Zone1 Debunking the view that Muhammad was a pedophile for his marriage to Aisha

And folks can use all the one liners and insults they want toward Islam, but especially if they are American or Christian their argument makes no logical sense. They would have to apply their argument to American society in the 19th century. So their argument therefore falls apart.

Yes, probably right now. Most child marriages in the world are in Muslim majority societies although it’s extremely rare. I believe it also occurs in Hindu majority areas that are very rural. It certainly does occur in some Mormons societies in Utah. It’s all rare though

BackAgain


Again Saudi Arabia is working with Israeli Jews in some capacities. So before getting all fired up the anti-Muslims especially those who are pro Jewish just take a chill pill.
 
And folks can use all the one liners and insults they want toward Islam, but especially if they are American or Christian their argument makes no logical sense.
Sure. 😂
They would have to apply their argument to American society in the 19th century.
Not even remotely true.
So their argument therefore falls apart.
In no way. Silly premise. No support. Conclusion does not follow from your “argument.”

BackAgain

What?
 
Well, no wonder Biden acts as he does, he must think he's back in 1871 Delaware.


Delaware's age of consent was set at seven years old in 1871 because the state adopted English Common Law, which dated back to the 1500s. This law stated that a girl could consent to sexual relations at age seven.
 
The OP debunks nothing.
reminds me of a conversation I had with a Chinese Canadian recently. He was very critical of Islam and then just ignored the points I told him…points I also made in the original post.

It doesn’t bother me. There’s people who say Judaism is evil because some rabbis say three-year-old girls can marry. The anti Judaic folks are wrong to for the same reasons listed in the original post.


Again, I’m all for free speech and I can get along with people who don’t like Islam or Judaism. I’m a free speech guy
 
Possibly …. But other Islamic narratives say Aisha was 19 years old upon marriage to Muhammad .

The critical point is undeniable. So we can go back to the 1800s in America when the age of consent was seven or nine years old in most states in the country. That Demolishes the anti-Islam narrative. Many centuries after Muhammad there was still child marriage even in the Christian west.

The fact is girls got married at a much much much younger age in the past. It was acceptable because people had to survive and create families. There’s other reasons as well.

Now there is still a problem in some of the really rural areas of some Muslim majority countries today where there is child marriage …. it’s unacceptable in the modern era. I know some Mormons and other Christians do this too.


We are in the dawn of a new age…. Look at the liberal advancements in Saudi Arabia, for example. They are working with Israelis in some capacity ….to the chagrin of Muslim and Jewish racists
I don't know where you get your information but the Mosque I went to taught that Aiesha was 6 upon marriage and 9 upon consummation. The Koran I have is very clear on killing all Jews wherever they are found.

At one time infants were betrothed in their cradles. So don't get confused about marriage laws. In parts of the middle east girls are routinely sold. They are merchandise, nothing more. The family needs the money selling that three year old girl will bring. These are not religious decisions. They are economic decisions.
 
Well, no wonder Biden acts as he does, he must think he's back in 1871 Delaware.

Delaware's age of consent was set at seven years old in 1871 because the state adopted English Common Law, which dated back to the 1500s. This law stated that a girl could consent to sexual relations at age seven.
Your article states that the age of consent in Britian has been 12 since 1275.

in 1275, the English government set the age of consent at 12 years old for females as part of a rape law and a 1576 law was created with more severe punishments for which the age of consent was set at 10 years old for females.[10][11] Jurist Sir Matthew Hale stated that both rape laws were valid at the same time.[10]
 
I don't know where you get your information but the Mosque I went to taught that Aiesha was 6 upon marriage and 9 upon consummation. The Koran I have is very clear on killing all Jews wherever they are found.

At one time infants were betrothed in their cradles. So don't get confused about marriage laws. In parts of the middle east girls are routinely sold. They are merchandise, nothing more. The family needs the money selling that three year old girl will bring. These are not religious decisions. They are economic decisions.
Well, first of all tons of Muslims and also Arab Christian supported Donald Trump. So it is imperative that the world sees Republicans and Trump supporters as not being bigots. Because that is after all what the left wing narrative is so let’s prove them wrong. Trump thanked Muslims for their support so I feel very comfortable in making threads like this.

There’s big problems in the west, too much porn, too much social degradation, radical views on race and gender….little family values. Things that we did not have even 50 years ago. These things do exist in some Muslim countries, but in a lot of them they don’t and that is something to admire.

I get my information from reputable sources.

Did you know that Jews served in Muhammad ‘s armies. Treated as equals and with respect. The idea that the Koran says to kill Jews wherever they are found is a big misunderstanding and not accurate. No different than the idea that the Torah says to kill all “goyim” or non-Jews or make them slaves, etc.

For the marriage point it’s already been provided. It was just a different era. Girls got married at a lot younger of an age all across the world. So that point has already been responded to. I’ve done what is necessary and provide the context of the situation you can see in this thread that some people are simply responding to it by saying things like no or one or two liners I can’t help them. That’s their problems similar to how Some people who are against Jews will never respond to arguments that show anti Judaic views to be based on error.

Yes, there is a problem in a very small portion of the Muslim world where girls are getting married at a young age today or abused somehow. That does obviously though occur all over the world in the west and every country there’s people in jail for sexual abuse of girls.
 
