Myth of health care's free market

Luddly Neddite

Diamond Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2011
Messages
63,820
Reaction score
9,870
Points
2,040
The Myth of Health Care's Free Market - Newsweek

For weeks, politicians and writers in the opinion pages of The Wall Street Journal and other critical outlets have declared Obamacare a failure with plenty of victims. Those are silly assertions because the law only took effect this week, on the first day of 2014.

These critics are all outrage with no detailed alternatives, except the mantra that competition will magically bring down health-care costs. The libertarians at the Cato Institute argue "we need market competition more than ever. Not the mealymouthed substitutes bandied about by most health policy wonks. We need something that none of us has ever seen - real competition in a free health-care market."

No. We need something easier, simpler, and already proven to cut costs...

... More than four decades ago the Supreme Court defined a fair market as the "price at which the property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither being under any compulsion to buy or to sell and both having reasonable knowledge of relevant facts." How many of us have "reasonable knowledge" of medical procedures, costs, or even the difference between a neurologist and a nephrologist?

Is an accident victim writhing in pain, life's blood flowing out of his body, free of compulsion?...

... We don't have a free market for health-care services. If we did, we would see a narrow range of prices for the same service. After all, a Ford F-150 pickup with the same options costs about the same in Washington, West Virginia, or Wyoming. Not so hospital and medical costs, a fact brought home in the 2012 Pricing Report of the International Federation of Health Plans, a trade association for health insurance companies.

While the average U.S. hospital stay is just under $4,300 per day, one in four patients are charged $1,514 or less and one in 20 pay $12,537 or more.

The total cost for an appendectomy ranges from $8,156 for a fourth of these procedures to more than $29,426 for the most expensive 5 percent. The average cost is $13,851....

... In France the average daily cost of a hospital stay is $853; in the U.S., it's $4,287.

An MRI costs on average $335 in Britain and $363 in France, but $1,121 in the U.S.

Routine and normal childbirth costs, on average: $2,641 in Britain and $3,541 in France but in the U.S. averages $9,775. Caesarean section delivery runs $4,435 in Britain, $6,441 in France; $15,041 in the U.S.

This pattern holds for all 21 procedures examined in the report...

... Our universal single-payer health-care plan for older Americans, Medicare, has lower costs and lower overhead than the system serving those under age 65. If everyone in the U.S. was on Medicare, the savings would move the federal budget from deficit to surplus.
We're doing it wrong...
 

boedicca

Uppity Water Nymph
Joined
Feb 12, 2007
Messages
55,366
Reaction score
17,277
Points
2,250
Location
The Land of Funk
We can always count on you to come to the wrong conclusion.

Our problems are because the free market in health care was seriously impaired decades ago - we have very few remannts left (elective surgery such as lasik which has dropped in price quite dramatically). But your solution is MORE GOVERNMENT CONTROL AND INTERFERENCE, which caused the problems in the first place.
 

eflatminor

Classical Liberal
Joined
May 24, 2011
Messages
10,644
Reaction score
1,665
Points
245
You think we've had a free market in healthcare?

Oh...my...God. Are you really that fucking stupid?

We've had nothing close to a free market in healthcare or healthcare insurance for many, many decades.

Only the most ardent collectivist could look at the thousands upon thousands of laws, mandates and meddling in the healthcare markets and call that "free".

Sorry comrade...one massive fail.
 

Quantum Windbag

Gold Member
Joined
May 9, 2010
Messages
58,308
Reaction score
5,090
Points
245
... Our universal single-payer health-care plan for older Americans, Medicare, has lower costs and lower overhead than the system serving those under age 65. If everyone in the U.S. was on Medicare, the savings would move the federal budget from deficit to surplus.
We're doing it wrong...[/QUOTE]

I find myself wondering why anyone would keep posting an outright lie that has been debunked so often that only brain dead morons would post it, then I find that the OP is someone that makes brain dead morons look like Albert Einstein.
 
OP
Luddly Neddite

Luddly Neddite

Diamond Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2011
Messages
63,820
Reaction score
9,870
Points
2,040
... Our universal single-payer health-care plan for older Americans, Medicare, has lower costs and lower overhead than the system serving those under age 65. If everyone in the U.S. was on Medicare, the savings would move the federal budget from deficit to surplus.
We're doing it wrong...
I find myself wondering why anyone would keep posting an outright lie that has been debunked so often that only brain dead morons would post it, then I find that the OP is someone that makes brain dead morons look like Albert Einstein.[/QUOTE]

Posting your opinion does make it fact. Its still just an opinion.

The thread you've been studiously avoiding ...

http://www.usmessageboard.com/healthcare-insurance-govt-healthcare/333278-baby-steps.html
 

Norman

Platinum Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2010
Messages
28,082
Reaction score
10,435
Points
900
If it's cheaper let people enroll in it. Why do you need to force people into it? Why not let them have a choice?

Forcing people into some program will always increase costs, because the ones running said program can ask whatever they want sort of. Plus there will be less choice, and who wants that? Individuals have different needs regarding health care.

Of course the cheap medicare is a myth. It's cheap overhead is due to the fact that they do not count things like IRS budget and like you know it's mostly old people.
 

BobPlumb

VIP Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
600
Points
88
The solution to healthcare would be to restore the free market. LASIK eye surgery is an excellent example of how thud Fred market can work in health care.
 

Most reactions - Past 7 days

Forum List

Top