A Leftists Harsh Words for the Unholy Alliance
July 12, 2013 By Matthew Vadum
It isnt often that a leftist thought leader calls out her comrades for aligning themselves with the Islamist enemies of the United States but thats exactly what Meredith Tax does in her new book.
...
These secularists that Tax writes of are those unicorns that in the West the mainstream media call moderate Muslims. We keep hearing about these people, and occasionally a few surface for TV cameras, but in most of the Ummah they have no real political power. Islam is not known for embracing pluralism. There may be some secularists in the Islamic world who struggle heroically for freedoms Americans and Europeans taken for granted, and we may admire their bravery and perseverance, but unfortunately in the end they count for little.
As the totalitarian Islamic juggernaut sweeps across Africa and Islamism becomes even more solidly entrenched in the Middle East (thanks in part to Obama administration policies), those who endorse Western-style notions of human rights are increasingly marginalized, terrorized, and liquidated by the powers that be.
Criticizing the Left
Tax chastens her fellow leftists for making common cause with Islamists out of hatred of the U.S. Over the last decade some groups on the far Left have allied with conservative Muslim organizations that stand for religious discrimination, advocate death for those they consider apostates, oppose gay rights, subordinate women, and seek to impose their views on others through violence, Tax writes.
This is happening in the current climate of increasing xenophobia, discrimination and violent attacks upon Muslims in both Europe and North America, she writes.
...
Smearing the Right
In her own words, Double Bind is about whats wrong with the Lefts approach to Islamic terrorism. It is about what happens when the Left takes up the language and framing of the Muslim Right.
But Taxs own taxonomy is troubling.
She defines the Muslim Right as a range of transnational political movements that mobilize identity politics towards the goal of a theocratic state. This means that in Taxs world, the Left is always on the side of the angels. Those who favor dictatorship, the death penalty for homosexuality, and the brutal subjugation of women including forced female genital mutilation are right-wingers.
In other words, Muslim Right is a synonym for Islamism.
...
In America it is only the Right that has carried on the battle for the rights of women and gays in Islamic countries. The Left, on the other hand, has largely been AWOL.
Nonetheless, boiled down to its essence, left-wing is good and right-wing is bad, according to Tax.
And Tax believes that leftists have to oppose all varieties of right wing politics and must stand up to demagogues who characterize every Muslim as a potential terrorist and try to whip up violence against civilians. She also claims we have a problem with white fascists in the US or UK. She doesnt name any of these alleged demagogues or fascists in the United States, probably because there arent any of note.
...
There is also no such thing as separation of religion and state in Islam. Trying to convince Muslims to embrace separation of mosque and state first requires teaching Muslims that mosque and state are in fact not the same thing and that separating them is actually possible.
...
Islamophobia
Also to her credit, Tax acknowledges that Islamists and their defenders smear their critics in an attempt to silence them. She notes that they hurl the word Islamophobia as a means of shutting down debate about the Muslim religion, whose leaders fairly uniformly reject democratic culture and the idea of separation of church and state.
Tax separates the two meanings behind the word.
...
Glenn Greenwald and Other Useful Idiots
Tax criticizes American writer Glenn Greenwald, the journalist now best known for his ties to NSA leaker Edward Snowden, for functioning as a useful idiot. Like the Islamists, Greenwald sees the wars in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Mali as anti-Muslim actions. He has written:
...
Tax believes the Islamic world is ripe for revolution and the Left can help nudge it into modernity. Its going to take a lot more than pamphlets and pickets to free Muslims from their self-imposed chains. Its going to require a sea change in thinking in the Ummah.
Good luck with that.
A Leftist?s Harsh Words for the Unholy Alliance | FrontPage Magazine