How much have U.S. farmers been affected by illegal immigrants being deported?

[Luckyone]

AI Overview
Learn more

Impact of Deportation on U.S. Farmers and the Agricultural Sector:
The deportation of undocumented immigrants has significantly impacted U.S. farmers and the agricultural sector due to the sector's heavy reliance on immigrant labor.

Here's a breakdown of the key effects:

1. Labor Shortages and Workforce Disruption:

• Significant portion of farmworkers are undocumented: Roughly 40% of crop farmworkers in the U.S. are estimated to be undocumented, according to the Department of Agriculture.
• Mass deportations could severely deplete the agricultural workforce: This could lead to significant disruptions in planting, harvesting, and other essential farm operations.
• Farmers struggle to find replacements: Many farmers find it challenging to attract domestic workers to fill these physically demanding and often low-paying jobs.

2. Economic Impacts on Farms and Consumers:

• Increased labor costs: With a reduced workforce, farmers may face increased competition for available labor, potentially driving up wages.
• Reduced domestic production: Labor shortages could lead to reduced planting and harvesting, potentially impacting the overall quantity of domestically grown crops.
• Higher food prices: Labor shortages and reduced domestic production could lead to higher food prices for consumers.
• Potential shift towards increased imports: Farmers might need to rely more on imported produce to meet demand, potentially weakening the domestic agricultural market.

3. Operational and Logistical Challenges:

• Difficulty in meeting seasonal labor needs: Many farms, especially those producing labor-intensive crops like fruits and vegetables, rely on a seasonal workforce to meet their harvest demands.
• Challenges in adapting to new immigration policies: Farms may need to invest time and resources in adapting to changes in immigration enforcement and regulations.

4. Psychological and Social Impacts on Farmworkers:

• Fear and anxiety among immigrant workers: The threat of deportation can create significant fear and stress among farmworkers and their families.
• Potential for exploitation: A climate of fear and uncertainty could potentially make some workers more vulnerable to exploitation by employers.

In summary: The deportation of undocumented immigrants presents significant challenges to U.S. farmers, impacting their ability to maintain a reliable workforce, manage costs, and sustain domestic agricultural production.



This is something that Trump has not truly addressed or offered a solution for. He is deporting illegal aliens but not giving the farmers a "doable" option. Yes, getting rid of illegal aliens is a good thing but when you hurt Americans in the process, the good diminishes and in many occasions means that more harm than good is done.

 

[scruffy]

AI Overview
Learn more

Impact of Deportation on U.S. Farmers and the Agricultural Sector:
The deportation of undocumented immigrants has significantly impacted U.S. farmers and the agricultural sector due to the sector's heavy reliance on immigrant labor.

Here's a breakdown of the key effects:

1. Labor Shortages and Workforce Disruption:

• Significant portion of farmworkers are undocumented: Roughly 40% of crop farmworkers in the U.S. are estimated to be undocumented, according to the Department of Agriculture.
• Mass deportations could severely deplete the agricultural workforce: This could lead to significant disruptions in planting, harvesting, and other essential farm operations.
• Farmers struggle to find replacements: Many farmers find it challenging to attract domestic workers to fill these physically demanding and often low-paying jobs.

2. Economic Impacts on Farms and Consumers:

• Increased labor costs: With a reduced workforce, farmers may face increased competition for available labor, potentially driving up wages.
• Reduced domestic production: Labor shortages could lead to reduced planting and harvesting, potentially impacting the overall quantity of domestically grown crops.
• Higher food prices: Labor shortages and reduced domestic production could lead to higher food prices for consumers.
• Potential shift towards increased imports: Farmers might need to rely more on imported produce to meet demand, potentially weakening the domestic agricultural market.

3. Operational and Logistical Challenges:

• Difficulty in meeting seasonal labor needs: Many farms, especially those producing labor-intensive crops like fruits and vegetables, rely on a seasonal workforce to meet their harvest demands.
• Challenges in adapting to new immigration policies: Farms may need to invest time and resources in adapting to changes in immigration enforcement and regulations.

4. Psychological and Social Impacts on Farmworkers:

• Fear and anxiety among immigrant workers: The threat of deportation can create significant fear and stress among farmworkers and their families.
• Potential for exploitation: A climate of fear and uncertainty could potentially make some workers more vulnerable to exploitation by employers.

In summary: The deportation of undocumented immigrants presents significant challenges to U.S. farmers, impacting their ability to maintain a reliable workforce, manage costs, and sustain domestic agricultural production.



This is something that Trump has not truly addressed or offered a solution for. He is deporting illegal aliens but not giving the farmers a "doable" option. Yes, getting rid of illegal aliens is a good thing but when you hurt Americans in the process, the good diminishes and in many occasions means that more harm than good is done.

