Calls for annexing West Bank, by Israeli Politicians.

[USAF 2023]

Israel did start military action in 1967.

You are not only a Pollack liar but a dumb stupid one. Egypt initiated the War by blocking the Straits .
Now please tell us why the U. N. “ peacekeepers “ deliberately left while Nasser was blocking Israel’s right to International Waters

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Arabs really got their asses kicked good, eh?

You’re such a Pollack Moron. You stated that Israel initiated the 67 War which is a lie .

Israel did start military action in 1967.

You are not only a Pollack liar but a dumb stupid one. Egypt initiated the War by blocking the Straits .
Now please tell us why the U. N. “ peacekeepers “ deliberately left while Nasser was blocking Israel’s right to International Waters

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Pollack liar refuses to answer my question. Egypt initiated the War by blocking Israel’s right to International Waters and the U.N. who was supposed to protect those waterways left

If so, surely Israel provoked the 1948 War, by stealing Palestinian lands.

Another Pollack lie. The International Community recognized Israel’s right to exist and the Arabs initiated the 67 War
Still waiting for the Dumb Pollack to explain WHY the U. N. Peacekeepers left

 

[Shusha]

Resistance?
How?
It's actually Colonialism.

No. Re-settlement of Israel, Judea and Samaria is resistance against the ideologies noted above and against the kind of erasure you committing by labeling Jewish return as "colonialism".

You can't colonialize your own homeland.

 

[Shusha]

Explain the Palestinian Arabic dialect?

My understanding is that there is a slight difference in the "g" sound. Regional difference. Shrug. What of it?

 

[Shusha]

Palestinians owned more land than Jews up into the 1940s.

I think you meant to say Arabs owned more land than Jews. They were ALL "Palestinians" from 1924 to 1948 (that is citizens under the Mandate for Palestine).

Arab land ownership is complicated. Far less land was under private Arab ownership, as we understand it in the West, than most people believe.


All irrelevant since private land ownership and sovereignty are two entirely separate things and the former does not give rise to the latter.

 

[ForeverYoung436]

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Arabs really got their asses kicked good, eh?

You are not only a Pollack liar but a dumb stupid one. Egypt initiated the War by blocking the Straits .
Now please tell us why the U. N. “ peacekeepers “ deliberately left while Nasser was blocking Israel’s right to International Waters

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Pollack liar refuses to answer my question. Egypt initiated the War by blocking Israel’s right to International Waters and the U.N. who was supposed to protect those waterways left

If so, surely Israel provoked the 1948 War, by stealing Palestinian lands.

Palestinian lands?
No such place.

Explain the Palestinian Arabic dialect?

First you explain why Israel has a distinct language of its own, Hebrew, while so-called "Palestine" shares a language with 22 other countries.

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

You are not only a Pollack liar but a dumb stupid one. Egypt initiated the War by blocking the Straits .
Now please tell us why the U. N. “ peacekeepers “ deliberately left while Nasser was blocking Israel’s right to International Waters

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Arabs really got their asses kicked good, eh?

Israel did start military action in 1967.

You are not only a Pollack liar but a dumb stupid one. Egypt initiated the War by blocking the Straits .
Now please tell us why the U. N. “ peacekeepers “ deliberately left while Nasser was blocking Israel’s right to International Waters

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Pollack liar refuses to answer my question. Egypt initiated the War by blocking Israel’s right to International Waters and the U.N. who was supposed to protect those waterways left

If so, surely Israel provoked the 1948 War, by stealing Palestinian lands.

Another Pollack lie. The International Community recognized Israel’s right to exist and the Arabs initiated the 67 War
Still waiting for the Dumb Pollack to explain WHY the U. N. Peacekeepers left

Oh please, Israel's existence to steal Palestinian land, provoked war, plain & simple.

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

Resistance?
How?
It's actually Colonialism.

Okay, the Jews are recognized as colonizators, Israel is recognized as an illegal state. They are demanded to give the land back to the Palestinians and they agree to abide by these demands. Now question rises. Where should several millions of Jews from Israel go? Which country must accept them?

The USA is fanatically pro-Jewish, they should donate some of their land for a new Israel.

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

Resistance?
How?
It's actually Colonialism.

No. Re-settlement of Israel, Judea and Samaria is resistance against the ideologies noted above and against the kind of erasure you committing by labeling Jewish return as "colonialism".

You can't colonialize your own homeland.

So, a bunch of Yiddish speakers with White skin, some how had rights to displace Palestinians, because 2,000 years ago a portion of their origins comes from the region?

Complete absurdity, of Biblical proportions.

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

Arabs really got their asses kicked good, eh?

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Pollack liar refuses to answer my question. Egypt initiated the War by blocking Israel’s right to International Waters and the U.N. who was supposed to protect those waterways left

If so, surely Israel provoked the 1948 War, by stealing Palestinian lands.

Palestinian lands?
No such place.

Explain the Palestinian Arabic dialect?

First you explain why Israel has a distinct language of its own, Hebrew, while so-called "Palestine" shares a language with 22 other countries.

The Palestinian dialect is unique from other Arabic dialects.

Besides, most Jews prior to Israel, did not speak Hebrew first, but rather other languages, including Yiddish, Arabic, and yada, yada.

 

[ESay]

Resistance?
How?
It's actually Colonialism.

Okay, the Jews are recognized as colonizators, Israel is recognized as an illegal state. They are demanded to give the land back to the Palestinians and they agree to abide by these demands. Now question rises. Where should several millions of Jews from Israel go? Which country must accept them?

The USA is fanatically pro-Jewish, they should donate some of their land for a new Israel.

What do you mean they? You are an American citizen as far as I can understand, so you should say we.
So, you are in favor of the idea of resettling several millions of Jews in your country?

 

[Shusha]

So, a bunch of Yiddish speakers with White skin, some how had rights to displace Palestinians, because 2,000 years ago a portion of their origins comes from the region?

Complete absurdity, of Biblical proportions.

Well no. A displaced people, speaking a number of different languages, and having a variety of skin tones, and from a number of different locations they were displaced to returned to their homeland where they all originated.

Did you want to argue that a displaced people have no right to return to their homeland?

 

[Shusha]

The Palestinian dialect is unique from other Arabic dialects.

Besides, most Jews prior to Israel, did not speak Hebrew first, but rather other languages, including Yiddish, Arabic, and yada, yada.

The Jewish people largely retained the Hebrew language through thousands of years in the Diaspora. That they also speak other languages is irrelevant.

If you are trying to argue that the Arab Palestinians are a distinct people, in part due to a small regional difference in the pronunciation of a consonant, you can hardly argue that the Jewish people are not a distinct people despite speaking a unique language for 4000 or so years.

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

The Palestinian dialect is unique from other Arabic dialects.

Besides, most Jews prior to Israel, did not speak Hebrew first, but rather other languages, including Yiddish, Arabic, and yada, yada.

The Jewish people largely retained the Hebrew language through thousands of years in the Diaspora. That they also speak other languages is irrelevant.

If you are trying to argue that the Arab Palestinians are a distinct people, in part due to a small regional difference in the pronunciation of a consonant, you can hardly argue that the Jewish people are not a distinct people despite speaking a unique language for 4000 or so years.

Not really, for example only something like 5% of Poland's Jews spoke Hebrew first.

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

So, a bunch of Yiddish speakers with White skin, some how had rights to displace Palestinians, because 2,000 years ago a portion of their origins comes from the region?

Complete absurdity, of Biblical proportions.

Well no. A displaced people, speaking a number of different languages, and having a variety of skin tones, and from a number of different locations they were displaced to returned to their homeland where they all originated.

Did you want to argue that a displaced people have no right to return to their homeland?

What homeland?
It was another people's homeland for 1,400 years.
It's complete insanity, to think you had the right to displace them after that long.

 

[USAF 2023]

Pollack liar refuses to answer my question. Egypt initiated the War by blocking Israel’s right to International Waters and the U.N. who was supposed to protect those waterways left

If so, surely Israel provoked the 1948 War, by stealing Palestinian lands.

Palestinian lands?
No such place.

Explain the Palestinian Arabic dialect?

First you explain why Israel has a distinct language of its own, Hebrew, while so-called "Palestine" shares a language with 22 other countries.

The Palestinian dialect is unique from other Arabic dialects.

Besides, most Jews prior to Israel, did not speak Hebrew first, but rather other languages, including Yiddish, Arabic, and yada, yada.

The Jewish State came into fruition by the U. N. Don’t like it? Too bad
Prior to Israel most Jews spoke Yiddish? So????

 

[USAF 2023]

Resistance?
How?
It's actually Colonialism.

Okay, the Jews are recognized as colonizators, Israel is recognized as an illegal state. They are demanded to give the land back to the Palestinians and they agree to abide by these demands. Now question rises. Where should several millions of Jews from Israel go? Which country must accept them?

The USA is fanatically pro-Jewish, they should donate some of their land for a new Israel.

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Arabs really got their asses kicked good, eh?

