Zone1 Is the Robert Marshall near death experience True, or False?

[DennisPTate]

I believe that there is really no middle ground for the Robert and Carol Marshall near death experience case?

Obviously it is either True, or False?

I have listened to every major interview that Mr. Robert Marshall has done since his 2024 near death experience and I am off the scale impressed.

He has quoted the doctors and the nurses who worked on his astonishing case and they admit that what happened for him, was NOT their doing?

The doctors and the nurses are in shock over what happened with Mrs. Carol Marshall's husband. They are a medical team in Fort Worth Texas and they are in a position to encourage all doctors, all nurses, and all medical workers in all the earth because it is pretty obvious that their skills were used by "The Being of Light of near death experience fame" to set up an astonishing medical miracle.

I hereby challenge CBN and Pope Leo himself, to choose teams to investigate this astonishing case and do a documentary or two or three, on this because I have seen CBN do very good investigations of specific cases in the past before they will do a show.

Question:

What is the book 44 Hours In Heaven About?




This is a true story and testimony from a man named Robert, who died three times on May 19th, 2024. He explains how he died by suffocating, drowning in his blood in his lungs, acute hypoxic respiratory failure, and cardiac arrest. The result was his suffering oxygen deprivation to his brain for a total of approximately 90 minutes and about his visits to Heaven each time he died.


Each time he died, he went to Heaven. The 1st time he went to Heaven was for 15 minutes; the 2nd time was for 17 minutes; and the 3rd time was for 43 hours and 28 minutes. In the book 44 Hours in Heaven, he shares what Heaven is like, the conversations he had with Jesus, and what he learned.



The following excerpt from chapter 10 in the book "44 Hours In Heaven" contains what Jesus commanded Robert to do.


Jesus said, "You will worship Me in truth and spirit, and you will do as I command you."


Jesus then told him what He would require him to do, “You will worship Me in Truth and Spirit, and you will do as I command you.”


“In doing so, you will share how and why you were given life again."


“You will share with anybody that I put in your path and will entertain any questions about what I shared and taught you from anybody who asks.”

What is the book 44 hours in heaven abou | 44 Hours In Heaven Ministries

With only one known case worldwide, Robert's story provides the world's first living testimony of a man who died and spent 44 hours in Heaven. He was taught by Jesus about Heaven and how to understand the Bible. Robert shares his entire experience in Heaven and with Jesus.

www.44hoursinheavenministries.org

“I DIED FOR 44 HOURS & GOD ANSWERED THE MYSTERIES OF LIFE!” on the Randy Kay channel.​

439,339 views Premiered Apr 25, 2025

After dying three times for a total of 44 hours in Heaven, Robert describes Heaven in vivid detail. But what makes this episode like none other is that Robert hears answers from Jesus about some the most mysterious questions of all-time:
1. How old is the earth?
2. What happened to the dinasaurs?
3. What happened to the Garden of Eden?
4. How were different ethnicities formed?
5. Why did Jesus use parables?...and so much more!

I also wish to challenge the largest women's organization on earth that I know of. The LDS Relief Society? Mrs. Carol Marshall's prayers were responsible for what appears to me to be one of the most astonishing medical miracles since Lazarus! A huge number of Latter day Saints have became nurses or doctors or other medical professionals and the new President of the sixteen million or so Latter day Saints community want to hear an official Latter day Saint assessment of this astonishing case. Mr. Robert Marshall admits that he personally was a rather lukewarm and backslidden Christian and he gives all the credit to his wife for her prayers for him being the main reason as to why he was sent back by Jesus on a mission to everybody who will listen to him. I want to hear the assessment of Latter day Saint Sisters with a background in medicine as they discuss his case and ask Mrs. Carol Marshall how a woman can pray for her husband in a way that results in massive changes in the way that he approaches life.

 

[DennisPTate]

Here is the testimony of a physician about two cases of people flatlining for a period of time and then being pronounced dead, [and later on they manage to come back from the dead]. This is essentially the same topic but viewed from a very different angle.

He was shocked about how these people could recount details about their operations or about the room that they could not have known from their position on the operating table.





Famous Cardiac Surgeon's Stories of Near Death Experiences in Surgery

1,779,469 views Jul 27, 2011
Dr. Lloyd Rudy, a pioneer of cardiac surgery, tells stories of two patients who came back to life after being declared dead, and what they told him.

 

[DennisPTate]

Because of his truly wild healing of his brain and internal organs and his being sent back with a message for all of us, Robert Marshall writes in a powerful manner.

He has added a new article to his website on miracles. Robert Marshall is a lot like a modern Lazarus.

