- Aug 4, 2009
- 281,171
- 140,755
- 2,615
We can discuss US Grant, Robert E. Lee, George Patton and most other American heroes but pop-culture has determined that there are certain icons that cannot be questioned and if you do you risk emotional outbursts. Everything we know or think we know about PT 109 is based on a puff piece called "Survivor" written by family friend John Hersey and published in the New Yorker magazine in 1944. The notion that JFK is a hero because he swam out to a coral reef and forlornly waved a lantern at passing ships hoping to hitch a ride is ludicrous. Maybe it indicates his lack of leadership but it isn't an example of clear thinking. JFK confessed that he was worried about the fallout over PT 109 and rightfully so but the article turned things around.
Sometimes you just have to have facts to support your wild conspiracy theories. There has been plenty of chances to interview the crew of PT 109. If they thought their young officer had screwed the pooch and almost cost them their lives, they would have bitched about it. Not just officially, but to any other sailor in the fleet as well as their family and friends
But you don't have a record of that do you?