.
  • "End the Gaza blockade:
    The 'unlawful blockade' on the Gaza Strip and all forms of collective punishment are demanded to be lifted.
  • "Permit humanitarian aid:
    Resolutions call for unimpeded access for humanitarian aid, including food, water, and medical supplies.
  • "Allow evacuations:
    Resolutions have called for the medical evacuation of Palestinians from Gaza and access for emergency medical teams.
  • "Support a two-state solution:
    The General Assembly has voted to urge Israel to commit to a Palestinian state as part of a two-state solution."

AI is for mindless morons who are incapable of doing their own research.

 

[georgephillip]

AI is for mindless morons who are incapable of doing their own research.

AI is for those who want to know more today than they did yesterday.

GoogleAI Overview:

"For students

• • "Personalized learning:
    AI tailors content and pacing to individual learning styles and needs, which can lead to improved self-efficacy and a more positive attitude toward education.
    
  • "Instant feedback:
    Students receive immediate and detailed feedback on their work, helping them identify strengths and weaknesses more quickly.
    
  • "24/7 support:
    AI-powered tutors and chatbots provide round-the-clock assistance with homework and difficult concepts, allowing students to learn at their own pace.
    
  • "Enhanced engagement:
    AI can be used to create more engaging and accessible content, such as visual aids for complex topics, and through educational games and simulations.
    
  • "Improved accessibility:
    Technologies like text-to-speech, speech recognition, and real-time captioning can provide crucial support for students with disabilities."

 

[georgephillip]

Yeah because no one should oppose the Zionist apartheid regime committing genocide. The ‘chosen people’ have a God given right to mass murder and steal land.

I'm beginning to believe it is barely possible Trump will prolong the genocide in Gaza (for his own selfish ends) long enough for western media to enter the Strip; if that happens the genocide Jews in Israel and elsewhere will be facing a level of opposition they can't begin to imagine today.