Question:

What is a miracle?




The scriptural definition of a miracle is an event involving God’s powerful and direct action, transcending the standard laws of nature and defying expectations of behavior. Miracles are remarkable occurrences that can only be attributed to God’s supernatural work and show His involvement in human history. In the Bible, God uses miracles to reveal His character, Himself, and His purposes to humanity through phenomena that aren’t otherwise explainable.



All the books in the world couldn’t record the miracles that Jesus Christ did. Healing the blind. Walking on water. Calming the storm. Feeding thousands with a few loaves and fish. Every miracle Jesus performed was for a purpose. He performed thousands of miracles, to shows us that God is real, God loves us and God wants to heal and restore us to abundant life.




The miracle you need most in life will lead you to what you really need most – a deeper relationship with God. Our relationship with our Heavenly Father is so important. Miracles draw us closer to Christ because they always reveal Jesus’ character. Often times, when we think about or study the miracles of Christ, we only look at the wow of the miracle, and we miss the wonder of God’s character. Luke 4:40-41 is a great example of this. The Bible speaks of Jesus’ healing in these verses. If you read the short passage quickly, your takeaway may simply be that Jesus cast out demons, but if you read deeper, you’ll see that Jesus attended to people individually. He touched each one. He made it personal. The miracles of Jesus draw us closer to Him.

...

What is a miracle | 44 Hours In Heaven

www.44hoursinheavenministries.org

 

[Mr. Friscus]

Unfortunately, one person’s perspective is tough to validate. That’s why the teachings of Mohammed are so sketchy… one guy tripping in the desert.

 

[DennisPTate]

Unfortunately, one person’s perspective is tough to validate. That’s why the teachings of Mohammed are so sketchy… one guy tripping in the desert.

True, but the fact that Robert Marshall flatlined for fifteen minutes, then for seventeen minutes, then for forty three hours and twenty eight minutes is unique. He was brain dead and his brain was without oxygen for ninety minutes. The doctors were beginning to tell Carol Marshall that there was nothing more that they could do for her husband and they admit that they were not the ones who did the miraculous recover for her husband. The doctors in his case admit that his recovery was "Miraculous" and beyond their technology.


I did read his book and it is awesome how he adds the medical updates to his case. Jesus gave him a message for his physicians that Jesus uses their talents, their training, their sincere desire to help patients, and their efforts set up Jesus to do an astonishing miracle that can be compared with Lazarus.

He donates the proceeds from his book totally to his ministry so that he and his wife can travel and do meetings for free with anybody who wants him to speak to their group.

PROFOUND NDE: BRAIN DEAD for 90 MINUTES; Met JESUS in HEAVEN & RETURNED w/ MESSAGE | Robert Marshall​

611,655 views

Oct 28, 2025 3 products

Next Level Soul Podcast tagged products below

Robert Marshall recounts his near-death experience, detailing his three-day coma and subsequent resurrection on May 17, 2017. He describes his time in heaven, where he interacted with Jesus, his father, and pets, and learned about the Bible and the new heavens and earth. Despite being brain dead for 90 minutes, he miraculously recovered with a new brain and body. His wife's determination and a living will prevented the doctors from ending life support. Robert emphasizes the miraculous nature of his recovery and his mission to share his experiences and teachings. Robert Marshall recounts his near-death experience, detailing how he died on May 19, 2024, and returned to life on May 23, 2024. He describes the disbelief and amazement of his family and friends upon his return, emphasizing the medical evidence of his death and resurrection. Robert shares the message he received from Jesus, urging doctors and nurses to trust in divine timing and their roles in performing miracles. He reflects on his transformation from an arrogant, competitive person to a kinder, more compassionate individual.Timecodes:
0:00 - Episode Teaser
2:05 – The Day Robert Died
4:30 – Out of Body Moment
7:10 – Meeting His Father in Heaven
9:25 – Colors & Music of Heaven
12:00 – Standing Before Jesus
15:10 – The Tears of Joy
18:05 – Lessons from Jesus
21:20 – Secrets of Creation
24:45 – “You Must Go Back”
28:00 – The Promise of Healing
31:40 – Waking Up From Death
34:55 – Doctor’s Shocked Reaction
38:10 – The Medical Miracle
41:30 – Why Jesus Sent Him Back
44:20 – Life After Heaven
47:00 – Faith, Purpose & Love

A lot of podcasters are wanting to interview Robert Marshall because of the extreme nature of his brush with death.


Robert Marshall, Clinically Dead, Walking with Jesus for 44 Hours – In Heaven–a Miracle of new life.

