The great men who founded this country disagreed, and so do I, and so, I think, would most Americans, if they really thought about it. This system of government was specifically designed to avoid the tyranny of the majority, and to assure the best chance that all Americans had their interests and needs represented in government, and not just those who could be grouped into majorities, over those who could not.
They weren't "Great Men", they were a bunch of Slave owners (which makes them irredeemably evil, Full fucking stop) who didn't want to pay their fair share in taxes for a war they instigated. (While the French and Indian War was part of the Seven Years War in Europe, the British did not want a war with France in North America until the colonists provoked one.)
If the majority votes for something, it's not tyranny. It's democracy.
But let's get down to brass tacks. We've had five elections where the Electoral Anachronism came up with a different result than we would have had if we had just left it to the popular vote.
One was 1824, which resulted in the "Corrupt Bargain" between JQ Adams and Clay. The people revolted and put Andrew Jackson in power the next election.
Next you had 1876, where you had another corrupt bargain when "His Fraudelency" Rutherford B. Hayes gave away the victory in the Civil War and gave us 100 years of Jim Crow. (I know being part of a racist cult, this doesn't bother you, but it should bother the rest of us.)
1888- Harrison stole the election from Cleveland, gave us a the Panic of 1893. It was so bad they stopped calling them "Panics" and started calling them "Depressions". (Then the GOP fucked it up again in 1929 and we stopped calling them "Depressions" and started calling them "Recessions". I guess with Trump, we'll need to come up with a new word.)
2000- The people said Gore, the electoral Anachronism says Bush, we got two wars, two recessions, doubled the national debt, and a major city got wiped off the map.
2016- The people said Hillary, the Electoral Anachronism gave us Trump. 26 million unemployed, 50,000 dead, a million people sick.
At some point, maybe we need to trust the people and not just put some guy who is going to piss on everything.