Christianity's single requirement and Islam's plenty

Muhammed is a messenger not a fortune teller. They had schools for prophets in Israel.
If you resort to semantics then you've already lost the argument.

Israeli prophets are examined by wisdom, might and wealth.

Illiterate, weak, and in debt men - are not prophets.
 
Last edited:
If you resort to semantics then you've already lost the argument.

Israeli prophets are examined by wisdom, might and wealth.

Illiterate, weak, and in debt men - are not prophets.

Most prophecy is after the fact. That's why scripture was amended.
 
Most prophecy is after the fact. That's why scripture was amended.

Before you try understand the prophecy in scripture,
can you answer if you hold the Islamist belief
that a prophet can be illiterate?

Until then it's like discussing Quantum physics
with a 1st graders struggling a second year...
 
Before you try understand the prophecy in scripture,
can you answer if you hold the Islamist belief
that a prophet can be illiterate?

Until then it's like discussing Quantum physics
with a 1st graders struggling a second year...

Why would I believe Muslim beliefs?

Vaticinium ex eventu - Wikipedia
vāticinium ex ēventū (Classical Latin: [wäːt̪ɪˈkɪnɪ.ʊ̃ˑ ɛks eːˈwɛn̪t̪uː], "prophecy from the event") or post eventum ("after the event") is a technical theological or historiographical term referring to a prophecy written after the author already had information about the events being "foretold". The text is written so as to appear that the prophecy had taken place before ...
 
Why would I believe Muslim beliefs?

Vaticinium ex eventu - Wikipedia
vāticinium ex ēventū (Classical Latin: [wäːt̪ɪˈkɪnɪ.ʊ̃ˑ ɛks eːˈwɛn̪t̪uː], "prophecy from the event") or post eventum ("after the event") is a technical theological or historiographical term referring to a prophecy written after the author already had information about the events being "foretold". The text is written so as to appear that the prophecy had taken place before ...
But you don't answer.

Do we agree that following an illiterate 'prophet' is ridiculous?
 
Why would you follow any prophet?

Me? Because I'm a son of prophets,
born to the very nation that brought prophecy.

And if we're already talking about 'following any prophet',
is the best that the Muslims find to offer this world - an illiterate charlatan?
 
Last edited:
Me? Because I'm a son of prophets,
born to the very nation that brought prophecy in this world.

But are we talking about me 'any prophet' - rather the one Muslims follow, the illiterate one?t

Muhammed's message to the people of the Arabian peninsula was, "Save yourselves. I cannot save you. Return to the God of Abraham."
 
Muhammed's message to the people of the Arabian peninsula was, "Save yourselves. I cannot save you. Return to the God of Abraham."
But the prophets of the God of Abraham must be wise men...

Does it mean illiterate Muhammad
can't be a prophet even according to Islam?
 
Last edited:
But the prophets of the God of Abraham must be wise men...

Does it mean illiterate Muhammad
can't be a prophet even according to Islam?

Evidently Muhammed had a vision just like all the patriarchs and prophets.
 
Evidently Muhammed had a vision just like all the patriarchs and prophets.
Evidently - if according to Islam a prophet is an illiterate man with visions,
they can follow just anyone in a mental institute, where such Muhammads in abundance,
exactly the reason for the Muslim world's such abysmal intellectual and social degradation.

Because in the Muslim desperation to compensate for Muhammad's illiteracy,
they forget that the very patriarch and prophets he's compared to were wise,
who warned us about many such madmen - hence results of Islam.

It still remains a question - whether Islam is even monotheism?
 
Last edited:
Evidently - if according to Islam a prophet is an illiterate man with visions,
they can follow just anyone in a mental institute, where such Muhammads in abundance,
exactly the reason for the Muslim world's such abysmal intellectual and social degradation.

Because in the Muslim desperation to compensate for Muhammad's illiteracy,
they forget that the Israeli patriarchs and prophets to whom he's compared,
warned us clearly against such madmen - hence results.

It's remains a question - whether Islam is even monotheism?

All your prophets and patriarchs had visions and there no reason to think they were literate. Heck, nobody wrote the Pentateuch down until Moses was dead 850 years.
 
All your prophets and patriarchs had visions and there no reason to think they were literate. Heck, nobody wrote the Pentateuch down until Moses was dead 850 years.
Are you really that simpleton?

Israeli prophets were examined by their wisdom, strength and wealth,
an illiterate man - by mere definition cannot be a prophet.

But I can see how questioning others makes you feel better
about compensating for Muhammad illiteracy...

Just look at the results -
Are Muhhamad's followers the least literate people on earth?

 
Are you really that simpleton?

Israeli prophets were examined by their wisdom, strength and wealth,
an illiterate man - by mere definition cannot be a prophet.

But I can see how questioning others makes you feel better
about compensating for Muhammad illiteracy...

Just look at the results -
Are Muhhamad's followers the least literate people on earth?


I think you are pitifully insecure to attack Islam.

Adam and Ever were running around naked while Babylon already had irrigation, agriculture, a written language and sailboats.
 
I think you are pitifully insecure to attack Islam.

Adam and Ever were running around naked while Babylon already had irrigation, agriculture, a written language and sailboats.

Talking about insecurity, I think you merely pretend to be THAT dumb,
to evade inconvenient questions -

Is it attack on Islam - to question the legacy of following illiterate Muhammad,
resulting in Arabs becoming the largest illiterate group on earth?


Is it an attack on Islam - to question if it's even Monotheism?
 
Last edited:
Talking about insecurity, I think you merely pretend to be THAT dumb,
to evade inconvenient questions, no Muslim scholar had the courage to touch.

Q. Is it attack on Islam - to question the legacy of following illiterate Muhammad,
resulting in Arabs becoming the largest illiterate group on earth?

Q. Or is it an attack on Islam - to question if it's even monotheism?

LOLOL.. Jesus and Moses and Abraham never wrote anything down either... nor did Solomon or King David.

You really are insecure.
 
LOLOL.. Jesus and Moses and Abraham never wrote anything down either... nor did Solomon or King David.

You really are insecure.

See you don't have the courage to address a single question about Islam,
without projecting its weaknesses on others, to compensate for Muhammad's illiteracy.

Q. Let's ask differently - if you argue they were illiterate as Muhammad,
then how come their followers became the most educated people,
while followers of Muhammad became the least literate group?

Q. What causes this intellectual depravity
among Muhammad's followers?
 
Last edited:
See you don't have the courage to address a single question about Islam,
without projecting its weaknesses on others, to compensate for Muhammad's illiteracy.

So let's ask differently - if you argue they were illiterate as Muhammad,
then how come their followers became the most educated people,
while followers of Muhammad became the least literate group?

What then is the cause of intellectual depravity of Islam?

They have a notable history.. You just have some sort of need to prove your "superiority:.
 
They have a notable history.. You just have some sort of need to prove your "superiority:.

I wouldn't consider it superiority,
to excel over people who weren't taught basic reading.

So, tell us -

what "notable history"
made Muhammad's followers
the least literate group on earth?
 
I wouldn't consider it superiority,
to excel over people who weren't taught basic reading.

So, tell us -

what "notable history"
made Muhammad's followers
the least literate group on earth?

There are a couple billion Muslims so many of them aren't educated, but they did use the Kamal and drip irrigation and preserve the works of Aristotle. You might look at the Akkadian Empire. They were from Arabia.. Sargon was also an Arab.
 

Forum List

Back
Top