One could argue that the ability to shop around for the best price would bring down the cost of insurance.
Take auto insurance as an example. if I have under X dollars of claims against my collision coverage I can avoid a surcharge or at least only get assessed a lesser surcharge.
If I need a fender repaired I am free to find a guy who will do it for the lowest price thereby keeping my premiums lower. We didn't have to abolish car insurance to do it.
Similarly, if my health insurance policy worked so that I was free to find the best deal on a CAT scan then my insurer would have less to pay out and premiums would go down.
there is no need to abolish insurance to implement this simple strategy.
right now your insurance company is doing the negotiating....if the hospital charges a thousand for the cat-scan, negotiated with the insurance company to only charge $600 for it.....
this hasn't brought the costs of healthcare to where it is affordable...even though they are getting 40% off of the catscan.... prices are still too high.
insurance companies do negotiate for the BEST PRICE already, only upfront....and prices are still through the roof....?
How can we know we are getting the best price when we are out of the loop?
And really, do you think the hospital would make a deal where they didn't get the maximum profit.
i guarantee you if the price of services was known, competition would spur a price war.
You would see things like CAT Scans R Us where you could get a doctor's order and walk in to get scanned at a cut rate price.
shit my Vet has an X ray in his clinic and the quality of the film is just as good as the one's you can get at a big people hospital. My vet charges less than 100 bucks for the same service the human doctor charges twice or three times as much for.
Why? because I can call the other 5 vets within 30 miles of me and ask what they charge for an x ray. I guarantee that we could get better prices than the insurance companies do.
let me use aetna group dental insurance as example....if i go to one of the dentists inside their negotiated group, to have a tooth pulled it is $75 bucks, but if you do not have dental insurance....which my mother does not, it is $140 bucks for the tooth extraction from the same dentist....
aetna has a tool online where you can get their negotiated price info for your or any zipcode and also get the 'normal' expected price without insurance for the procedure....
They negotiate a price per region they are in.... in maine where i am, the cost of these different dental procedures is 10%-20% higher than in Florida where my parents live, but their discount once negotiated is still comparable in the reduction in price...as example my insurance company may pay $90 bucks to an in network dentist up here, but the normal price for the procedure without insurance would be something like $170 bucks.
Well anyway, i gave this info to my mom and she said to herself, I'll be damned that they can only charge you "x" for the same thing they are charging me XX for...so she tried to negotiate with them....the best they would give her is a charge of $112, 20% off....so, my negotiated insurance price of $75 bucks is much greater savings than my mom's individual negotiating power...and she called several dentists to negotiate, not just one.
-------------------------------------------
I suppose what i am trying to say is that I do believe that insurance companies negotiate to the best of their ability and are not SLACK in that area and i believe they can negotiate better than the individual.
they would be negligent to their business if they did not get the best and cheapest price possible for the services of the hospital and doctor....and I am not certain that individuals have as much power in negotiation as individuals....
I guess I need more information on how this plan that you speak about would work....
Also, when you need a catscan, it is usually an emergency and taking the time to call around and negotiating the fee is not really that likely...
Health care does not seem to fit, like other widgets would....because you can bet your bottom dollar that I would check the prices of a 42 inch flat screen from every retailer out there before i buy it...and with routine health care, i might do such, but with any kind of emergency or critical situation, I would not even THINK about what this was costing me....it would be "save the life" first...that's all that would be on my mind.
Ideally, if insurance companies never got involved, if businesses were never encourage through tax breaks to buy insurance for their employees, if hospitals were never funded by the government for emergency rooms, if PHARMA was never funded with subsidies for R and D, and if the elderly were never given a government sponsored insurance such as medicare...you can not necessarily bet your bottom dollar that health care services would be much less expensive...because then the hospitals will be paying their own emergency room fees for the indigent, and PHARMA would be paying 40% more for their research and development, and all the elderly would either be turned down for their health care by the hospitals and die on us, unless they had boo coos of money....
the only thing that might come down in price are routine doctor visits i suppose? Because those would be the things that we could have the time to negotiate over...
I guess i just don;t understand how you forsee this working?