How the $1,000-per-baby ‘Trump accounts’ would work and who would benefit most

shockedcanadian

Diamond Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2012
Messages
43,912
Reaction score
42,957
Points
3,605
I think this is a great idea. America is more capitalist than other Western nations but you also have reasonable social programs. I don't hear enough speaking about this. $1000 account for a newborn and it is invested in the Stock Market, I presume an index fund so that as the stock market does well, so does this investments.

This would be worth thousands by the time a child reaches adulthood and it ensures that everyone has a stake in capitalism, while also ensuring all kids get a chance in life regardless of their socio-economic start.

This crushed anything Canada or offers their citizens when they have children.


On the face of it, the so-called “Trump accounts” — which would provide parents of newborns with $1,000 to invest on behalf of their child’s future — would be a plus for many families.

“It’s a pro-family initiative that will help millions of Americans harness the strength of our economy to lift up the next generation, and they’ll really be getting a big jump on life,” President Donald Trump said Monday at a White House event.



The five-year pilot program, which is included in the House-passed budget bill — also known as the “One Big Beautiful Bill Act,” now under consideration in the Senate — could give a financial leg up to a new generation to build savings for their education and beyond.

While the proposal has its merits, it may not do as much as it could to help the tens of millions of families who will struggle to save for their children.

“This proposal meets some, but not all, of the best practices recommended by decades of research on early wealth-building programs,” said Madeline Brown, a senior policy associate at the Urban Institute, a Washington, DC-based think tank.


Here is a look at how the program would work and who is likely to benefit most.
 
I still think that all welfare, or this $1000 per child award, should be tied to the parents being drug tested first.
In theory I disagree. As I understand it this endowment is exclusively for the child. It is locked in (and growing at the rate of the market) until they become adults, the money isn't for the parent.

Why should a child be punished for the sins of their parents?

You are America man, don't become like Canada please. Everyone should be free to pursue their dreams.
 
In theory I disagree. As I understand it this endowment is exclusively for the child. It is locked in (and growing at the rate of the market) until they become adults, the money isn't for the parent.

Why should a child be punished for the sins of their parents?

You are America man, don't become like Canada please. Everyone should be free to pursue their dreams.
You're a fool if you think money intended for a kid won't be spent by its addicted mother.
 
You're a fool if you think money intended for a kid won't be spent by its addicted mother.
Once a child becomes an adult they can choose to do as they please. You are expecting quite alot for a mother to be strung out for 18-21 years or whenever you deem that person an adult (assuming they were addicts at a childs birth).

You could say the same of anything right? That is how Canada works, I know, they interfered with my grandfathers Will to deny me money.

Don't become like Canada. What an adult wants to do with their money is their business. If a crime is committed, than address it. Freedom is everything, especially in the pursuit of happiness, economic freedom and employment opportunity.
 
I think this is a great idea. America is more capitalist than other Western nations but you also have reasonable social programs. I don't hear enough speaking about this. $1000 account for a newborn and it is invested in the Stock Market, I presume an index fund so that as the stock market does well, so does this investments.

This would be worth thousands by the time a child reaches adulthood and it ensures that everyone has a stake in capitalism, while also ensuring all kids get a chance in life regardless of their socio-economic start.

This crushed anything Canada or offers their citizens when they have children.


On the face of it, the so-called “Trump accounts” — which would provide parents of newborns with $1,000 to invest on behalf of their child’s future — would be a plus for many families.

“It’s a pro-family initiative that will help millions of Americans harness the strength of our economy to lift up the next generation, and they’ll really be getting a big jump on life,” President Donald Trump said Monday at a White House event.



The five-year pilot program, which is included in the House-passed budget bill — also known as the “One Big Beautiful Bill Act,” now under consideration in the Senate — could give a financial leg up to a new generation to build savings for their education and beyond.

While the proposal has its merits, it may not do as much as it could to help the tens of millions of families who will struggle to save for their children.

“This proposal meets some, but not all, of the best practices recommended by decades of research on early wealth-building programs,” said Madeline Brown, a senior policy associate at the Urban Institute, a Washington, DC-based think tank.


Here is a look at how the program would work and who is likely to benefit most.
Free shit!!!
 
Free shit!!!
$1000 at birth for a nation looking to encourage more births? ANd, in the future, it will down significantly on those who require assistance as they could have $50k or more available to them.

I think it's a great idea and an excellent investment. As far as government money goes, this is about as good an investment as a nation could make. Far better than borrowing trillions to bomb a desert somewhere, right?
 
$1000 at birth for a nation looking to encourage more births? ANd, in the future, it will down significantly on those who require assistance as they could have $50k or more available to them.

I think it's a great idea and an excellent investment. As far as government money goes, this is about as good an investment as a nation could make. Far better than borrowing trillions to bomb a desert somewhere, right?
How many votes do you think it will buy? Dems are offering their own free shit. Can Rs keep up?
 
More welfare from our democrat president.
 
How many votes do you think it will buy? Dems are offering their own free shit. Can Rs keep up?
WHen you use the term "investment" when government spends, it's usually a fallacy as they burn cash.

This is as honest a definition of the term investment for government spending as you will ever find. $1000 Is peanuts to give a kid a chance in life.
 
We already have this in the form of a tax deduction, which is every year for 18 years+.

Tax Savings for Claiming a Dependent Child
Claiming a qualifying child can lead to various tax benefits:
  • Child Tax Credit (CTC): For the 2024 and 2025 tax years, the CTC can be up to $2,000 per qualifying child. A portion of this credit, up to $1,700, may be refundable through the Additional Child Tax Credit (ACTC) depending on earned income.
  • Credit for Other Dependents: A nonrefundable $500 credit may be available for dependents who don't qualify for the CTC.
  • Other potential benefits: Claiming a dependent child may also qualify you for other credits like the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), Child and Dependent Care Credit, or education credits.
 
WHen you use the term "investment" when government spends, it's usually a fallacy as they burn cash.

This is as honest a definition of the term investment for government spending as you will ever find. $1000 Is peanuts to give a kid a chance in life.
Kids are a pain in the ass. I need a new pair of skis. That would be a much better investment.
 
15th post
We already have this in the form of a tax deduction, which is every year for 18 years+.

Tax Savings for Claiming a Dependent Child
Claiming a qualifying child can lead to various tax benefits:
  • Child Tax Credit (CTC): For the 2024 and 2025 tax years, the CTC can be up to $2,000 per qualifying child. A portion of this credit, up to $1,700, may be refundable through the Additional Child Tax Credit (ACTC) depending on earned income.
  • Credit for Other Dependents: A nonrefundable $500 credit may be available for dependents who don't qualify for the CTC.
  • Other potential benefits: Claiming a dependent child may also qualify you for other credits like the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), Child and Dependent Care Credit, or education credits.
That benefit goes to the parents. All tax credits go to the parents.
 
The proposed baby benefit stays in a blocked account until the baby grows up and reaches their majority.
So you want TWO tax breaks?

Dumb idea.
Don't support it just because it came from trump.
Use your brain.......Dumb idea.
You will hate it when a minority baby gets that fund.....Dumb idea.
 
Back
Top Bottom