Should Israel withdraw to the Separation Barrier?

[toastman]

I pray Israel never tries this as it would lead to a lot of dead Jews in Israel and Europe.

Yes, Europe is very anti-Semitic.

Well, for every Arab killed by the Israelis in an attempt to commit ethnic cleansing, a Jew might die in Europe. That's not anti-Semitism, but justice.

Israel should instead just pull back to their very expensive barrier and call it a day.

Thats your form of justice? Wow, you are one seriously deranged person. Go get professional help

 

[Kondor3]

I pray Israel never tries this as it would lead to a lot of dead Jews in Israel and Europe.

Yes, Europe is very anti-Semitic.

Well, for every Arab killed by the Israelis in an attempt to commit ethnic cleansing, a Jew might die in Europe. That's not anti-Semitism, but justice.

Israel should instead just pull back to their very expensive barrier and call it a day.

Oh... my... God !!!...

 

[Sally]

Yes, Europe is very anti-Semitic.

Well, for every Arab killed by the Israelis in an attempt to commit ethnic cleansing, a Jew might die in Europe. That's not anti-Semitism, but justice.

Israel should instead just pull back to their very expensive barrier and call it a day.

Oh... my... God !!![

/U]...

This is called Palestine Mentality. It reminds me of the signs held by Muslims at protests in Europe which say "Hitler Should Have Finished the Job."

 

[SayMyName]

It's time for Israel to withdraw from all of the West Bank.

 

[Kondor3]

It's time for Israel to withdraw from all of the West Bank.

Or just kick the Palestinians out of the West Bank across the border into Jordan and fill the vacuum with fresh Israeli settlers - thereby completing the Reconquista of Eretz Yisrael.

 

[Victory67]

It's time for Israel to withdraw from all of the West Bank.

Or just kick the Palestinians out of the West Bank across the border into Jordan and fill the vacuum with fresh Israeli settlers - thereby completing the Reconquista of Eretz Yisrael.

Such a crime by Israel would lead to many dead Jews in Israel and Europe.

Why would you want so many Jews to die?

Better for Israel to just withdraw to the Seperation Barrier, which is their plan.

 

[Kondor3]

It's time for Israel to withdraw from all of the West Bank.

Or just kick the Palestinians out of the West Bank across the border into Jordan and fill the vacuum with fresh Israeli settlers - thereby completing the Reconquista of Eretz Yisrael.

Such a crime by Israel would lead to many dead Jews in Israel and Europe.

Why would you want so many Jews to die?

Better for Israel to just withdraw to the Seperation Barrier, which is their plan.

Yes.

So you have told us on numerous occasions.

You have even gone so far as to tell us who would kill those millions of Jews.

Iran.

Jordan.

Russia.

Which takes care of the "WHAT" (death of millions of Jews) and "WHO" (combatants).

You were a little shaky on the details, though, when challenged to outline the "HOW".

As well as being a little shaky about what the IDF will be doing during all of this.

You were also a little shaky about what the US and the EU and NATO would be doing, while all that was going on.

Keep working on that, Sparky.

One of these days, you'll dream up something that the grownups will require 2 minutes to shred to pieces, rather than 5-10 seconds.

Meanwhile, in your shoes, I'd avoid such asinine projections about Russia, et al.

They aren't going to do shit.

ESPECIALY on behalf of the rabid, mad-dog Palestinians, that even the Jordanians and Egyptians tend to wall-off and blockade.

 

[Victory67]

Or just kick the Palestinians out of the West Bank across the border into Jordan and fill the vacuum with fresh Israeli settlers - thereby completing the Reconquista of Eretz Yisrael.

Its very anti-Semitic for you to suggest that Israel would engage in such a criminal act of ethnic cleansing, reminiscent of the Nazi plan to deport the Jews to the "Ost".

More likely, Israel wil just withdraw to their Plan B border, aka the Seperation Barrier.

 

[Kondor3]

Or just kick the Palestinians out of the West Bank across the border into Jordan and fill the vacuum with fresh Israeli settlers - thereby completing the Reconquista of Eretz Yisrael.

Its very anti-Semitic for you to suggest that Israel would engage in such a criminal act of ethnic cleansing, reminiscent of the Nazi plan to deport the Jews to the "Ost"...

Populations get kicked out of regions all the time; including a large number of such expulsions and transfers since WWII - the Czechs expelling the ethnic Germans in the Sudentenland, the Poles expelling the ethnic Germans in East Prussia, the Russians expelling and relocating minorities in the Caucauses, the Indians expelling Muslims during the split between India and Pakistan, the Pakistanis expelling Hindus at the same time, the Vietnamese dealing with their troublesome types, the Chinese dealing with Muslims, Mongols, etc. - and, of course, over 1,000,000 Jews expelled or nudged-out of Muslim countries in the 1948-1975 timeframe...

All of those since WWII, after the creation of the UN and much relevant international law - and none of those Semitic or anti-Semitic in nature - and none of them charged or prosecuted at-law as 'ethnic cleansing'; instead, pitched, and eventually accepted by fait accompli, as dealing with chronically hostile population segments in the only practical way; removing the danger they pose, while allowing them to live.

It is the only way to complete the Reconquista, and, if and when it comes, it will be no different any any of those other expulsions and transfers listed above.

Oh, and, by the way, the analogy to the Nazi variation on the theme only holds true if the Israelis start packing the Palestinians off to extermination camps and begin gassing them and bulldozing them into the ground en masse.

Without such intent and outcomes, the analogy is dismissed, with prejudice, and rendered into a much simpler and comparatively humane (non-slaughtering) Expulsion or Transfer similar in nature to those others listed above.

"...More likely, Israel wil just withdraw to their Plan B border, aka the Seperation Barrier."

Yes. So you have already said. We heard you the first time. But repeating it does not make it any more likely to happen, the 2nd time, or the 200th time, than the 1st.

 

[Victory67]

Yes. So you have already said. We heard you the first time. But repeating it does not make it any more likely to happen, the 2nd time, or the 200th time, than the 1st.

Is Israel is more likely to withdraw to the Seperation Barrier and leave a few thousand troops in the Jordan Valley, than to engage in a Nazi-like act of mass ethnic cleansing, which would lead to thousands of dead Palestinians who would of course resist such a crime, and lead to thousands of dead Jews as retribution.

Its very anti-Semitic for you to even suggest that the Jews would do such a horrible thing. The Jews are not like the Nazis. They don't commit war crimes in such a massive scale.