Disir
Platinum Member
- Sep 30, 2011
- 28,003
- 9,611
- 910
"In the true Arctic shamanic realm, rain can be taken for granted. In the near-rainless river valleys of Egypt and Mesopotamia, crops can be grown through state-controlled irrigation, and only so. In the Mediterranean realm, a seer who is thought to manage the withholding and grantinf of rain holds the keys of life and death. Greek Kleis âkeyâ went into Aramaic: at Luke 11:52 the âkey of knowledge become sin the Syriac qlydâ dyd âtâ; see Rev 1:18 âthe keys of death and Hades.â See Matt 16:19 âthe keys of the kingdom of heaven.â The theme is taken up in Qurâan 39.63: âHis are the keys (maqalidu) of heaven and earth,â where maqalidu is the plural of maqlid, an inner -Arabic extension of the Greek.
The rabbis agreed (Gen.Rabbah 73.4; Deut. Rabbah 7.6) that the Holy One had three keys: the key of the raising of the dead, for he says (Ezek 37:12), âI will open your gravesâ; the key of the womb, for it is written (Gen 29:31), âAnd he opened her wombâ; and the key of the rain for it is said (Deut 28:12), âYahweh will open to you his good treasure.â But individually they are called in Greek style âqlydâ.
This doctrine provides a most ingenious exegesis of the history of Elijah (b, Sanh. 113a). He rashly predicted drought; in a weak moment the Holy One gave him the key of rain. He locked the rain up but couldnât reopen it. A Galilean said, âHe is like a man who locked the gate and lost the key.â The Holy One saw distress on the world and resorted to subterfuge. He sent Elijah to Sarepta where the widowâs son was sick, and Elijah begged mercy to be given the key of the raising of the dead. The Holy One said, âThree keys have never been given to angel or seraph (Deut. Rabbah); people will say, âTwo are in the hand of the talmid and one in the hand of the Rab?â Return that one and take this one.â So he got the key of the rain back, and the storm at Carmel follows. But Elijah kept the key of the raising of the dead.
The vocabulary of rain mostly relates to the High God; here we look at the role of the seer. The displeasure of the god is made manifest by the withholding of rain. When the Pythia at Delphi tells the men of Thera to colonize Libya, and they refuse , âfor seven years it did not rain on Theraâ (Herodotus 4.151.1); the figure is conventional, cf. the âseven years of famineâ of Gen 41:30 in Egypt. Elijah is abruptly introduced (1 Kgs 17:1) saying to Ahab, âAs Yahweh the God of Israel lives, there shall be neither rain nor dew these years, except by my word.â Yahweh in his brief against Israel (Amos 4:6-13) lists all his warnings, âyet you did not return to meâ; he rains on one city or field and not on another."
He goes on to say that âthe Godâ can also carry out the alternate style of warning by bringing on unseasonable and damaging rain as in 1 Sam 12:17. Zeus can do the same for the same reasons (Hesiod Opera 263-264). It is also pointed out that Greek lampas and Hebrew lappid can both mean âtorchâ and âlighteningâ. Additionally there is a brief section of priests and seers that are performing water rituals for agricultural purposes- including Egypt.
Further into the book (p 188) it is pointed out that the Hellenes and Yahweh both share similar views on what the world looked like. Land and sea are circular and the earth for the Abrahamic God is âwheel shaped.â We know that there is an earlier recorded version of the flood by the Sumerians. He says, The later flood legends as of Noah and Deucalion surely rest in part on the great tsunami of (perhaps) 1628 B.C.E.; folk memory may have retained some relic of the great cataract when the level of the Black Sea was raised 350 feet about 5600 BCE.
What if it really is a combo on that flood story and it became a part of âfolk memoryâ? The Big One as it were. similar to how we all wait for California to fall into the ocean. TBH, I didnât know about the Black Sea going up. This is from John Pairman Brownâs Ancient Israel and Ancient Greece. He was a biblical scholar and was a professor. I included enough from him as best I could for those that like to look up their own stuff.
The rabbis agreed (Gen.Rabbah 73.4; Deut. Rabbah 7.6) that the Holy One had three keys: the key of the raising of the dead, for he says (Ezek 37:12), âI will open your gravesâ; the key of the womb, for it is written (Gen 29:31), âAnd he opened her wombâ; and the key of the rain for it is said (Deut 28:12), âYahweh will open to you his good treasure.â But individually they are called in Greek style âqlydâ.
This doctrine provides a most ingenious exegesis of the history of Elijah (b, Sanh. 113a). He rashly predicted drought; in a weak moment the Holy One gave him the key of rain. He locked the rain up but couldnât reopen it. A Galilean said, âHe is like a man who locked the gate and lost the key.â The Holy One saw distress on the world and resorted to subterfuge. He sent Elijah to Sarepta where the widowâs son was sick, and Elijah begged mercy to be given the key of the raising of the dead. The Holy One said, âThree keys have never been given to angel or seraph (Deut. Rabbah); people will say, âTwo are in the hand of the talmid and one in the hand of the Rab?â Return that one and take this one.â So he got the key of the rain back, and the storm at Carmel follows. But Elijah kept the key of the raising of the dead.
The vocabulary of rain mostly relates to the High God; here we look at the role of the seer. The displeasure of the god is made manifest by the withholding of rain. When the Pythia at Delphi tells the men of Thera to colonize Libya, and they refuse , âfor seven years it did not rain on Theraâ (Herodotus 4.151.1); the figure is conventional, cf. the âseven years of famineâ of Gen 41:30 in Egypt. Elijah is abruptly introduced (1 Kgs 17:1) saying to Ahab, âAs Yahweh the God of Israel lives, there shall be neither rain nor dew these years, except by my word.â Yahweh in his brief against Israel (Amos 4:6-13) lists all his warnings, âyet you did not return to meâ; he rains on one city or field and not on another."
He goes on to say that âthe Godâ can also carry out the alternate style of warning by bringing on unseasonable and damaging rain as in 1 Sam 12:17. Zeus can do the same for the same reasons (Hesiod Opera 263-264). It is also pointed out that Greek lampas and Hebrew lappid can both mean âtorchâ and âlighteningâ. Additionally there is a brief section of priests and seers that are performing water rituals for agricultural purposes- including Egypt.
Further into the book (p 188) it is pointed out that the Hellenes and Yahweh both share similar views on what the world looked like. Land and sea are circular and the earth for the Abrahamic God is âwheel shaped.â We know that there is an earlier recorded version of the flood by the Sumerians. He says, The later flood legends as of Noah and Deucalion surely rest in part on the great tsunami of (perhaps) 1628 B.C.E.; folk memory may have retained some relic of the great cataract when the level of the Black Sea was raised 350 feet about 5600 BCE.
What if it really is a combo on that flood story and it became a part of âfolk memoryâ? The Big One as it were. similar to how we all wait for California to fall into the ocean. TBH, I didnât know about the Black Sea going up. This is from John Pairman Brownâs Ancient Israel and Ancient Greece. He was a biblical scholar and was a professor. I included enough from him as best I could for those that like to look up their own stuff.
Last edited: