"Israeli policies don't affect anti-Semitism"

[Roudy]

You want ethnic cleansing, check the Palestinian savages. Lets hear it from the horse's mouth herself:

[ame=http://youtube.com/watch?v=4RJRSA2XtrE]92 years old palestinian women talk about Hebron massacre - YouTube[/ame]

 

[Roudy]

Ethnic Cleansing of a Bedouin Village in the Negev Desert by Israeli Forces - YouTube

Was it ethnic cleansing when Israeli forces evicted all the Jews from Gaza and handed the genocidal Palestinians their Jew free homeland?

Israeli parents thought it was stupid to use 20,000 IDF to protect 8,000 Jewish settlers amid 1 million Gazans who are for the most part refugees from Palestine.

So Jews forcibly removing other Jews from their homes that they had lived on for years wasn't "ethnic cleansing". Very interesting.

 

[Shaarona]

You want ethnic cleansing, check the Palestinian savages. Lets hear it from the horse's mouth herself:

92 years old palestinian women talk about Hebron massacre - YouTube

Hebron was an Arab town until 1500 when many Jews who had been expelled from Spain moved in without incident.

 

[toastman]

You want ethnic cleansing, check the Palestinian savages. Lets hear it from the horse's mouth herself:

92 years old palestinian women talk about Hebron massacre - YouTube

Hebron was an Arab town until 1500 when many Jews who had been expelled from Spain moved in without incident.

And ?

 

[P F Tinmore]

So...if a group uses terrorist tactics for noble means...they aren't terrorist?

Or...if they use terrorist tactics and also do "heroic" acts...they aren't terrorist?

Do you realize what a can of worms this opens up in regards to who is or isn't terrorist?

Once that group beat the crap out of a bald-head who attacked a Jewish girl.

No, that's not terrorism. Not by all means. If the police couldn't handle this Nazi, then if you ask me, it's good those men were there.

If they attack innocent ones, it is of course terrorism.

Many terrorist groups also conduct "good acts" - for example Hamas has done a great deal of charitable stuff to help Palestinians in need. Does that make them any less a terrorist group? Does mean they are open for debate?

Same with Price Tag (though I know you and I will forever disagree here ) - at what point do bad actions overrule good actions and the group becomes a terrorist group?

What then defines a terrorist group?

Anyone we do not like.

 

[Sally]

Was it ethnic cleansing when Israeli forces evicted all the Jews from Gaza and handed the genocidal Palestinians their Jew free homeland?

Israeli parents thought it was stupid to use 20,000 IDF to protect 8,000 Jewish settlers amid 1 million Gazans who are for the most part refugees from Palestine.

So Jews forcibly removing other Jews from their homes that they had lived on for years wasn't "ethnic cleansing". Very interesting.

Speaking of Gazans, that Egyptian official who told the Gazans to come back to Egypt must have known something. Betcha that an awful lot of these Gazans have Egyptian surnames.

 

[toastman]

Once that group beat the crap out of a bald-head who attacked a Jewish girl.

No, that's not terrorism. Not by all means. If the police couldn't handle this Nazi, then if you ask me, it's good those men were there.

If they attack innocent ones, it is of course terrorism.

Many terrorist groups also conduct "good acts" - for example Hamas has done a great deal of charitable stuff to help Palestinians in need. Does that make them any less a terrorist group? Does mean they are open for debate?

Same with Price Tag (though I know you and I will forever disagree here ) - at what point do bad actions overrule good actions and the group becomes a terrorist group?

What then defines a terrorist group?

Anyone we do not like.

Crock of crap.

A terrorist group is a group who's attacks don't distinguish between civilian and military targets and are perpetrated in order to create fear (hence the word TERROR in TERRORISM) for the purpose of achieving a political and or religious goal.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Many terrorist groups also conduct "good acts" - for example Hamas has done a great deal of charitable stuff to help Palestinians in need. Does that make them any less a terrorist group? Does mean they are open for debate?

Same with Price Tag (though I know you and I will forever disagree here ) - at what point do bad actions overrule good actions and the group becomes a terrorist group?

What then defines a terrorist group?

Anyone we do not like.

Crock of crap.

A terrorist group is a group who's attacks don't distinguish between civilian and military targets and are perpetrated in order to create fear (hence the word TERROR in TERRORISM) for the purpose of achieving a political and or religious goal.

My definition is more accurate.

 

[Shaarona]

Israeli parents thought it was stupid to use 20,000 IDF to protect 8,000 Jewish settlers amid 1 million Gazans who are for the most part refugees from Palestine.

So Jews forcibly removing other Jews from their homes that they had lived on for years wasn't "ethnic cleansing". Very interesting.

Speaking of Gazans, that Egyptian official who told the Gazans to come back to Egypt must have known something. Betcha that an awful lot of these Gazans have Egyptian surnames.

You are ignorant of surnames in the part of the world..

70% of Gazans weren't born there.. They were driven out of the West Bank as refugees.

The European Jews were also refugees... seeking sanctuary.. Give that some thought.

 

[Sally]

Kach was declaied illegal in Israel itself and it no longer exists, as a matter of fact. They've been out of the loop for years, now.

Kahane Chai are mostly hilltop youth, and they aren't recognized in Israel as terrorists. And they are active only in Israel.

As for the JDL, that's up for debate.

JDL is up for debate????

