Yeah, I was happier without redemption island, but I can see now how it does change the dynamics of the game when you know that a particularly disliked or favorite player can get back into the game. (I was really REALLY pulling for Christine before she finally got the final boot.)
I respect ZB's opinion that Upolu "isn't playing ethically" but I'm wondering what he sees that is any more unethical than any Suvivor tribe in power has been? Seems to me they've been up front with their intent that they intend to eliminate all the Savaii players. I look for Dawn to flip next though to buy her a little extra time and maybe a less dangerous opponent on Redemption Island. The three guys that are there now are all formidable when it comes to challenges. There's sure no guarantee that Ozzy can defeat Keith or Jim.
Where it starts getting interesting is the ethics involved when Upolu has to start voting itself off.
<sigh> Just pointing out that they claim to play with integrity yet turn around and belittle and mock the other tribe. They're hypocrites.
Hey, I'm not a "he"!
Oops and I knew that too. Sorry g/f.
And it's okay. I suppose there are those who really like Ozzy but I wasn't that impressed. Seems to me he isn't that much of a leader. And I keep comparing him to Boston Rob who I did like and who WAS a leader and who I REALLY liked to just look at. (Sorry but I don't think Ozzy is anything special to look at.

)
And I have developed an appreciation for Coach's laid back but effective leadership style too.
As far as the hypocrisy, manipulation, manuveuring, back stabbing, lies, etc. go on Survivor, I don't judge anybody there because that's the kind of game it is. It was not designed to promote a better society but rather a game of strategy that includes social interaction and a study of how the people in the game maneuver within that social structure. So I don't see Coach's team as any more arrogant than Savaii because I guarantee you Savaii would be just as 'arrogant' if they were the ones in control.
But yeah, Survivor isn't everybody's cup of tea. But I have to admit I'm still hooked. There are rumors that Jeff may leave after this season and I may not like it as well then, but we'll see. I didn't think American Idol would survive without Simon and Paula either, but it did. And soon, we may know whether America's Got Talent will survive without Piers Morgan and with Howard Stern as a host. (gag)