Seasonal workers can always get a seasonal work visa. Legally. Seasonal work is legal.

 

[OhPleaseJustQuit]

AI Overview
Learn more

Impact of Deportation on U.S. Farmers and the Agricultural Sector:
The deportation of undocumented immigrants has significantly impacted U.S. farmers and the agricultural sector due to the sector's heavy reliance on immigrant labor.

Here's a breakdown of the key effects:

1. Labor Shortages and Workforce Disruption:

• Significant portion of farmworkers are undocumented: Roughly 40% of crop farmworkers in the U.S. are estimated to be undocumented, according to the Department of Agriculture.
• Mass deportations could severely deplete the agricultural workforce: This could lead to significant disruptions in planting, harvesting, and other essential farm operations.
• Farmers struggle to find replacements: Many farmers find it challenging to attract domestic workers to fill these physically demanding and often low-paying jobs.

2. Economic Impacts on Farms and Consumers:

• Increased labor costs: With a reduced workforce, farmers may face increased competition for available labor, potentially driving up wages.
• Reduced domestic production: Labor shortages could lead to reduced planting and harvesting, potentially impacting the overall quantity of domestically grown crops.
• Higher food prices: Labor shortages and reduced domestic production could lead to higher food prices for consumers.
• Potential shift towards increased imports: Farmers might need to rely more on imported produce to meet demand, potentially weakening the domestic agricultural market.

3. Operational and Logistical Challenges:

• Difficulty in meeting seasonal labor needs: Many farms, especially those producing labor-intensive crops like fruits and vegetables, rely on a seasonal workforce to meet their harvest demands.
• Challenges in adapting to new immigration policies: Farms may need to invest time and resources in adapting to changes in immigration enforcement and regulations.

4. Psychological and Social Impacts on Farmworkers:

• Fear and anxiety among immigrant workers: The threat of deportation can create significant fear and stress among farmworkers and their families.
• Potential for exploitation: A climate of fear and uncertainty could potentially make some workers more vulnerable to exploitation by employers.

In summary: The deportation of undocumented immigrants presents significant challenges to U.S. farmers, impacting their ability to maintain a reliable workforce, manage costs, and sustain domestic agricultural production.



This is something that Trump has not truly addressed or offered a solution for. He is deporting illegal aliens but not giving the farmers a "doable" option. Yes, getting rid of illegal aliens is a good thing but when you hurt Americans in the process, the good diminishes and in many occasions means that more harm than good is done.

.


OH, NOES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

There goes all our slaves!




.

 

[Oddball]

 

[Dekster]

AI Overview
Learn more

Impact of Deportation on U.S. Farmers and the Agricultural Sector:
The deportation of undocumented immigrants has significantly impacted U.S. farmers and the agricultural sector due to the sector's heavy reliance on immigrant labor.

Here's a breakdown of the key effects:

1. Labor Shortages and Workforce Disruption:

• Significant portion of farmworkers are undocumented: Roughly 40% of crop farmworkers in the U.S. are estimated to be undocumented, according to the Department of Agriculture.
• Mass deportations could severely deplete the agricultural workforce: This could lead to significant disruptions in planting, harvesting, and other essential farm operations.
• Farmers struggle to find replacements: Many farmers find it challenging to attract domestic workers to fill these physically demanding and often low-paying jobs.

2. Economic Impacts on Farms and Consumers:

• Increased labor costs: With a reduced workforce, farmers may face increased competition for available labor, potentially driving up wages.
• Reduced domestic production: Labor shortages could lead to reduced planting and harvesting, potentially impacting the overall quantity of domestically grown crops.
• Higher food prices: Labor shortages and reduced domestic production could lead to higher food prices for consumers.
• Potential shift towards increased imports: Farmers might need to rely more on imported produce to meet demand, potentially weakening the domestic agricultural market.

3. Operational and Logistical Challenges:

• Difficulty in meeting seasonal labor needs: Many farms, especially those producing labor-intensive crops like fruits and vegetables, rely on a seasonal workforce to meet their harvest demands.
• Challenges in adapting to new immigration policies: Farms may need to invest time and resources in adapting to changes in immigration enforcement and regulations.

4. Psychological and Social Impacts on Farmworkers:

• Fear and anxiety among immigrant workers: The threat of deportation can create significant fear and stress among farmworkers and their families.
• Potential for exploitation: A climate of fear and uncertainty could potentially make some workers more vulnerable to exploitation by employers.

In summary: The deportation of undocumented immigrants presents significant challenges to U.S. farmers, impacting their ability to maintain a reliable workforce, manage costs, and sustain domestic agricultural production.



This is something that Trump has not truly addressed or offered a solution for. He is deporting illegal aliens but not giving the farmers a "doable" option. Yes, getting rid of illegal aliens is a good thing but when you hurt Americans in the process, the good diminishes and in many occasions means that more harm than good is done.