When Robert Marshall went into cardiac arrest, he was clinically dead—no heartbeat, no breath—for 44 hours. During that time, he says he was fully conscious in Heaven with Jesus. What he witnessed was beyond anything imaginable: harmonic trees, divine light, and a mission he was honored to do.

 

[DennisPTate]

Unfortunately, one person’s perspective is tough to validate. That’s why the teachings of Mohammed are so sketchy… one guy tripping in the desert.

But there is a former Muslim who says that about a century or two after the death of the Prophet Muhammad, [Shalom be upon him], there was something like a Civil War among Muslims and the winners essentially rewrote the Koran.

This are very different with near death experiencer Robert Marshall. I am now listening to this personal testimony by him for the second time right now. The consistency in the testimony of Robert Marshall is impressive.




Pt. 1 |Robert Marshall Died and Spent 44 Hours in Heaven

13,709 views Mar 15, 2025

This is the first part of an incredible story about Robert Marshall. He died in the hospital and spent 44 hours in heaven. He met his deceased father, pets and even sat by a river and talked to Jesus. This is part 1 that is more of his story of death and short heaven testimony. Part two will be in depth about what Jesus told him and more details of heaven,

Ask​

Get answers, explore topics, and more

Here is a suggestion for you to pass on.....
imagine a group of Roman Catholic Sisters and Nuns interviewing Mrs. Carol Marshall about how exactly she prayed for her husband in such a way that her husband got resurrected on a scale that could to some degree be compared with Lazarus from the Town of Bethany?


Then later on.... some Sisters and Nuns who love HORSES and dogs could interview both Mrs. Carol Marshall as well as her husband because this would make an awesome outreach to younger Roman Catholics, [but actually everybody on earth would be interested in these interviews].

 

[DennisPTate]

Here is one of the latest interviews with Robert Marshall.
Some new details are coming out about how his new voice box has abilities that he did not have before his 2024 brush with death.

44 Hours in Heaven, Part 1 with Robert Marshall​

 

[DennisPTate]

Here is a very different type of interview with near death experiencer Robert Marshall where he answers specific questions about heaven and on the events in the Bible.

44 Hours In Heaven with Robert Marshall | 01/17/2026​

Here is the song that Jesus gave to Robert Marshall in about five minutes and then in about ten minutes he was given the music to this song.

Texas Resilience by Robert Marshall​

44 Hours In Heaven Ministries

Official channel of '44 Hours In Heaven Ministries'. A global evangelistic ministry through public venues and audio/video podcasts.

www.youtube.com

 

[DennisPTate]

Here is the first part of that testimony by Robert Marshall in the same church in Houston, Texas, as in the post above. This testimony will make many doctors and nurses do a lot of thinking because this raises the question of how many people in a coma could be prayed for and could recover?

44 Hours In Heaven with Robert Marshall | 01/17/2026​

An important point here is that Jesus told Robert Marshall that it would be OK if he would give up and just go on to heaven. That is one important part of the questions and issues that the Robert Marshall near death experience puts in front of us.

 

[Vibor Blue]

Please find out if his middle name is Eon. He’s given his birthdate as 5-24-1949 on one of his interviews. Robert Eon Marshall is the only Robert Marshall that shows up as living in Texas with that birthdate. Yes, his wife’s name is Carol. There’s a reason confirmation is necessary:

Robert Eon Marshall Sentencing Press Release

https://trellis.law/doc/115008895/check-in-out-index-card-docket-sheet

Hopefully he will address this issue as this cast doubts on all of his claims.

 

[DennisPTate]

Please find out if his middle name is Eon. He’s given his birthdate as 5-24-1949 on one of his interviews. Robert Eon Marshall is the only Robert Marshall that shows up as living in Texas with that birthdate. Yes, his wife’s name is Carol. There’s a reason confirmation is necessary:

Robert Eon Marshall Sentencing Press Release

https://trellis.law/doc/115008895/check-in-out-index-card-docket-sheet

Hopefully he will address this issue as this cast doubts on all of his claims.

The Robert Marshall who had the near death experience was seventy five years old in 2024 when he had his near death experience.

This other Robert Marshall was fifty eight in 2007.

"Marshall, 58"

There even is another Robert Marshall who is also a near death experiencer.

Thank you for this interesting question. You obviously did your homework.

Robert Marshall in Texas​

There are 250 people named Robert Marshall in Texas.

Personally I am pretty sure that the first major interview with near death experiencer and Pastor Randy Kay would never have taken place if this was the Robert Marshall that you are referring to.





