Just HOW BAD Is the MSM?

[Annie]

They are having problems getting the news right. From WaPo:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/05/20/AR2005052001868.html

Which is dismantled here:

http://lebop.blogspot.com/2005/05/msm-fails-again-factually-incorrect.html

There's a lot more:

Sunday, May 22, 2005
MSM Fails Again: Factually incorrect Propaganda Printed in the Washington Post

If you want to become uninformed about Lebanon, read Annia Ciezadlo's piece "Lebanon's Election: Free but Not Fair" in Sunday's Washington Post. And where is that main stream media (MSM) "safeguard" that makes it so much better than blogs?

I was originally going to post a response, but the factual errors occur in every paragraph. Enumerating them is the best way to manifest the failures.

Here are factual transgressions:

First:
"This inequality [between sects] dates back to 1943, when the French handed Lebanon over to the country's French-speaking Maronite Christian elite and founded what is called the confessional system, with parliamentary and executive offices parceled out among the major religious sects."

This "background" sentence is so filled with errors I will break it apart in pieces.

The French didn't create the confessional system. In fact, they inherited it. Why would a fiercely Republican government set up such an odd system? They didn't do it in their colonies in Martinique, Algeria, or Senegal? Why was this system created in Lebanon?

Because they did not create it. In fact, if you want to blame anyone for confessionalism, blame the Ottoman's, which forced the Maronites and Druze into agreement during the mutasarifiyya. The French went with what was the precedent on the ground because they didn't have a better system to put in place when they took over in 1920.

Second flaw in that sentence: the French handed Lebanon over? Uhhh, which French were those? The Vichy French held on to Lebanon with all their might. Remember, 1943 was a period during which France wasn't even an operative country. Were they in any position to hands things in any direct?

The Lebanese won their independence with British aid. Let us not forget good General Spears who came roaring into this country on an anti-Vichy, anti-French colonist campaign. The British general was as much a partisan for a free Lebanon as anyone else, and he had to fight for it.

Why, then, were three of our national leaders thrown into prison by the French, with the fourth escaping only because he was in the Kit Kat Club when the goons came for him?
The French threw our first Maronite President Bechara Khoury into jail. They didn't hand him a thing....