Soooooo, back on track (so to speak........). Here's a future classic, if you can afford it get one now as they're only going up in price.
Honda S2000
Arguably the best car Honda ever made.
The only really important thing to remember here is that cars are not machines in the conventional sense, there is no absolute better or worse, good or bad with them like an elevator or a pacemaker. Automobiles are as much a statement about the individual as they are about getting around, that is why there are literally 10,000 different sizes, shapes, styles, specs and colors. So the entire premise of this OP is lame brained about older cars and only speaks to one persons bias towards them as if his views were absolute. A 1940 Packard was as much a statement of the state of the art in its day on its roads then as any car today.
You like what you like, you drive what you drive and for whatever reason suits you. It is all the individual choices out there that make them so great.