Is Trump's wife an illegal immigrant?

[Juan de Fuca]

if you marry an American that makes you an American. That balloon was easy to pop.

No, it entitles you to a visa it does not entitle you to citizenship. You have to go through the motions like everyone else.

 

[Camp]

if you marry an American that makes you an American. That balloon was easy to pop.

No, it doesn't, it qualifies you to apply for citizenship after five years of marriage. Even than the person has to pass a citizenship test.

 

[Howey]

Word on the streets is she came to the U.S. a year earlier than she and Donald claim - as an illegal immigrant!

 

[Conservative65]

I said the named spelled Shithead was pronounced Sha Thed. While the name was pronounced differently than it spelled, the kid, according to my friend, acted like a shithead and a pronunciation of shithead would have been far more accurate.

Never saw the internet meme. Stated something that occurred. Hate to break it to you asshole but your acceptance isn't required for it to be true in either case. Learn it.

Wrong because you made up both instances and you actually stooped low enough to make fun of a child's name. What you stated was in fact an internet meme and it could not have happened as you said it did.

If you claim I made them up, prove it.

Maybe you didn't understand. You not believing doesn't change the truth and the fact that it is real.

Prove what? I showed where you deliberately changed a child's name to be something it wasn't and I posted an internet meme that was 8 years old and described perfectly what your wife told you was a disciplinary action when it couldn't have been. You've created fantasy out of whole cloth and expect people to believe it. It isn't true none of it.

I didn't change a name. The name was spelled "Shithead" as I said and pronounced "Sha-Thed", as I said. That the person acted like a shithead has nothing to do with the spelling or the pronunciation.

You haven't shown anything. You claimed, without proof, that it happened the way you claim.

Still waiting on your proof.

You changed a name to make fun of a child. No parent is going to name their kid "shithead" and pronounce it sha-thed. You twisted the spelling. see explanation #4 Urban Dictionary: shithead The second part was made up because a meme from 8 years ago, is not going to give credence to a discipline letter that your wife "heard about" when it is an established urban legend. Le-a

You need to get out more, attempting to pass racial humor as genuine is pretty fucking sad.

I know of one situation, therefore, you're wrong. I didn't twist the spelling, I typed it phonetically so that the way it was pronounced was easy to see. If I saw the spelling of "Shithead", I would call the person Shit head never thinking it was pronounced otherwise.

As for the second one, I have a real life example. It wasn't something my wife heard about. She worked with the nurse that receive the write up.

It's not racial humor but the fact that blacks name their kids things like that is funny. What's not funny is the kid has to live with the name their entire life.

 

[Auld Phart]

Word on the streets is she came to the U.S. a year earlier than she and Donald claim - as an illegal immigrant!

Interesting

She 'snuck' into the US to appear on popular magazine covers.

 

[Juan de Fuca]

Wrong because you made up both instances and you actually stooped low enough to make fun of a child's name. What you stated was in fact an internet meme and it could not have happened as you said it did.

If you claim I made them up, prove it.

Maybe you didn't understand. You not believing doesn't change the truth and the fact that it is real.

Prove what? I showed where you deliberately changed a child's name to be something it wasn't and I posted an internet meme that was 8 years old and described perfectly what your wife told you was a disciplinary action when it couldn't have been. You've created fantasy out of whole cloth and expect people to believe it. It isn't true none of it.

I didn't change a name. The name was spelled "Shithead" as I said and pronounced "Sha-Thed", as I said. That the person acted like a shithead has nothing to do with the spelling or the pronunciation.

You haven't shown anything. You claimed, without proof, that it happened the way you claim.

Still waiting on your proof.

You changed a name to make fun of a child. No parent is going to name their kid "shithead" and pronounce it sha-thed. You twisted the spelling. see explanation #4 Urban Dictionary: shithead The second part was made up because a meme from 8 years ago, is not going to give credence to a discipline letter that your wife "heard about" when it is an established urban legend. Le-a

You need to get out more, attempting to pass racial humor as genuine is pretty fucking sad.

I know of one situation, therefore, you're wrong. I didn't twist the spelling, I typed it phonetically so that the way it was pronounced was easy to see. If I saw the spelling of "Shithead", I would call the person Shit head never thinking it was pronounced otherwise.

As for the second one, I have a real life example. It wasn't something my wife heard about. She worked with the nurse that receive the write up.

It's not racial humor but the fact that blacks name their kids things like that is funny. What's not funny is the kid has to live with the name their entire life.

How odd that both of your examples have been debunked as urban legends. I really don't know what to say to you except they are poor examples of racial slurs and somehow you think they are fact. They are disproven and I linked the examples, how you got to to this point is your problem.

 

[tinydancer]

Word on the streets is she came to the U.S. a year earlier than she and Donald claim - as an illegal immigrant!

No. Her modelling agency would send her on shoots and they would be responsible for her paperwork as well. She was travelling all over like most models do. This shoot was in New York apparently. Models like entertainers are fluid and are constantly travelling.

Melania would have had to have had paperwork for the shoot. And that would have been handled by her agency.

 

[The Great Goose]

no one cares.

 

[tinydancer]

And just an FYI, there is nothing shocking about nudity in European magazines. It's all par for the course. 12 supermodels posed for Lui/ all covers/and a calendar.

It's against the rules to put up a link.

 

[the_human_being]

Why didn't they PROVE their allegations? Should be easy enough to do. Her posing for a FRENCH magazine in 1995 raises no red flag for me if she claims to have been in the US in 1996. FRANCE is not the US.

