Official USMB Mafia Game #2: Enter the Godfather

[AyeCantSeeYou]

dont forget the scum know who each other are and get to some plans prior to the game starting...we get a bit of a head start

This is the first comment that made me suspect her. After her Rosie push and that being successful, I dropped it. I'll go look at a few more posts. I will try to find what Shaitra is looking at without forcing a PR to be outed.

that comment also caused one of the scum to out themselves in the way responses to posts were said. i consider that a really good play on bones' part.

 

[strollingbones]

damn 3 votes.......i am a townie......i try to make sure everyone eats well....

 

[Shaitra]

Jeebus, are we up to the hammer already?

I'm about ready to follow bone's gut on this one.

There are still three scum voting, so yeah - we're getting close. That's why I didn't make my vote official. I don't want to give them the chance goad us into lynching another townie.

My gut tells me Rosie. But my gut told me Avi.

Anyway, here's something that seems a little 'off' to me, and was kind of glossed over (and frankly, it seems paranoid even to me) ... but sb counted wolf as voting for rosie before she actually did, before she even suggested she would. How would she know that?

I get nothing but townie vibes from wolf, but still, slips like this can make or break a game.

Here's something else. We know Scum can talk at night. What if Rosie told them she wasn't feeling good and would need to bow out of the game. They could have planned the whole second day lynch as a cover for both of the remaining scum. After all, SB went after Rosie hard and looked really good for finding one of the scum. But she did count Wolf's vote before Wolf made it.

 

[Shaitra]

I've gone back and read all her posts from the 13th through today. Nothing sticks out as odd. I saw where she was trying to get the players to talk about who they think should be lynched and why. I just don't see whatever it is you do.

It's nothing SB said. Look at other people's posts.

 

[strollingbones]

again i went after rosie due to her total change in posting style and her being just mean as a snake...when she is one of the most decent posters i know....that is why.....i objected to lynching avatar and tried anything to keep yall from doing it...now didnt i? i was wrong about sam....grandma was a night kill.....cant blame me for that...why? cause i am not scum

 

[strollingbones]

okay i think i have 3 votes.....

 

[Wolfsister77]

Shaitra should we look at other posts that are around bones posts in the last 48 hours or all of her posts? Can you tell us this much?

 

[strollingbones]

o hell i vote your ass has to look at them all....you cant hang me on just a few posts now can you?

 

[Mertex]

I'm racking my brain trying to get you guys the help you need to figure this out without outing a PR. We need to guard our PR's to the best our our ability. It's one reason I've backed off MeBelle. She says she's the doc and no one else has stepped forward so maybe she is. But that puts a big honking target on her back come nightfall. So let's not give scum an additional target.

SB made that slip when she used "we" back on day 2. She claims it was intentional to try and suck people out. What if it was really a slip and she tried to cover it up?

Did you or Wolfsister read my post above, where I suggested that maybe MeBelle and SB voted for Rosie on Day 1 because Rosie was so sick and wanted out? When we voted for Avatar instead, they couldn't wait, in fact SB was pushing for a fast vote and voted for
Rosie the very first day of Day 2.

That is the only thing that would make sense that Mafia would vote for one of their own. But after Rosie was lynched, she quickly went after Sameech (who turned out to be Town).

I'll go ahead and switch my vote, even though I think MeBelle is her partner, but we can deal with her later. If MeBelle really is the Doctor, Mafia would be really stupid not to take her out at night, and if she is still alive the next day, we will have our answer.

Vote:Strollingbones

 

[AyeCantSeeYou]

shaitra, the post you are referring to is not a pr role. if it is, then that person will be killed off at night before the scum go after mebelle. i believe that person was referring to the flavor role in that post, nothing more. if i remember correctly, that player has said that same thing more than once.

 

[AyeCantSeeYou]

i'm not voting for someone i feel is town.

ya'll go right ahead and be wrong again.

scum is getting a free hit from this so-called lynch.

 

[strollingbones]

uh oh 4 votes..its not looking good for me....packing a bug out back pack.....yall really have no evidence of me being mafia...you are letting a the need to lynch someone and suddenly i am the prime candidate with no real evidence? i would see mertex and wolf working together more than me and ma....i simply thing lynching a townie is a bad move....they will then kill someone over the night...what will you learn from that?