“I DIED FOR 44 HOURS & GOD ANSWERED THE MYSTERIES OF LIFE!” on the Randy Kay channel.

474,580 views Premiered Apr 25, 2025

After dying three times for a total of 44 hours in Heaven, Robert describes Heaven in vivid detail. But what makes this episode like none other is that Robert hears answers from Jesus about some the most mysterious questions of all-time:1. How old is the earth?2. What happened to the dinasaurs?3. What happened to the Garden of Eden?4. How were different ethnicities formed?5. Why did Jesus use parables?...and so much more!

 

[Vibor Blue]

@ DennisPTate

Thanks for getting back with me. So, Robert Eon Marshall and Robert Marshall are the same age. Same birthday 5-24-1949. They both have wives named Carol. I’m not confusing him with another NDE experiencer. I’m wanting you and others to be aware that we are probably being deceived by him.

There are even more similarities in case you need them: Robert Eon Marshall and Robert Marshall both enjoy playing golf, both also served in the military, and both also live in Lipan Texas. Walks like a duck and quacks like a duck. Yes, I believe they are one and the same person. I just don’t have 100% proof. All I have is a feeling of betrayal and the hope that everyone’s love for Christ will help heal them if the deception I suspect is true.

 

[DennisPTate]

@ DennisPTate

Thanks for getting back with me. So, Robert Eon Marshall and Robert Marshall are the same age. Same birthday 5-24-1949. They both have wives named Carol. I’m not confusing him with another NDE experiencer. I’m wanting you and others to be aware that we are probably being deceived by him.

There are even more similarities in case you need them: Robert Eon Marshall and Robert Marshall both enjoy playing golf, both also served in the military, and both also live in Lipan Texas. Walks like a duck and quacks like a duck. Yes, I believe they are one and the same person. I just don’t have 100% proof. All I have is a feeling of betrayal and the hope that everyone’s love for Christ will help heal them if the deception I suspect is true.

I gave your question a lot of thought yesterday evening. I remember from Robert and Carol Marshall's book that they actually decided to drive for forty five minutes to get to the big hospital in Fort Worth, Texas, because they knew that what was happening with him was not something that could be addressed at a "stand alone hospital."

I believe that near death experiencer Robert Marshall CANNOT be the Robert Eon Marshall who has a residence in Fort Worth, Texas, because once you drive for forty five minutes from that big hospital in Fort Worth, you are no longer in Fort Worth, you are in another town or city in Texas.
Carol Marshall, [who has been involved in the medical industry somehow for decades], writes about driving that forty five minutes over and over again while her husband was still in Intensive Care. The Robert Marshall who had the near death experience is a veteran of Viet Nam which gives you quite a bit more information to work with.

Now that I have read your message over again you have given me something else to look at. Thank you for that specific detail of "Lipan, Texas." That is certainly an interesting detail. Thank you for doing your research. My impression from the interviews so far is that when Robert Marshall gave his birthday as May 24, he may have been referring to when he was "resurrected?" I will have to listen to these interviews again.

If your theory is correct that near death experiencer Robert Marshall could really be the "bad boy" that you found in your research, then I would have to say that that would have to be perhaps one of the most extreme examples of Jesus, in His resurrected body, deliberately offending all of us, perhaps to give himself a loophole, for later on when we are judged?????


In a way I believe that the questions that were asked by the Apostle Paul in 2 Corinthians 12: 1 - 5 were addressed two or three years later, in Romans chapters nine, ten and eleven.


The Apostle Paul sounds rather astonished by what he was shown, which is very much in line, with what near death experiencers do report feeling after their NDE.

1It is doubtless not profitable for me to boast. I will come to visions and revelations of the Lord: 2I know a man in Christ who fourteen years ago—whether in the body I do not know, or whether out of the body I do not know, God knows—such a one was caught up to the third heaven. 3And I know such a man—whether in the body or out of the body I do not know, God knows— 4how he was caught up into Paradise and heard inexpressible words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter. 5Of such a one I will boast; yet of myself I will not boast, except in my infirmities. 6For though I might desire to boast, I will not be a fool; for I will speak the truth. But I refrain, lest anyone should think of me above what he sees me to be or hears from me.

II Corinthians 12 | NKJV Bible | YouVersion

The Vision of ParadiseIt is doubtless not profitable for me to boast. I will come to #Acts 16:9; 18:9; 22:17, 18; 23:11; 26:13–15; 27:23visions and #Acts 9:3–6; 1 Cor. 14:6; 2 Cor. 12:7; (

www.bible.com

Romans 11 does hint that sometimes Messiah Yeshua - Jesus in His resurrected body will give people an excuse to disbelieve, even in genuine miracles.

