Ok. Let me get this straight. The Rangers will be Pussies if they are named for anyone but Benning. The Airborne will be afraid to fly if they are stationed at a base named for anyone but Bragg right?
Bullshit. Absolute Crap. Green Berets will still be astonishing no matter what the name of the place they are trained at. SOD Delta troops will still be scary if they are trained at Fort Sweeney. In fact, Fort Sweeney would be a good name.
But traditionalists who fear any change will whip themselves into a tizzy over anything. These are the same type of people who whipped themselves into a tizzy over the change from the M-14 to the M-16.
It doesn’t matter what the base is called. It doesn’t matter what the name of the joint is. What matters is the training the troops receive. The support they get.
But oh no. We have to resist the change, any change. Nuts.
And those who object to the bases named after Confederate Generals? Did you have to look it up or did you study history to find out why the base was named after the idiot in the first place?
Shock and Awe, and various other tactics of rapid advance were all derived from the Nazi’s Blitzkrieg, or Lightning War. Combined Arms tactics, using Artillery, Aviation, and Troops in a coordinated attack is another tactic we took from Nazi’s. Should we abandon that tactic which is successful because a Nazi developed it? Or should we teach our officers where this came from and the philosophy of the attack because it is successful so when they reach higher rank they can understand what is expected of them?
It is like swearing off of movies because a Nazi shot Triumph of the Will. It was a brilliant piece of propaganda. And it is studied today along with the film maker to understand how to make shots more effective.
Sometimes, good ideas come from bad people. Sometimes good information comes from bad people. A lot of the medical advances we got during the middle of the 20th Century came from the experiments of Doctor Mengele. That information saved lives by the millions, as more information was added to the knowledge gained. He was an awful man. A horrible man who deserved to die. But we have to admit we got the knowledge from him, and we have to admit we took his knowledge and added it to our own. We built upon that knowledge in more humane methods. Sometimes More human methods were used.
The long term results of Radiation exposure. We have a large body of knowledge. Doctors know what is going to happen to you, and have you ever wondered why? The United States Navy irradiated Sailors outside of Bikini Atol by letting them stay on decks and exposing them to Radiation. We followed their cases as they exhibited the symptoms in the days, weeks, and even years later. So when you are exposed to Radiation, the Doctor knows what he can do to treat it because of the tens of thousands who suffered at the hands of the “good guys”.
Would you prefer to die because that knowledge was gained through in humane means?
Change the name doesn’t change the fact that those bases are named after people who came up with something revolutionary in war. Benning was opposed to conscription by the way. That is the drafting of people into the army. Yet he was also a racist ass. Sadly a vast majority of those of the era were. Even the “Northerners” who fought to “free the slaves” were racist asses. After all they were the ones who argued against letting Blacks join the Army and fight as equals along with the Whites afterwards.
Even during the Civil War, the Blacks could join, but only be commanded by Whites. And that was the norm through the Second World War. Nearly a hundred years of established racism.
So who do we name the bases after? White Generals from the North who were just as racist? White Admirals who only allowed Blacks to serve as Stewards? Some modern officer who became famous using the tactics of the racists from the Civil War in the modern era?