18 I said to myself, [that this is] because of the children of men, so that God should clarify for them, so that they may see that they are [like] beasts to themselves.
19 For there is a happening for the children of men, and there is a happening for the beasts-and they have one happening-like the death of this one is the death of that one, and all have one spirit, and the superiority of man over beast is nought, for all is vanity
Yeah.........if you attempt to declare that one section of scripture contradicts another section of the scriptures, especially when its the same author being quoted, you have a comprehension problem. Solomon is simply pointing out that man and animal are equals in the fact that both are destined to die a physical death, face the same environmental problems in their earthly struggle for life, face the same circumstances of sickness, etc.,
In fact vs. "19" begins by suggesting 2 different fates.......then declaring there is one fate they both share.....physical death.
Ever attempt to read from a valid translation such as the New American Standard, or even the KJV........instead of twisting the interpretation to met a certain doctrine?
Read the scripture in ENGLISH, Same verse......in comprehendible English, ASV (American Standard), Eccl. 3:19, "For that which befalls the sons of men, befalls beasts, even one thing befall them; AS ONE DIETH SO DOES THE OTHER........" Both must face physical death.
Its after death that comes the defining difference between man and beast.
He(SOLOMON) has already stated this in scriptures with no ambiguity possible, with the difference being that the spirit of animals goes back to the earth, while the spirit of man (made in the image of God) goes back to God who gave it....with the physical body going back to the dust from which it was created. In fact........the difference is explained quite clearly in Eccl. 3:22..........why stop reading at 19?
One must comprehend the difference between the spirit of man and the soul of man. Man.....unlike an animal is composed of 3 elements, body, soul and spirit (1 Thess 5:23) The body is not difficult at all to explain (Job: 19-17). Its understood that the body is just a vessel for something that lives on after the flesh is gone. (2 Peter 2:13-14).
Then, its more difficult to understand the soul and spirit. (Heb. 4:12) Paul states that the soul and spirit can be divided. The Greek word used for spirit in this verse means WIND, or like the wind. In this case the spirit being divided from the soul is the thoughts of man or the mind of man.....when your spirit (mind) is separated from your soul you are dead (even in the afterlife) When spirit is used it depends upon the context that surrounds it use that defines its meaning. There is a difference, depending upon the context of the passage when speaking of the spirit of man.
The spirit of man is defined in scripture. Man was made in the image of God (God is a spirit being) -- Gen. 1:26-27, John 4:24
God forms the spirit of man (Zechariah 12:1). In other contextual definitions the spirit of man is referencing THE MIND and THOUGHTS of man, as it is the mind that controls the actions of the man. A man knows his own thoughts (1 Cor. 2:11)
A man's spirit searches the depths of one's heart (Prov. 20:27). One must worship in spirit (mind) and truth (John 4:23-24).
In the case of Solomon......the context makes it obvious......the spirit being spoken of was the Soul/Spirit (Eccl. 12:7) The spirit of man goes back to He that created it for JUDGMENT.
Some might attempt to interpret this and declare there are no animals in heaven...........the simple truth is no one knows, but we do know that animals can't sin because they are unable to comprehend the laws that define sin. No judgement is required of any beast. If the scriptures are silent we are to be silent.