For God has committed them all to disobedience, that He might have mercy on all.
33Oh, the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are His judgments and His ways past finding out!
34“For who has known the mind of the Lord?
Or who has become His counselor?”
35“Or who has first given to Him
And it shall be repaid to him?”
36For of Him and through Him and to Him are all things, to whom be glory forever. Amen.

Romans 11 | NKJV Bible | YouVersion

Israel’s Rejection Not TotalI say then, #Ps. 94:14; Jer. 46:28has God cast away His people? # Sam. 12:22; Jer. 31:37Certainly not! For # Cor. 11:22; Phil. 3:5I also am an Israelite, of the seed

www.bible.com

 

[Vibor Blue]

@ DennisPTate

My initial reaction was one of denial. I thought, isn’t it just like God to use a man who was a scammer and former convict to finally bring modern clarity to the scriptures. I have prayed for that kind of clarity. Mostly due to mistranslated words, words with multiple meanings, and of course long forgotten euphemisms that no one remembers. So I was hoping that was one of the reasons Robert Marshall was sent back. The other, to show us the glory of God and that with Him all things are possible.

I tried to keep my optimism, but something would not let this rest with me. Like you, I had read the book and watched as many videos on YouTube as I could find. It was my curiosity about his military service that led me to government search engines which is where I discovered some of the information I mentioned previously. Then there was his appearance at VCC Houston. The one where he was being untruthful about NOT having a cold.

He brought it up within the first few minutes of the VCC event that he DIDN’T have a cold. He said something along the lines that he cries a lot during the testimony and that the tears turn into snot, etc. He does cry a lot, I agree. Realistically though, he had a cold, he was coughing. It was even more evident he still had a cold when he did the event at the Church of Glad Tidings. By then he was taking cough drops through the whole show.

So what am I leading to? I felt the reason he told everyone that he didn’t have a cold was due to the fear people would start walking out and the second night would be cancelled —EVERYONE remembers COVID. Personally I felt he was lying and this only gestated the doubt I had growing inside me. If he was lying about a cold to keep the event going, could he be lying about other things?

So then I began poking more holes at his story and his music (I tested 2 songs with AI detection software and they tested in the 80’s and 90’s for the probability of AI assistance). I also noticed that it wasn’t until the VCC event in January of 2026 that I had never heard him mention that he had liver cancer instead of throat cancer. This is something he would have known by the end of 2024 yet he doesn’t mention it until 2026 to the best of my very fallible memory.

Prior to November of 2025 (and possibly as late as 2026) there was no mention of him witnessing the actual main Biblical events of the Bible. Previously it had always been that Jesus had told him about things, but not that he, Robert Marshall, had traveled through time witnessing the creation of the earth, the crucifixion, and the New Heaven and Earth after the millennial reign. Why wasn’t this mentioned in the original testimony? Simply Incredible. How could you leave that out?

Finally, the last thing I discovered was the discrepancy in the age of the earth as told to him by Jesus:

13.3 billion years 53:20 timestamp:


3.6 billion years old 1:00:09 timestamp:


He also claims that Jesus gave him a perfect brain with 100% recall and that Jesus sent a spirit to assist him and to speak through him or something along those lines. Nothing as elaborate as that had been told in the previous interviews. That part seemed really confusing to me.

Robert said the spirit is the same spirit that resurrected Jesus? I thought at first he was talking about the Holy Spirit, but the Holy Spirit was sent to us all during Pentecost. Regardless he should not be able to make such a mistake. If his own total recall fails him, the spirit would speak through him to keep him from giving out an incorrect date. That’s my understanding of why Robert Marshall has said the spirit was sent to assist him.

I doubt Robert will ever address any of the things that I’ve discussed here. Use your own discernment. Test him. That’s what we are told to do. Currently he is failing the test in my opinion. Though there are still a lot of things that need answered. Especially motivation.

Why would a 76 year old man do something like this? I can only speculate without any facts. If he is indeed Robert Eon Marshall, he could have a ton of debt due in part to the gambling website and credit card fraud he was ordered to pay back. He was released in 2015 from Federal Prison and the only amount of debt made public was close to 1 million dollars, he could have owed much more.

