Is it time to start assuming everything on the internet is a lie?

[Blues Man]

now whos talking in circles,,

I expect you fell flat on your ass after that spin,,

What is the definition of murder?

Please link to any source you want.

 

[progressive hunter]

You are basing that on the laws of this country.

Some killings were defined as murder and made illegal long before this country existed.

so again you admit murder existed first and then laws were made against it,,

if I could only get you to read your own words,,

 

[Blues Man]

This is the definition or murder I am using

Definition of MURDER

the crime of unlawfully and unjustifiably killing a person; specifically, law : such a crime committed under circumstances defined by statute; something very difficult or dangerous; something outrageous or blameworthy… See the full definition

www.merriam-webster.com

1
: the crime of unlawfully and unjustifiably killing a person

Do you think it is possible to commit an unlawful act BEFORE that act was made UNLAWFUL?

 

[progressive hunter]

What is the definition of murder?

Please link to any source you want.

are you going to explain why make something illegal that had never happened in the history of man??

 

[Blues Man]

are you going to explain why make something illegal that had never happened in the history of man??

Killing has always existed before there were any laws against it.

 

[progressive hunter]

This is the definition or murder I am using

Definition of MURDER

the crime of unlawfully and unjustifiably killing a person; specifically, law : such a crime committed under circumstances defined by statute; something very difficult or dangerous; something outrageous or blameworthy… See the full definition

www.merriam-webster.com

1
: the crime of unlawfully and unjustifiably killing a person

Do you think it is possible to commit an unlawful act BEFORE that act was made UNLAWFUL?

I am not talking about whats unlawful,,

I am talking about tha act of murder that is the unjustified killing of another person with malice and intent,,'


all the illegal part is for is if you want to punish someone for it,,

 

[progressive hunter]

Killing has always existed before there were any laws against it.

as you said,, some killings were defined as murder and then made illegal,,

so that means murder exited before it was made illegal,,

 

[Blues Man]

as you said,, some killings were defined as murder and then made illegal,,

so that means murder exited before it was made illegal,,

and BEFORE they were defined as murder they were not UNLAWFUL

yes or no?

 

[progressive hunter]

and BEFORE they were defined as murder they were not UNLAWFUL

yes or no?

but they were still murder just as you said,,

 

[Blues Man]

but they were still murder just as you said,,

No there wasn't because murder is UNLAWFUL.

if the act of killing is not defined as UNLAWFUL then that act is not murder.

therefore murder as I defined in the link I provided did not exist before a particular act of killing was made UNLAWFUL.

 

[progressive hunter]

No there wasn't because murder is UNLAWFUL.

if the act of killing is not defined as UNLAWFUL then that act is not murder.

therefore murder as I defined in the link I provided did not exist before a particular act of killing was made UNLAWFUL.

laws are made as a deterent or for punishment of something that exists,,

so as you said for murder was defined and then made illegal,,

before it was unlawful you just didnt get punished for it,, at least by the government,, the family if the person you murdered might have something to say about it,,

 

[Blues Man]

laws are made as a deterent or for punishment of something that exists,,

so as you said for murder was defined and then made illegal,,

before it was unlawful you just didnt get punished for it,, at least by the government,, the family if the person you murdered might have something to say about it,,

And the law against murder was made to deter the act of killing.

DUH

 

[progressive hunter]

And the law against murder was made to deter the act of killing.

DUH

only the killings done with intent and malice that were unjustified,,

self defense killing is still legal,, and accidental killings are reviewed by the legal system to determin if they had elements of neglegence in them that would make it manslaughter,,
all that is dependent on the jurisdiction of course,,

but you had it right when you said murder was defined and then made illegal,,

 

[Crepitus]

youre the poster child for whats a lie on the internet,,

YOu're a brainwashing victim.

 

[progressive hunter]

YOu're a brainwashing victim.

yes I am a victim of attempted brainwashing,, but unlike you I survived with my mind in tact,,

 

[Crepitus]

yes I am a victim of attempted brainwashing,, but unlike you I survived with my mind in tact,,

I know that's what they tell you when you're done with each session.

 

[sartre play]

THIS IS AN INSANE SITE, & many times when I come here I get caught up in the insanity.
and yes its fun to not even try to be rational.
And no its not wise or healthy.