You liberal black guys are all the same.....
I've read the whole thread. I'll bet you can guess my opinion. There's some interesting perspective here, once you weed out the icky stuff, though.
Do you think Lincoln should have just said "Okay, bye!" when the south seceded?
I'm not a Civil War scholar, don't have any background in the details of what was happening in Congress or the courts for the decade before the War, when the economics of slavery was being dealt with--presumably--by them. Seems no mutually satisfactory solution could be found. When the South said they'd had enough, Lincoln could either accept the dissolution of the Union or deem them "rebels" and fight to sustain the country as a whole. I'm not sure it would have been good for either side, long term, if he had chosen the other option.
Interesting stuff, though.