Money, however, is the main motivation for most of the evil that occurs in the world. He makes roughly twenty dollars per ebook sold. Probably $12 to $15 per hard copy. He has to pay web server fees for hosting, legal fees, and of course a fee for the cds. Everything is mostly digital downloads though. He has his 501(c) umbrella. All proceeds are supposedly only used for travel expenses, but we don’t know how many events he goes to etc. Without transparency we don’t know how much he is making and how much he is spending. He could easily be making a million dollars a year yet only spending 200,000. That kind of thing. Fame is a slight possibility as well. The scary part is that Carol would also have to be complicit in some of this as she was a witness to the healing of his trachea and throat, as well as how long he was clinically dead. Without anyone else coming forward we have no idea about any of the story. This could all, unfortunately, be a very elaborate con.

 

[DennisPTate]

@ DennisPTate

My initial reaction was one of denial. I thought, isn’t it just like God to use a man who was a scammer and former convict to finally bring modern clarity to the scriptures. I have prayed for that kind of clarity. Mostly due to Mistranslated words, words with multiple meanings, and of course long forgotten euphemisms that no one remembers. So I was hoping that was one of the reasons Robert Marshall was sent back. The other, to show us the glory of God and that with Him all things are possible.

I tried to keep my optimism, but something would not let this rest with me. Like you, I had read the book and watched as many videos on YouTube as I could find. It was my curiosity about his military service that led me to government search engines which is where I discovered some of the information I mentioned previously. Then there was his appearance at VCC Houston. The one where he was being untruthful about NOT having a cold.

He brought it up within the first few minutes of the VCC event that he DIDN’T have a cold. He said something along the lines that he cries a lot during the testimony and that the tears turn into snot, etc. He does cry a lot, I agree. Realistically though, he had a cold, he was coughing. It was even more evident he still had a cold when he did the event at the Church of Glad Tidings. By then he was taking cough drops through the whole show.

So what am I leading to? I felt the reason he told everyone that he didn’t have a cold was due to the fear people would start walking out and the second night would be cancelled —EVERYONE remembers COVID. Personally I felt he was lying and this only gestated the doubt I had growing inside me. If he was lying about a cold to keep the event going, could he be lying about other things?

So then I began poking more holes at his story and his music (I tested 2 songs with AI detection software and they tested in the 80’s and 90’s for the probability of AI assistance). I also noticed that it wasn’t until the VCC event in January of 2026 that I had never heard him mention that he had liver cancer instead of throat cancer. This is something he would have known by the end of 2024 yet he doesn’t mention it until 2026 to the best of my very fallible memory.

Prior to November of 2025 (and possibly as late as 2026) there was no mention of him witnessing the actual main Biblical events of the Bible. Previously it had always been that Jesus had told him about things, but not that he, Robert Marshall, had traveled through time witnessing the creation of the earth, the crucifixion, and the New Heaven and Earth after the millennial reign. Why wasn’t this mentioned in the original testimony? Simply Incredible. How could you leave that out?

Finally, the last thing I discovered was the discrepancy in the age of the earth as told to him by Jesus:

13.3 billion years 53:20 timestamp:


3.6 billion years old 1:00:09 timestamp:


He also claims that Jesus gave him a perfect brain with 100% recall and that Jesus sent a spirit to assist him and to speak through him or something along those lines. That part seemed really confusing to me.

Robert said the spirit is the same spirit that resurrected Jesus? I thought at first he was talking about the Holy Spirit, but the Holy Spirit was sent to us all during Pentecost. Regardless he should not be able to make such a mistake. If his own total recall fails him, the spirit would speak through him to keep him from giving out an incorrect date. That’s my understanding of why Robert Marshall has said the spirit was sent to assist him. I doubt Robert will ever address any of the things that I’ve discussed here. Use your own discernment. Test him. That’s what we are told to do. Currently he is failing the test in my opinion. Though there are still a lot of things that need answered. Especially motivation.

Why would a 76 year old man do something like this? I can only speculate without any facts. If he is indeed Robert Eon Marshall, he could have a ton of debt due in part to the gambling website fraud and credit card claims he’s been ordered to pay back. He was released in 2015 from Federal Prison and the only amount of debt made public was close to 1 million dollars.

Money, however, is the main motivation for most of the evil that occurs in the world. He makes roughly twenty dollars per ebook sold. Probably $12 to $15 per hard copy. He has to pay web server fees for hosting, legal fees, and of course a fee for the cds. Everything is mostly digital downloads though. He has his 501(c) umbrella. All proceeds are supposedly only used for travel expenses, but we don’t know how many events he goes to etc. Without transparency we don’t know how much he is making and how much he is spending. He could easily be making a million dollars a year yet only spending 200,000. That kind of thing. Fame is slight possibility as well. The scary part is that Carol would also have to be complicit in some of this as she was a witness to the healing of his trachea and throat, as well as how long he was clinically dead. Without anyone else coming forward we have no idea about any of the story. This could all, unfortunately, be a very elaborate con.

