Official USMB Mafia Game #2: Enter the Godfather

[Mertex]

Okay Shaitra, I had a strong hunch about Strollingbones, because she went after Rosie so vehemently, but once Rosie was found to be Scum I discarded that thought. I later suggested that maybe it was strategy but it didn't make good sense.

Could it be that because Rosie was feeling so sick that maybe she wanted out of the game so bad, why she made those accusations to force a quick vote and that's why SB was going so hard for her? I noticed that Rosie also voted for her at one time....which is one of Mafia's way of diverting suspicion away from each other as working as a team.

Here are some posts that might shed some light on SB.

i got up expecting a vote ......and a lynching by now.....

my vote remains:

Vote: ropey

Why are you being this way? You've been told over and over the final vote is not due until the middle of next week.

People are saying that those who push for an early vote are likely Mafia, because
Mafia benefits most from a rush to lynch.

You must remember during the last game that Syrenn acted just like this with a major push to vote fast - and she was blue Mafia!

In the face of all the opposing evidence that is out there you are still acting the same as Syrenn did, so I am changing my vote.

Vote: Strollingbones

Regards from Rosie

We're all easy targets.

Avatars defense is that only scum would doubt him despite all the evidence used to back up why he appear suspicious. Add to that, his scum picks are solely based on those who picked him, except me. He voted to lynch me early on, on a gut feeling and it just snowballed to fit his pick.

Those who follow him around thanking him are not doing themselves any favors either.

I don't go on gut feelings because I don't get gut feelings. I've posted many times why I suspect him based on his posts alone. Not one of them being because he picked me.

Except you keep claiming all this evidence that doesn't actually exist if we analyze it, which i did a few posts up.

Trying to scare others away from defending me? Seems kind of scummy to me.

And your only evidence against me is that I'm coming after you, strongly.

I still think Avatar, Mebelle and either Manifold or Strollingbones are the Mafia....I'm leaning toward SB being the one.

I think Ropey, RD, Myself, Wolfsister, Luissa, Rosie, dblack, and Grandma are all townies.

AyeCantSeeYou sounds suspicious but maybe because she's new she's throwing out all these nonsensical clues. I'm not sure about her at this time. She sides with Avatar but it may be that he is suckering her in with his being innocent comments.

Shaitra is probably Townie, thinks Avatar is Townie because she was under his wing the last time and she believes everything he says. She is going with R.D. because Avatar went with him....Avatar knows how to sucker people in.

Here MeBelle claims she suspects Avatar, ACSY and SB, but she votes for Rosie?

Even though I believe these are the scum:

Avatar4321, AyeCantSeeYou, strollingbones

Even though I believe these are the scum:

Avatar4321, AyeCantSeeYou, strollingbones

But you're voting Rosie? That makes a lot of sense.....

That would make sense why MeBelle would vote claim she suspects SB, but ends up voting for Rosie....they wanted to help Rosie out of the game. Also, why SB jumped on the
"Mertex" bandwagon, because I have been pushing hard for MeBelle. Could be the Doctor doesn't want to play his hand just yet....we still have a lot of days left.....you may be on to something.

 

[strollingbones]

i am not scum....sorry

 

[Mertex]

This looks pretty scummy to me.

It does if you didn't read my post as to why I did it. I get the feeling that you haven't spent much time reading the posts and I can understand why, there is so much drama being thrown in, that it's hard to read each and every single word.

I was trying to help town because I believe that a no-lynch will help Mafia. At least everyone would be able to see that I am Town, and could then focus on those that keep insisting that I am Scum. Scum knows what I am, and they are going to try and convince other Townies that I am Scum. If no one gets lynched, Mafia comes in at night and snuffs one of us out and the next day you'll still be coming after me thinking I'm Scum.

But, since some of the other Townies didn't want me to commit suicide, I took my vote off myself. I voted for AyeCantSeeYou because it seem like at the last count she had 4 ....since no one was willing to vote for MeBelle, whom I think is Scum, and we don't want to be caught tomorrow with a no lynch. A wrong guess is better than a no-lynch, because it narrows the field...at least that is my opinion.

A wrong guess provides more and better information than a no lynch in most situations.
I don't find you scummy enough to vote for; I'm just not a fan of self-voting.

When Mani suggested I was Scum, and SB jumped on it followed by ACSY, I was sure that Shaitra and MeBelle would follow suit and could influence WS or you, and I would be gone, so it was more of a last attempt to get Townies to pay attention to what I had been saying. It wasn't until later when I came back and noticed that nobody else had voted that I decided to take my vote back. I guess voting for myself was not a good move on my part.