Take the lesson from the egg industry---short the supply even more and drive up the prices even higher.

 

[martybegan]

Seasonal workers can always get a seasonal work visa. Legally. Seasonal work is legal.

And the best thing is for those who self deport, they don't get the bans usually associated with being deported when caught.

 

[martybegan]

.


OH, NOES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

There goes all our slaves!




.

if we start treating mental illnesses and drug addiction properly and actually enforce laws on vagrancy a whole big group of new workers opens up.

 

[tahuyaman]

Legal migrant workers are still able to pick crops.

 

[Luckyone]

Legal migrant workers are still able to pick crops.

40% of the migrants working in agriculture are illegal.

Has Trump offered any plan that will allow more migrants to come legally?

 

[martybegan]

40% of the migrants working in agriculture are illegal.

Has Trump offered any plan that will allow more migrants to come legally?

Should have thought of that when Biden was opening the floodgates.

Welcome to the backlash, bitch.

 

[OhPleaseJustQuit]

40% of the migrants working in agriculture are illegal.

Has Trump offered any plan that will allow more migrants to come legally?

.



Translation -- "We REALLY need to keep our slaves!"




.

 

[g5000]

Seasonal workers can always get a seasonal work visa. Legally. Seasonal work is legal.

As I have been saying for a very long time, our quota system is broken.

The supply of legal workers is not enough to meet the labor demand.

A farmer has no choice but to hire illegals.

Every time someone has tried to reform our immigration system, they are shot down.

See: Republican Eric Cantor. The third most powerful member of Congress, primaried out of office for daring to submit an immigration reform bill.

Dubya tried it. Shot down.

And so it has been going for at least a quarter of a century.

All stopped by ignorant bigots.

Immigrants do the shit jobs Americans won't do.

Like Melania.

 

[tahuyaman]

40% of the migrants working in agriculture are illegal.

Has Trump offered any plan that will allow more migrants to come legally?

That doesn’t make it legal or legit. Trump doesn’t need to offer a plan to promote legal entry of migrant workers. They can do that now.

 

[WEATHER53]

They put their children back to work
Builds character and unity

 

[g5000]

There are two things the bigots are taught by their MAGA propagandists and by their president.

1. There are far more illegals than reported.

One bigot on this forum quoted a figure to me that was so stupid, I had to point out that would mean one in five people in our country is an illegal.

This is a ladder effect pushed by their propagandists where the number of illegals gets bigger and bigger, and scarier and scarier.



2. They bring drugs, they bring crime, they are rapists, and SOME it is ASSUMED are good people.

When it comes to Nazis at a protest, though, there are good people on both sides.

This statement about drugs and crime and rapists and only SOME good people implies MOST are wild animals.

This is a patent lie. A deliberate lie. A calculated lie.

Illegal immigrants commit violent crime at a rate half of American citizens. You literally have far more to worry about from your fellow Americans than you do illegals.

But MAGA propagandists never miss an opportunity to hype the living shit out of a crime committed by an illegal, for WEEKS. Especially if the victim is a white female.

This feeds the confirmation bias of their viewers, and this, too, is calculated.

It's all about eyeballs. It's about ad dollars.

We saw this with the 2020 Big Lie. Fox News behind the scenes knew Biden won, but they also unequivocally said they needed to feed the Big Lie to their viewers lest they lose them to a competitor.

You are being manipulated, folks. You are cattle with wallets. You are led around with a ring in your nose.

 

[CrusaderFrank]

AI Overview
Learn more

Impact of Deportation on U.S. Farmers and the Agricultural Sector:
The deportation of undocumented immigrants has significantly impacted U.S. farmers and the agricultural sector due to the sector's heavy reliance on immigrant labor.

Here's a breakdown of the key effects:

1. Labor Shortages and Workforce Disruption:

• Significant portion of farmworkers are undocumented: Roughly 40% of crop farmworkers in the U.S. are estimated to be undocumented, according to the Department of Agriculture.
• Mass deportations could severely deplete the agricultural workforce: This could lead to significant disruptions in planting, harvesting, and other essential farm operations.
• Farmers struggle to find replacements: Many farmers find it challenging to attract domestic workers to fill these physically demanding and often low-paying jobs.

2. Economic Impacts on Farms and Consumers:

• Increased labor costs: With a reduced workforce, farmers may face increased competition for available labor, potentially driving up wages.
• Reduced domestic production: Labor shortages could lead to reduced planting and harvesting, potentially impacting the overall quantity of domestically grown crops.
• Higher food prices: Labor shortages and reduced domestic production could lead to higher food prices for consumers.
• Potential shift towards increased imports: Farmers might need to rely more on imported produce to meet demand, potentially weakening the domestic agricultural market.

