I still haven't gotten an answer to this...imagine it is 2007 and Nancy Pelosi sends to the Senate a budget that funds everything, but ends the Bush tax cuts for the top 2%. She says she will allow the government to shut down if the budget isn't passed with an expiration of those tax cuts.
Who would be "shutting down the government" in the above scenario?
Pelosi
She would be trying to screw us out of a tax break.
In this case the Repubs are trying to prevent the Dems from screwing us with another tax increase.
Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk 2
That's not an answer but a deflection. It's okay...we can already imagine what y'all would be saying if it were Democrats trying to shut down the government over something they couldn't do legislatively. The Fox wing nuts would be exploding with ire.
It happened in the 70's over abortion funding.
It was a war between the Democrat Liberals (then in the minority) over the majority of Democrats who were Conservative and Moderate.
Liberal Dem's in the Senate insisted they wanted to add rape and incest to the Medicaid funding.
The Abortion Shutdown
When did it take place? Sept. 30 to Oct. 13, 1977
How long did it last? 12 days
Who was president? Jimmy Carter
Who controlled the Senate? Democrats, 59-41; Robert Byrd was majority leader
Who controlled the House? Democrats, 292-143; Tip O'Neill was speaker
Why did it happen? The House insisted on continuing the ban on using Medicaid dollars to pay for abortions except in cases where the life of the mother was at stake. The Senate wanted to loosen this to include allowances for abortions in the case of rape or incest or when the mother's health was in danger. Because the issue had become tied to funding for Labor and HEW, failure to come to an agreement led those agencies to have a funding gap.
Government shut down happened 3 times over the fight.
What resolved it?
A deal was brokered in which the exception allowing Medicaid to pay for abortions in cases where the mother's life is endangered was widened to include abortions resulting from rape or incest, or which are necessary to protect the mother's health (even if her life was not endangered).
A victory of the minority back then for what they thought was for the rights of Women.
It's the opposite now, with the Minority in the House & Senate (Tea Party - Conservatives) with wanting to stop the New Health care Bill that they think will do great harm to our Economy and how the quality of our Health Care will be given.
The Liberals (minority) back then were not called names like radicals and they got their way.