Last edited:
Your article states that the age of consent in Britian has been 12 since 1275.

in 1275, the English government set the age of consent at 12 years old for females as part of a rape law and a 1576 law was created with more severe punishments for which the age of consent was set at 10 years old for females.[10][11] Jurist Sir Matthew Hale stated that both rape laws were valid at the same time.[10]




IMG_3554.webp
IMG_3555.webp
 
We have often heard folks who are critical of Islam or outright bigots say that Muhammad was a pedophile. Or something like that for his marriage to Aisha, who, according to some was nine years old upon marrying Muhammad . But actually firstly according to other Islamic narratives Aisha was 18 upon marrying Muhammad.

The simplest way to address this issue is to look at the context. For example, in the 19th century in the USA in one state the age of consent was seven years old for girls. Now we’re not talking about 1000 years ago but

View attachment 1066759

There it is so people who hate Islam or Muhammad will by that logic have to hate America. So their argument falls apart very quickly.

Not to mention there are some Jewish interpretations that say according to Jewish law, the age of consent can be as low as three years old or Jewish men can marry three-year-old girls.

Now again, the critics or the bigots will say “who cares about the past” which of course destroys their own point of view anyways. But they’ll say “why is it that Muslims today still marry 10-year-olds” or something like that. Which by the way is extremely rare and happening only in tribal areas in Afghanistan if at all.

In addition In fact when you look at the age of consent. It is actually higher on average in Muslim countries compared to non Muslim countries.

There are some countries in the world today non-Muslim ones like the Philippines where the age of consent was recently 12 years old until only a few years ago. And for a long time the age of consent in Japan was 13 years old.


Now confronted with these facts, the critics or bots will jump to other topics and say “oh Muslims blow themselves up all the time” or something. And of course, that is another topic and it’s also debunked. But the point is that when they are proven wrong, the critics of Islam or the biggest will just start jumping to other topics or try and look for the Gacha moments. We are dealing with people who simply don’t know better. Actually, a lot of critics of Islam simply don’t understand the historical context.

There is another set of critics of Islam, who are outright racist or never honest. They live a deranged life very unhealthy. In many cases physically unhealthy, a bad diet and a really bad mindset. They never will change their ways before they die. They will go to their grave absolutely hating people who are different from them. This is the case with hatred of Jews, hatred of Catholics hatred of Muslims, whatever it might be.

View attachment 1066760



View attachment 1066762



As an American Patriot and Trump supporter…Knowing well that Arabs and Muslims in large part supported Donald Trump, I am vindicated. I am providing common sense here. And ready to show the radical left that we Trump supporters are united more than ever. You got your blacks, your whites, your Christians, your Jews, your Muslims all United behind Donald Trump. There are way more racists on the left wing side When it comes to the BLM supporters. There are still a few Trump supporters who are Racist, but it’s few and and far between.
So, you're justifying pedophilia (sex with prepubescent girls) by Muhammad because others, centuries later, practice pedophilia.
Just rest about this man's evils. He rivals Hitler. Still you want to justify this demon
 
We have often heard folks who are critical of Islam or outright bigots say that Muhammad was a pedophile. Or something like that for his marriage to Aisha, who, according to some was nine years old upon marrying Muhammad . But actually firstly according to other Islamic narratives Aisha was 18 upon marrying Muhammad.
You seem to be arguing out of both sides of your mouth. She was either 9 or 18 years old. If she was 18, no problem. If she was 9, that is a big problem for the Last Prophet and those who adhere to his every word and deed.
 
Last edited:
You seem to be arguing out of both sides of your mouth. She was either 9 or 18 years old. If she was 18, no problem. If she was 9, that is a big problem for the Last Prophet and those who follow his every word.

Childhood marriages were quite common during those times. Thirteen was an average marriage age... Considering the average lifespan was less than 50. It's very possible that nine is the accurate age.
 
Possibly …. But other Islamic narratives say Aisha was 19 years old upon marriage to Muhammad .

The critical point is undeniable. So we can go back to the 1800s in America when the age of consent was seven or nine years old in most states in the country. That Demolishes the anti-Islam narrative. Many centuries after Muhammad there was still child marriage even in the Christian west.

The fact is girls got married at a much much much younger age in the past. It was acceptable because people had to survive and create families. There’s other reasons as well.

Now there is still a problem in some of the really rural areas of some Muslim majority countries today where there is child marriage …. it’s unacceptable in the modern era. I know some Mormons and other Christians do this too.


We are in the dawn of a new age…. Look at the liberal advancements in Saudi Arabia, for example. They are working with Israelis in some capacity ….to the chagrin of Muslim and Jewish racists
No Mormon does it liar. You still claim unauthorized off shoots are the church, that is like claiming protestants are Catholics.
 
And folks can use all the one liners and insults they want toward Islam, but especially if they are American or Christian their argument makes no logical sense. They would have to apply their argument to American society in the 19th century. So their argument therefore falls apart.

Yes, probably right now. Most child marriages in the world are in Muslim majority societies although it’s extremely rare. I believe it also occurs in Hindu majority areas that are very rural. It certainly does occur in some Mormons societies in Utah. It’s all rare though

BackAgain


Again Saudi Arabia is working with Israeli Jews in some capacities. So before getting all fired up the anti-Muslims especially those who are pro Jewish just take a chill pill.
quit lying about Mormons. If you have any facts to back up your ignorant claims link them.
 
Back
Top Bottom