3. Operational and Logistical Challenges:

• Difficulty in meeting seasonal labor needs: Many farms, especially those producing labor-intensive crops like fruits and vegetables, rely on a seasonal workforce to meet their harvest demands.
• Challenges in adapting to new immigration policies: Farms may need to invest time and resources in adapting to changes in immigration enforcement and regulations.

4. Psychological and Social Impacts on Farmworkers:

• Fear and anxiety among immigrant workers: The threat of deportation can create significant fear and stress among farmworkers and their families.
• Potential for exploitation: A climate of fear and uncertainty could potentially make some workers more vulnerable to exploitation by employers.

In summary: The deportation of undocumented immigrants presents significant challenges to U.S. farmers, impacting their ability to maintain a reliable workforce, manage costs, and sustain domestic agricultural production.



This is something that Trump has not truly addressed or offered a solution for. He is deporting illegal aliens but not giving the farmers a "doable" option. Yes, getting rid of illegal aliens is a good thing but when you hurt Americans in the process, the good diminishes and in many occasions means that more harm than good is done.

 

[OhPleaseJustQuit]

As I have been saying for a very long time, our quota system is broken.

The supply of legal workers is not enough to meet the labor demand.

A farmer has no choice but to hire illegals.

Every time someone has tried to reform our immigration system, they are shot down.

See: Republican Eric Cantor. The third most powerful member of Congress, primaried out of office for daring to submit an immigration reform bill.

Dubya tried it. Shot down.

And so it has been going for at least a quarter of a century.

All stopped by ignorant bigots.

Immigrants do the shit jobs Americans won't do.

Like Melania.

.




Translation -- "If you try to take our slaves, we'll burn our cities down!"



.

 

[marvin martian]

AI Overview
Learn more

Impact of Deportation on U.S. Farmers and the Agricultural Sector:
The deportation of undocumented immigrants has significantly impacted U.S. farmers and the agricultural sector due to the sector's heavy reliance on immigrant labor.

Here's a breakdown of the key effects:

1. Labor Shortages and Workforce Disruption:

• Significant portion of farmworkers are undocumented: Roughly 40% of crop farmworkers in the U.S. are estimated to be undocumented, according to the Department of Agriculture.
• Mass deportations could severely deplete the agricultural workforce: This could lead to significant disruptions in planting, harvesting, and other essential farm operations.
• Farmers struggle to find replacements: Many farmers find it challenging to attract domestic workers to fill these physically demanding and often low-paying jobs.

2. Economic Impacts on Farms and Consumers:

• Increased labor costs: With a reduced workforce, farmers may face increased competition for available labor, potentially driving up wages.
• Reduced domestic production: Labor shortages could lead to reduced planting and harvesting, potentially impacting the overall quantity of domestically grown crops.
• Higher food prices: Labor shortages and reduced domestic production could lead to higher food prices for consumers.
• Potential shift towards increased imports: Farmers might need to rely more on imported produce to meet demand, potentially weakening the domestic agricultural market.

3. Operational and Logistical Challenges:

• Difficulty in meeting seasonal labor needs: Many farms, especially those producing labor-intensive crops like fruits and vegetables, rely on a seasonal workforce to meet their harvest demands.
• Challenges in adapting to new immigration policies: Farms may need to invest time and resources in adapting to changes in immigration enforcement and regulations.

4. Psychological and Social Impacts on Farmworkers:

• Fear and anxiety among immigrant workers: The threat of deportation can create significant fear and stress among farmworkers and their families.
• Potential for exploitation: A climate of fear and uncertainty could potentially make some workers more vulnerable to exploitation by employers.

In summary: The deportation of undocumented immigrants presents significant challenges to U.S. farmers, impacting their ability to maintain a reliable workforce, manage costs, and sustain domestic agricultural production.



This is something that Trump has not truly addressed or offered a solution for. He is deporting illegal aliens but not giving the farmers a "doable" option. Yes, getting rid of illegal aliens is a good thing but when you hurt Americans in the process, the good diminishes and in many occasions means that more harm than good is done.

You have to give up your slaves.

We had this discussion with you in 1861, and you lost that time, too.

 

[Luckyone]

That doesn’t make it legal or legit. Trump doesn’t need to offer a plan to promote legal entry of migrant workers. They can do that now.

This OP is about how American Farmers are getting hurt, which in turn hurts all Americans. Trump is supposed to help Americans, meaning that she should be offering alternatives to the farmers. All he is doing is doing but not solving.

 

[WEATHER53]

This OP is about how American Farmers are getting hurt, which in turn hurts all Americans. Trump is supposed to help Americans, meaning that she should be offering alternatives to the farmers. All he is doing is doing but not solving.

You feel they should be hurt but they still have some kegals and provides economic opportunity to those who Are Not illegal.