Song covers in different genres...

[Pogo]

no more for me here

it's both songs or nothing.

sorry babies that's how it is with moi.

You ran out of music too huh?

 

[Montrovant]

I dunno, that's parsing a genre into razor-thin slices.

"Different genre" to me means more like

​

No, that's not razor-thin at all. The original sounds much different than Amos's version.

Here's the original:


The Tori Amos version:


And for fun, here's a heavier version by some band called Bruthal 6:


All 3 from pretty clearly different genres.

Sure it's razor-thin, they're both contemporary pop. "Different genres" would be classical, funk, jazz, etc If you consider everything that sounds different as, a genre then we have infinity genres.

Neither Nirvana nor Tori Amos are contemporary pop. Nirvana was a grunge band. I'm not sure what genre Tori Amos fits into, indie/alternative or something like that. Neither is pop. Grunge might be called a sub-genre of rock, but Tori Amos is certainly not rock.

 

[skye]

no more for me here

it's both songs or nothing.

sorry babies that's how it is with moi.

You ran out of music too huh?

I ran from things I think are wrong.

but that's ok too

it' only me and my opinion

 

[Montrovant]

you have to put both songs

yes?

not only one

or am I wrong?

I've just been posting the covers, not the originals.

Actually it slows the page loading if you post more videos. I've been assuming the audience knows the original.

But Skye --- when it comes to music you're never wrong.

Yeah, I figure if someone is curious, it isn't hard to find the original on youtube or elsewhere. It's slow enough to load pages already with all the videos being embedded.

 

[Pogo]

For skye , with love

​

Neither of those is the original though

 

[skye]

nice ^^^ I like that song

 

[Pogo]

I dunno, that's parsing a genre into razor-thin slices.

"Different genre" to me means more like

​

No, that's not razor-thin at all. The original sounds much different than Amos's version.

Here's the original:


The Tori Amos version:


And for fun, here's a heavier version by some band called Bruthal 6:


All 3 from pretty clearly different genres.

Sure it's razor-thin, they're both contemporary pop. "Different genres" would be classical, funk, jazz, etc If you consider everything that sounds different as, a genre then we have infinity genres.

Neither Nirvana nor Tori Amos are contemporary pop. Nirvana was a grunge band. I'm not sure what genre Tori Amos fits into, indie/alternative or something like that. Neither is pop. Grunge might be called a sub-genre of rock, but Tori Amos is certainly not rock.

Of course she is. They both are. Are they jazz? Are they reggae? Samba? Folk? Baroque? Salsa?
None of the above. You're trying to subgenre the subgenres.

 

[Pogo]

nice ^^^ I like that song

I know you do. That's why I put it in there.

 

[Pogo]

Rolf Harris - Stairway to Heaven

( skye if you don't know the original you're not missing anything.... )

Dig who's painted on his wobble board.

​

 

[MarathonMike]

 

[MarathonMike]

 

[MarathonMike]

 

[MarathonMike]

You'll get a chuckle out of this one

 

[Pogo]

He reminds me of someone

can't put my finger on it

The Carpenters?

 

[Pogo]

You'll get a chuckle out of this one

Don't know what genre this is but pretty sure it's a different one

​

 

[Pogo]

which segues to

​

 

[daveman]

you have to put both songs

yes?

not only one

or am I wrong?

Just the cover is fine.

 

[daveman]

you have to put both songs

yes?

not only one

or am I wrong?

I've just been posting the covers, not the originals.

ok thank for your reply


I like both originals and covers otherwise it doesnt make any sense to me


so

i wont post more here MUAH! lol

Of course you can post both!

 

[daveman]

Ya beat me to this one.

It's incredible, isn't it?

 

[daveman]

no more for me here

it's both songs or nothing.

sorry babies that's how it is with moi.

Then post both. The more participation the merrier!