 

[Mertex]

No. I may be putting someone at risk if I reveal. My reason is in the posts, all anyone has to do is go look for it.

Can you at least say who's post? There are way too many posts to go back and read all of them.

 

[strollingbones]

yes, my posts are full of hidden meanings.....like the devinci code and all.....i want yall to search all my past posts...or just the last couple of days, eh?

 

[AyeCantSeeYou]

No. I may be putting someone at risk if I reveal. My reason is in the posts, all anyone has to do is go look for it.

Can you at least say who's post? There are way too many posts to go back and read all of them.

I second what Mertex says above (part I bolded). Please provide links to the posts. Otherwise, I'll just consider your reason as nothing more than a guess.

 

[Shaitra]

If I have something figured out correctly, to tell you who's post would out a PR. That's why I'm being so evasive about it. But it's happened in the last 48 hours.

 

[AyeCantSeeYou]

that tells me nothing. most that have been guessing have been wrong. we already know mebelle is the town doc. she told us that when she was at L-1, probably as help to all us townies in case she was lynched or taken out by mafia. some of ya'll may not believe what she said, but i do. the other pr role that was killed by mafia - grandma - upset some townies because she didn't have a chance to tell us her role and what info she had. what gets me is that the same ones that don't believe mebelle probably wouldn't have believed grandma had she been given the chance to talk.

bones hasn't put anything in her posts yet that screams out scum to me. if i'm missing something, then point me in that direction by posting a link to the post.

 

[Shaitra]

Sorry, it's not my place to out a PR. Go back and look at the roles in the first couple of posts from Wake. Grandma and MeBelle aren't the only PR's in the game.

 

[Wake]

Vote Count 4.9​

"That which can be destroyed by the truth should be."​

Not Voting (0):

Mertex (4): strollingbones♀, manifold♂, AyeCantSeeYou♀, Mebelle60♀
MeBelle60 (3): R.D.♀, Wolfsister77♀, Mertex♀
strollingbones (2): Luissa♀, Shaitra♀
AyeCantSeeYou (1): tn5421♂

~ With 10 players, it takes 6 to lynch!
~ Deadline expires 6/16/14, @ 2pm central.

1.1 | 1.2 | 1.3 | 1.4 | 1.5 | 1.6 | 1.7 | 1.8 | 1.9 | 1.10 | 1.11 | 1.12 | 1.13 | 1.14 | 1.15
2.1 | 2.2 | 2.3 | 2.4
3.1 | 3.2 | 3.3 | 3.4
4.1 | 4.2 | 4.3 | 4.4 | 4.5 | 4.6 | 4.7 | 4.8​

 

[AyeCantSeeYou]

Sorry, it's not my place to out a PR. Go back and look at the roles in the first couple of posts from Wake. Grandma and MeBelle aren't the only PR's in the game.

that, i'm aware of.

 

[Shaitra]

OK, then figure it out.

 

[Shaitra]

If you were a PR Aye, would you want someone outing you?

 

[Wolfsister77]

I trust you Shaitra as a townie. I will go look over her posts. She did make that we comment was the only thing that made me suspicious. Her strong push for Rosie cleared her. However, even if I switch, we still have to get 3 more votes over to her by 2 pm tomorrow. TN is right about a no-lynch. I'd rather guess wrong that have that. So I'll look into it.

 

[Shaitra]

I'm racking my brain trying to get you guys the help you need to figure this out without outing a PR. We need to guard our PR's to the best our our ability. It's one reason I've backed off MeBelle. She says she's the doc and no one else has stepped forward so maybe she is. But that puts a big honking target on her back come nightfall. So let's not give scum an additional target.

SB made that slip when she used "we" back on day 2. She claims it was intentional to try and suck people out. What if it was really a slip and she tried to cover it up?

 

[Shaitra]

Heck, you all can lynch me if we can't decide on a person. I agree that a no lynch only helps scum.

 

[Wolfsister77]

Vote: Strollingbones

 

[AyeCantSeeYou]

I've gone back and read all her posts from the 13th through today. Nothing sticks out as odd. I saw where she was trying to get the players to talk about who they think should be lynched and why. I just don't see whatever it is you do.

 

[Wolfsister77]

dont forget the scum know who each other are and get to some plans prior to the game starting...we get a bit of a head start

This is the first comment that made me suspect her. After her Rosie push and that being successful, I dropped it. I'll go look at a few more posts. I will try to find what Shaitra is looking at without forcing a PR to be outed.

 

[AyeCantSeeYou]

Heck, you all can lynch me if we can't decide on a person. I agree that a no lynch only helps scum.

I've already got 2 votes; no need to throw another person in the mix at this point. Voting for me would make more sense - only 4 votes needed.