Seriously? If you excuse their actions as non terrorist, I am amazed.

Some of their actions are pure terrorism. Some can be viewed as heroic.

What's why I said "It's up for debate" and didn't say "They aren't terrorist".

See the dif?

Quite a while back there was a poster who was a Christian man from the New York area. He was a member of the JDL in New York, and there was a website for the JDL where all those joining made comments. Many of the new members happened to be Christians. I would imagine that they were trying to help the Jews in New York from those who would attack them.

 

[Sally]

So Jews forcibly removing other Jews from their homes that they had lived on for years wasn't "ethnic cleansing". Very interesting.

Speaking of Gazans, that Egyptian official who told the Gazans to come back to Egypt must have known something. Betcha that an awful lot of these Gazans have Egyptian surnames.

You are ignorant of surnames in the part of the world..

70% of Gazans weren't born there.. They were driven out of the West Bank as refugees.

The European Jews were also refugees... seeking sanctuary.. Give that some thought.

Tell you what, Miss Know-it-all. Go find the Egyptian official who said that the Gazans should return to Egypt and ask him why he stated that.

 

[Shaarona]

Speaking of Gazans, that Egyptian official who told the Gazans to come back to Egypt must have known something. Betcha that an awful lot of these Gazans have Egyptian surnames.

You are ignorant of surnames in the part of the world..

70% of Gazans weren't born there.. They were driven out of the West Bank as refugees.

The European Jews were also refugees... seeking sanctuary.. Give that some thought.

Tell you what, Miss Know-it-all. Go find the Egyptian official who said that the Gazans should return to Egypt and ask him why he stated that.

Name the Egyptian "official".

 

[toastman]

Anyone we do not like.

Crock of crap.

A terrorist group is a group who's attacks don't distinguish between civilian and military targets and are perpetrated in order to create fear (hence the word TERROR in TERRORISM) for the purpose of achieving a political and or religious goal.

My definition is more accurate.

What you provided isnt a definition.

 

[toastman]

You are ignorant of surnames in the part of the world..

70% of Gazans weren't born there.. They were driven out of the West Bank as refugees.

The European Jews were also refugees... seeking sanctuary.. Give that some thought.

Tell you what, Miss Know-it-all. Go find the Egyptian official who said that the Gazans should return to Egypt and ask him why he stated that.

Name the Egyptian "official".

Isn't that what she asked you to do ?

 

[Shaarona]

Tell you what, Miss Know-it-all. Go find the Egyptian official who said that the Gazans should return to Egypt and ask him why he stated that.

Name the Egyptian "official".

Isn't that what she asked you to do ?

I never heard of that Egyptian official or that statement..

Sinai an Canaan was controlled by Egypt in antiquity and Gaza was administered by Egypt for decades.

The People.. whether they are Syrian, Palestinian or Egyptian are all related thru family and share many surnames.

Was your family from Palestine or did they immigrated from Europe or Russia?

 

[Sally]

Tell you what, Miss Know-it-all. Go find the Egyptian official who said that the Gazans should return to Egypt and ask him why he stated that.

Name the Egyptian "official".

Isn't that what she asked you to do ?

I'm shocked. Miss Know-it-all throws things out, but she can't do any research on finding who the Egyptian official was. I think the official knew what he was talking about when he made that statement even though Shaarona herself would probably call him a liar.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Name the Egyptian "official".

Isn't that what she asked you to do ?

I never heard of that Egyptian official or that statement..

Sinai an Canaan was controlled by Egypt in antiquity and Gaza was administered by Egypt for decades.

The People.. whether they are Syrian, Palestinian or Egyptian are all related thru family and share many surnames.

Was your family from Palestine or did they immigrated from Europe or Russia?

US citizens are from all over the place. We are still all US citizens.

I don't see the relevance of this discussion.

 

[Shaarona]

Name the Egyptian "official".

Isn't that what she asked you to do ?

I'm shocked. Miss Know-it-all throws things out, but she can't do any research on finding who the Egyptian official was. I think the official knew what he was talking about when he made that statement even though Shaarona herself would probably call him a liar.

Just name him....

I do recall that Ghaddafi invited all Libyan Jews to return..

I remember many of them who lived in Libya until the Yom Kippur war. The women were pretty active in the arts community in Tripoli.

 

[Coyote]

Name the Egyptian "official".

Isn't that what she asked you to do ?

I'm shocked. Miss Know-it-all throws things out, but she can't do any research on finding who the Egyptian official was. I think the official knew what he was talking about when he made that statement even though Shaarona herself would probably call him a liar.

Sally. You brought up this Egyptian official.

Either source it or admit it was BS and you're flailing around trying to deflect.

It's not Shaarona's job to source your claims.

Who was it?

 

[toastman]

Name the Egyptian "official".

Isn't that what she asked you to do ?

I never heard of that Egyptian official or that statement..

Sinai an Canaan was controlled by Egypt in antiquity and Gaza was administered by Egypt for decades.

The People.. whether they are Syrian, Palestinian or Egyptian are all related thru family and share many surnames.

Was your family from Palestine or did they immigrated from Europe or Russia?

My dad was born in Poland in 1949, but moved to Israel when he was barely two years old with his brother and parents
My mother was born in Morocco and moved to Israel in her twenties with her brothers, sisters and parents.
My parents met in Haifa.