 

[Shaitra]

Shaitra should we look at other posts that are around bones posts in the last 48 hours or all of her posts? Can you tell us this much?

It's not what SB said in the past 48 hours. Look at other people's posts.

 

[strollingbones]

you have said that and yet it still doesnt make sense......no matter how many times you repeat a lie...its still a lie

 

[Wolfsister77]

Shaitra should we look at other posts that are around bones posts in the last 48 hours or all of her posts? Can you tell us this much?

It's not what SB said in the past 48 hours. Look at other people's posts.

You guys would make me do this when I feel a major sinus headache coming on.

 

[AyeCantSeeYou]

uh oh 4 votes..its not looking good for me....packing a bug out back pack.....yall really have no evidence of me being mafia...you are letting a the need to lynch someone and suddenly i am the prime candidate with no real evidence? i would see mertex and wolf working together more than me and ma....i simply thing lynching a townie is a bad move....they will then kill someone over the night...what will you learn from that?

that's what i don't get - why lynch someone that comes across as town? i'm just not seeing where bones is scum.

i'd rather have a no-lynch than have people panic and vote for someone with no reason they will post. a no-lynch would mean scum get 1 kill on town instead of 2 with town killing off one of our own.

 

[strollingbones]

we are down how many townies now? 3?

 

[strollingbones]

okay i got to go herd chickens for a while....well that wont take long but then game of thrones season finale is on......

 

[Wolfsister77]

uh oh 4 votes..its not looking good for me....packing a bug out back pack.....yall really have no evidence of me being mafia...you are letting a the need to lynch someone and suddenly i am the prime candidate with no real evidence? i would see mertex and wolf working together more than me and ma....i simply thing lynching a townie is a bad move....they will then kill someone over the night...what will you learn from that?

that's what i don't get - why lynch someone that comes across as town? i'm just not seeing where bones is scum.

i'd rather have a no-lynch than have people panic and vote for someone with no reason they will post. a no-lynch would mean scum get 1 kill on town instead of 2 with town killing off one of our own.

No one knows for sure she is town except scum. Advocating a no-lynch which would leave us right where we are now with a free mafia kill and no chance of lynching scum.........

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

scummy move right there

 

[Mertex]

Jeebus, are we up to the hammer already?

I'm about ready to follow bone's gut on this one.

There are still three scum voting, so yeah - we're getting close. That's why I didn't make my vote official. I don't want to give them the chance goad us into lynching another townie.

My gut tells me Rosie. But my gut told me Avi.

Anyway, here's something that seems a little 'off' to me, and was kind of glossed over (and frankly, it seems paranoid even to me) ... but sb counted wolf as voting for rosie before she actually did, before she even suggested she would. How would she know that?

I get nothing but townie vibes from wolf, but still, slips like this can make or break a game.

Here's something else. We know Scum can talk at night. What if Rosie told them she wasn't feeling good and would need to bow out of the game. They could have planned the whole second day lynch as a cover for both of the remaining scum. After all, SB went after Rosie hard and looked really good for finding one of the scum. But she did count Wolf's vote before Wolf made it.

I'm beginning to feel like you are totally ignoring my posts. I posted this (below) regarding their plan to let Rosie off because she was sick, and nobody has even made reference to it, except for you bringing it up as if for the first time.

Also, the comment that Mani made about SB claiming Wolf's vote before she even made it, I believe I brought that up right after it happened.....didn't anybody see my post on that? That's when Rosie got all offensive and claimed there was cheating going on....was it all a ruse to take attention away from SB's comment and just get Rosie voted off? It all sounds very plausible to me, but I never suspected Wolfsister to be one of the three....

Okay Shaitra, I had a strong hunch about Strollingbones, because she went after Rosie so vehemently, but once Rosie was found to be Scum I discarded that thought. I later suggested that maybe it was strategy but it didn't make good sense.

Could it be that because Rosie was feeling so sick that maybe she wanted out of the game so bad, why she made those accusations to force a quick vote and that's why SB was going so hard for her? I noticed that Rosie also voted for her at one time....which is one of Mafia's way of diverting suspicion away from each other as working as a team.