There is absolutely no connection between one's respect for those of the Jewish faith and also seeing that the establishment of the modern state called Israel was a huge mistake for everyone, especially Jewish people.
Actually, there is. Since most of 'those of the Jewish faith' see it very differently, your POV that 'establishing Israel was a huge mistake for .... Jewish people', carries with it the assumption that you know better than the vast majority of Jewish people, what is good/not good for them.
At its best, such a view is 'paternalistic': it absolutely is NOT 'respectful' in any usual sense of the word.
Well, perhaps you are used to telling your friends what's good for them - and they are used to listening to you. It hardly seems worth the effort, particularly when you endow your personal opinion with 'fact' status and give no explication whatsoever.

....Israelis playing as a Muslim against Hamas...nice try Mossad.