She modeled in New York for a French magazine.

I still see no proof of any wrongdoing on her part. Where's the proof? Talk is worth nothing.

Here is an explanation in a nutshell.

"An ex-agent, Pablo Zampolli, has told the Associated Press that he personally secured an H-1B for her. If that’s what in fact happened, there’s no story here.

The problem is that some of Melania’s past statements make it seem like that wasn’t what she did.

On a couple of occasions, Melania has told reporters that after coming to the United States, she had to return to Slovenia “every few months” to get her visa renewed. That’s not something you have to do if you’re on a work visa. It is something you have to do if you’re on a six-month tourist visa, like the B-1 visa for “temporary business visitors.”

But if Melania was on a tourist visa, then, as a rule, she shouldn’t have been able to work for hire in the United States. Yet people who were active in the modeling industry at the time say it was common for Eastern European models to come here on B-1 tourist visas and work anyway."

The problem is Melania Trump's conflicting statements, it's up to her to correct the record.

No. Actually it's up to the reporter for the smear piece to publish facts that back up his claim. If the reporter fails to back up his smear piece, he has no real credibility as a journalist.

Yes, that makes sense since HB visas are subject to FOIA, but that will take substantial time to produce. It would be easier if Mrs Trump came forward with an explanation that could clear it up. Until then she will remain under a cloud deservedly or not.

Only in your mind. If there's evidence let the publication produce the evidence.

 

[the_human_being]

Word on the streets is she came to the U.S. a year earlier than she and Donald claim - as an illegal immigrant!

Again - Prove it. Otherwise it is simply smear.

 

[Ravi]

Improperly documented

yep. There is actually a difference there, I'll let you figure it out.

Actually, there isn't.

Ravi, he is in fact correct. Those who overstay their visas and such are not considered or counted as undocumented. Words have meanings, you've never seemed to understand that.

Sure they are. Expired documents means undocumented no matter how you try to spin it.

Undocumented means not recorded. Expired means out of date. The two aren't the same. To say they are is like saying you can have something that is out of date that never existed.

Do you have a driver's license? If so, if it expires, does that mean you never had one? It means the one you have is out of date. Expired doesn't mean undocumented.

Yes it does.

 

[Pogo]

The idea of the Giant Orange Birfer being complicit in something like this is an irony that's delicious enough to have for dinner.

 

[StLucieBengal]

First off this would have been covered by the interview and investigation that everyone who marries a non us citizen goes through. So for anyone to act like this is anything is a joke .

For those who think that they are hitting him with a gotcha ..... you just dont understand the immigration process..... Not to mention there is loads of missing information here.... like...........

If she came on a non work visa and did this photo shoot, was she paid? If not did she receive rent money and stipends in lieu?
How did she get a green card? Did her employer sponsor her?

Her employer is responsible for her work visa. She didnt sneak across the border like a mexican. So she had to come through a POE legally. If she tried to come without the proper information she would have been denied and returned from where she came.

This is not even close to being a trump issue. And it cant be a Melania issue either since the Petitioner (her employer) holds responsibility and control of the petition.

If it's a tourist visa then we go back up to the earlier questions I posted. But it's not against the visa to have your photo taken.

 

[Syriusly]

Gaps in Melania Trump's immigration story raise questions

While Trump and her husband, Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, have said she came to the United States legally, her own statements suggest she first came to the country on a short-term visa that would not have authorized her to work as a model. Trump has also said she came to New York in 1996, but the nude photo shoot places her in the United States in 1995, as does a biography published in February by Slovenian journalists.

This would be pretty damn funny if true.

Funny but irrelevant.

 

[Correll]

Gaps in Melania Trump's immigration story raise questions

While Trump and her husband, Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, have said she came to the United States legally, her own statements suggest she first came to the country on a short-term visa that would not have authorized her to work as a model. Trump has also said she came to New York in 1996, but the nude photo shoot places her in the United States in 1995, as does a biography published in February by Slovenian journalists.

This would be pretty damn funny if true.

And now you are concerned about enforcing immigration laws?

LOL!!

 

[MarathonMike]

So the plagiarism mudball didn't stick to the wall so now you're trying illegal alien. Keep digging because that's how you determine for us who would be the best President.

 

[cnm]

Every time I think it can't get any better, it does.

 

[aris2chat]

Word on the streets is she came to the U.S. a year earlier than she and Donald claim - as an illegal immigrant!

She obtained a work visa before she modeled professionally in the United States in the mid-1990s. Standard H-1B Temporary Work Visa for models. She arrived in 1996 to the US.

She married Trump in 2005

The nude photos were from a French Magazine taken in 1995 by a French photographer, not taken in the US for a US magazine.

 

[Conservative65]

yep. There is actually a difference there, I'll let you figure it out.

Actually, there isn't.

Ravi, he is in fact correct. Those who overstay their visas and such are not considered or counted as undocumented. Words have meanings, you've never seemed to understand that.

Sure they are. Expired documents means undocumented no matter how you try to spin it.

Undocumented means not recorded. Expired means out of date. The two aren't the same. To say they are is like saying you can have something that is out of date that never existed.

Do you have a driver's license? If so, if it expires, does that mean you never had one? It means the one you have is out of date. Expired doesn't mean undocumented.

Yes it does.

I explained the difference. If you're too fucking stupid to understand, let me know. Wait, you already did.