I am glad that you are digging into this just as I did. I am truly hopeful that Robert Marshall's flaws from his past, [whatever they may be], set him up to be one of those extreme transformation testimonies.

I am truly hopeful that even if he is the guy that you refer to that Jesus, in His astonishing sense of humour, has hit all of us with a story that will shock us, much as the hair style of Pastor Todd White did a couple of decades ago.

For you see your calling, brethren, that not many wise according to the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble, are called. 27But God has chosen the foolish things of the world to put to shame the wise, and God has chosen the weak things of the world to put to shame the things which are mighty; 28and the base things of the world and the things which are despised God has chosen, and the things which are not, to bring to nothing the things that are, 29that no flesh should glory in His presence. 30But of Him you are in Christ Jesus, who became for us wisdom from God—and righteousness and sanctification and redemption— 31that, as it is written, “He who glories, let him glory in the Lord.”

I Corinthians 1 | NKJV Bible | YouVersion

GreetingPaul, #Rom. 1:1called to be an apostle of Jesus Christ # Cor. 1:1through the will of God, and #Acts 18:17Sosthenes our brother,To the church of God which is at Corinth, to those who #(Acts 15

www.bible.com

There is actually a significant secondary reason as to why the Heavenly Father calls the people that none of us would want to see God working with.

By calling people that nobody would want God to call, [such as the somewhat valid saying "can anything good come out of Nazareth?"..... it is possible that our Creator is giving Himself a loophole, to perhaps have mercy on us later on? The calling of the Apostle Paul is also one of the most extreme examples of God calling somebody that the group who they are sent to, don't want them of all people!

That is one of the only ways that I can understand Romans 11 verse thirty two?

For God has committed them all to disobedience, that He might have mercy on all.
33Oh, the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are His judgments and His ways past finding out!
34“For who has known the mind of the Lord?
Or who has become His counselor?”
35“Or who has first given to Him
And it shall be repaid to him?”
36For of Him and through Him and to Him are all things, to whom be glory forever. Amen.
[Romans 11]

Romans 11 | NKJV Bible | YouVersion

Israel’s Rejection Not TotalI say then, #Ps. 94:14; Jer. 46:28has God cast away His people? # Sam. 12:22; Jer. 31:37Certainly not! For # Cor. 11:22; Phil. 3:5I also am an Israelite, of the seed

www.bible.com

The medical updates to the Robert Marshall case are impressive to say the least. No matter what his sins of the past may be, they do not negate the power of his shocking situation. His doctors would have tended to doubt that he could be healed and sent back, and his ability to talk and talk and talk and talk for hour after hour at seventy six years of age can be taken as inspirational by any of us as we get older.

"Upon entering the emergency room, the admission staff quickly observed the medical emergency: I was having difficulty breathing. I was immediately escorted to the care area of the ER and met with a member of the medical team who performed the perfunctory vital signs and symptom identification.


The hospital staff responded to my symptoms and ordered a new CT scan and a broader, all- encompassing blood test. The results showed I had “unstable/abnormal vital signs and life-threatening conditions,” as described in my medical record. I was at risk of my airway being blocked by the mass indicated on the CT scan and I needed emergency intubation with ventilator support. They moved me to a surgical suite, inserted the oral intubation tube, and admitted me to the ICU immediately."

Emergency Room Medical Note:

IMPRESSION:

Increased inflammatory change in the deep left neck soft tissues with worsening swelling of the epiglottis and moderate to severe airway narrowing. Additional inflammatory change involving the left submandibular fossa and submandibular gland as well as the left anterior belly of the digastric. Findings suggest worsening infectious pharyngitis/tonsillitis/epiglottitis. No drainable collection.


Left glossotonsillar sulcus fullness persists. Although superimposed infection is likely, evaluation for an underlying malignancy should be pursued. Direct visualization and tissue sampling may be warranted by ENT. Follow-up CT neck with contrast in one to 3 months is recommended to confirm resolution.

No cervical lymphadenopathy by size criteria.

Incidental severe spinal canal narrowing C5-6 due to ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament.

For the next two days, I rested comfortably, my body fighting the infection with the help of IV antibiotics, and the intubation tube that kept the mass away from my airway.