You are not only a Pollack liar but a dumb stupid one. Egypt initiated the War by blocking the Straits .
Now please tell us why the U. N. “ peacekeepers “ deliberately left while Nasser was blocking Israel’s right to International Waters

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Pollack liar refuses to answer my question. Egypt initiated the War by blocking Israel’s right to International Waters and the U.N. who was supposed to protect those waterways left

If so, surely Israel provoked the 1948 War, by stealing Palestinian lands.

Another Pollack lie. The International Community recognized Israel’s right to exist and the Arabs initiated the 67 War
Still waiting for the Dumb Pollack to explain WHY the U. N. Peacekeepers left

Oh please, Israel's existence to steal Palestinian land, provoked war, plain & simple.

Oh please, the Arab Wars that they initiated was to wipe Israel off the face of the map

 

[Shusha]

So, a bunch of Yiddish speakers with White skin, some how had rights to displace Palestinians, because 2,000 years ago a portion of their origins comes from the region?

Complete absurdity, of Biblical proportions.

Well no. A displaced people, speaking a number of different languages, and having a variety of skin tones, and from a number of different locations they were displaced to returned to their homeland where they all originated.

Did you want to argue that a displaced people have no right to return to their homeland?

What homeland?
It was another people's homeland for 1,400 years.
It's complete insanity, to think you had the right to displace them after that long.

In acknowledging that it was "another people's homeland" and giving the starting point of that homeland as 1400 years ago -- the time of the Arab conquest and colonization -- you are displaying your acceptance of colonialization. At least, when its Arabs doing the colonizing. You can't have it both ways. Either you accept colonialization as a valid "transfer of homeland" or you do not.

Be clear what my position is:

1. The Jewish people have a right to return to their historical homeland. ALL of them, regardless of race, language or place of Diaspora. Subject to the rules of the State of Israel.

2. The Arab Palestinian people have a right to return to their historical homeland. Subject to the rules of the (eventual, maybe) State of Palestine.

3. The Jewish people have a right to self-determination based on the culture and values of the Jewish people on part of the territory as sovereigns.

4. The Arab Palestinian people have a right to self-determination based on the culture and values of the Arab Palestinian people on part of the territory as sovereigns.

5. The Jewish people have a right to live in peace and security within their sovereign territory.

6. The Arab Palestinian people have a right to live in peace and security within their sovereign territory.

Are you sensing the theme here? BOTH peoples have the SAME rights.


There is and never was a "right" to displace peoples. On either side. Nor was there ever a "right" to colonize people. There is and was a conflict between these two peoples, largely driven by one group's intent to erase the other, in many small and large ways. The Jewish people refuse to be erased.

 

[Shusha]

The Palestinian dialect is unique from other Arabic dialects.

Besides, most Jews prior to Israel, did not speak Hebrew first, but rather other languages, including Yiddish, Arabic, and yada, yada.

The Jewish people largely retained the Hebrew language through thousands of years in the Diaspora. That they also speak other languages is irrelevant.

If you are trying to argue that the Arab Palestinians are a distinct people, in part due to a small regional difference in the pronunciation of a consonant, you can hardly argue that the Jewish people are not a distinct people despite speaking a unique language for 4000 or so years.

Not really, for example only something like 5% of Poland's Jews spoke Hebrew first.

Its irrelevant how many languages people learn or how old they are when they learn them. The Hebrew language was preserved for thousands of years in the Diaspora.

If language is one of the measures of a distinct people, as you seem to be arguing, the Jewish people certainly meet that measure.

 

[Shusha]

SobieskiSavedEurope

You keep wanting to have different rules for the Jewish people than for other peoples.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Arabs really got their asses kicked good, eh?

You are not only a Pollack liar but a dumb stupid one. Egypt initiated the War by blocking the Straits .
Now please tell us why the U. N. “ peacekeepers “ deliberately left while Nasser was blocking Israel’s right to International Waters

Operation Focus was the first military action in the 6 Day War.
It was done by Israel, no lie there.

Pollack liar refuses to answer my question. Egypt initiated the War by blocking Israel’s right to International Waters and the U.N. who was supposed to protect those waterways left

If so, surely Israel provoked the 1948 War, by stealing Palestinian lands.

Another Pollack lie. The International Community recognized Israel’s right to exist and the Arabs initiated the 67 War
Still waiting for the Dumb Pollack to explain WHY the U. N. Peacekeepers left

Oh please, Israel's existence to steal Palestinian land, provoked war, plain & simple.

They seriously kicked some Arab ass.