[Robert and Carol Marshall, Forty Four Hours in Heaven," page 13]

What is the book 44 hours in heaven abou | 44 Hours In Heaven Ministries

With only one known case worldwide, Robert's story provides the world's first living testimony of a man who died and spent 44 hours in Heaven. He was taught by Jesus about Heaven and how to understand the Bible. Robert shares his entire experience in Heaven and with Jesus.

www.44hoursinheavenministries.org

Vibor Blue.. if you were to ask some of your family or friends to assist you to make a documentary about this unusual case, you might just be able to bring this case in front of people who need to hear and read about this, [even if it is not for the most obvious reasons]. If your worst fears turn out to be true.... then maybe the Robert Marshall case will be an effective tool for prison ministries?

In my sixty six years Jesus has surprised and astonished me over and over and over again.

The Pastor Todd White testimony on youtube helped our daughter to repent and give her life to Jesus.

You were correct that Robert Marshall says that the earth was about 13.3 billion years old in that video, [which is different from the 3.6 billion years that he gives in all other interviews]. I personally am not looking for a perfect witness of a miracle, even Cephas - Peter, James, John and Paul were all imperfect witnesses, who noticed somewhat different details due to their looking at what they saw from a somewhat different angle.

 

[Vibor Blue]

With Christ all things are possible. We are all sinners. Robert might truly believe his encounter was real. Only God can reveal to us if it was. However, Robert is in a very dangerous predicament as he is wandering into the realm of prophecy and I’m not referring to the term as a teacher. We have enough disinformation in our modern society. We don’t need any more. Everyone, please be careful.

 

[DennisPTate]

With Christ all things are possible. We are all sinners. Robert might truly believe his encounter was real. Only God can reveal to us if it was. However, Robert is in a very dangerous predicament as he is wandering into the realm of prophecy and I’m not referring to the term as a teacher. We have enough disinformation in our modern society. We don’t need any more. Everyone, please be careful.

But, what if you had flatlined for fifteen minutes, then for seventeen minutes and then been mentored directly by Jesus for forty three hours and twenty eight minutes? Would you conclude that you should be rather quiet and hide this allegorical "candle" under something?

Robert Marshall was as good as dead according to his doctors and nurses. His speaking to audiences with such energy and enthusiasm, should be encouraging to us, [even if he was a very bad boy in the past]?

“You are the light of the world. A city that is set on a hill cannot be hidden. 15Nor do they light a lamp and put it under a basket, but on a lampstand, and it gives light to all who are in the house. 16Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works and glorify your Father in heaven.

Matthew 5 | NKJV Bible | YouVersion

The BeatitudesAnd seeing the multitudes, #Matt. 14:23; 15:29; 17:1; Mark 3:13; Luke 6:17; 9:28; John 6:3, 15He went up on a mountain, and when He was seated His disciples came to Him. Then He opened H

www.bible.com

Robert Marshall, is some sort of a "light" and a vastly better "light" than what he was doing before he flatlined three times.

 

[Vibor Blue]

@ DennisPTate

I am glad you are still optimistic. I can get brought down by some of this. I have enjoyed our conversations and I apologize for being a Debbie Downer. I don’t hate the guy.

 

[DennisPTate]

@ DennisPTate

I am glad you are still optimistic. I can get brought down by some of this. I have enjoyed our conversations and I apologize for being a Debbie Downer. I don’t hate the guy.

In my opinion you did really good to dig all of this up. For example I listened to near death experiencer and former ATheist Rabbi Alon Anava a lot as well. Only over the past year or so, was Rabbi Alon Anava fully freed to release certain details about his own past that would tend to be extremely offensive to many people. I actually found his very flawed past encouraging. Rabbi Alon Anava had to wait until the Statutes of Limitations had ran out before he could give certain details relevant to his shocking transformation after his 2001 brush with death.

www.AlonAnava.com/



Rabbi Alon Anava's wife feels that her husband's transformation in how he thought and behaved was an even greater miracle than his brush with death, in many important ways.

When I hear the NDE testimony of Rabbi Alon Anava I am reminded of Matthew chapter four. When I listen to his teachings since his seven minute brush with death I am hearing the basics of Judaism, similar to Matthew chapters five, six and seven, in so many ways.

You are correct that God loves to use very flawed people to shock us and make us think. I believe that Rabbi Alon Anava has a calling in life somewhat like the historical Bar Abbas or Barabbas who was released when Rabbi Yeshua - Jesus was crucified.

Rabbi Alon Anava is live!​

 

[Vibor Blue]

I will watch it when I get a chance. Thank you also for not being rude and maintaining an open mind. If I am wrong about any of the things I have said regarding Robert Marshall I apologize in advance and ask God for forgiveness. I just want the truth and the proof. Unfortunately I might not get either one.