First off, it teaches that others besides whites have done things. Coyote, whites are where they are now because of things you say you had nothing to do with. And this is not about teaching whites to feel guilty. That is what you have been race pimped to believe. In this complete teaching of history, the positive accomplishments of whites have not been ignored. I did not create white preference, the system did. Non whites are not the ones that created the term. A white female did. And I don't think you have any doubt that there is male privilege and specifically white male privilege. The facts support that just as the facts support white racial preferences. So do I complain about how men are being made to feel guilty? Do I endeavor to make the changes I am required to based on the facts I am shown? Or do I spend years whining in every forum available about how I should not feel guilty about what I didn't do like most of these guys do.
Institutional racism has been considered by the supreme court to be a continuing problem. This means whites today, right now, benefit only because of their skin color. As long as whites refuse to do what is necessary to completely end institutional racism, you are doing the same thing that was done in the past.
Coyote, things are not the same for blacks and whites. Racism has not ended, the method of exclusion is not as overt, but it still happens. Because of this, whites do get into college because of white privilege and do get hired and promoted based on skin color. It is a false equivalence to compare that to what you said in your last sentence.
So in the end, why do I have to learn I descend from people who were made to be slaves but whites think they have the right to feel butthurt because there are some not so nice events in their history?
You make good points, but I guess, from where I am coming from, I tend to see a lot of generalizing whites as if they are all the same and think the same. I dislike seeing this targeting of any group.
And I take issue with this:
Institutional racism has been considered by the supreme court to be a continuing problem. This means whites today, right now, benefit only because of their skin color. As long as whites refuse to do what is necessary to completely end institutional racism, you are doing the same thing that was done in the past.
I don’t disagree with the concept of institutionalized racism. I do, however, disagree strongly with the idea that every white personal owes his or her success solely to skin color. To me, that is as offensive as the claim that blacks owe their success solely due to affirmative action.
You are talking about whites as a monolithic entity that is failing to do what is necessary...yet they are not monolithic, and I think it is wrong to judge them in that way.
What do you think they should be doing that they are not?
I don't think of whites like that, but when I have to hear whites telling me how blacks have been given everything and don't want to work, the reality that American history show us must be displayed. I realize you are a good, decent and fair minded person, but the reality is that this system has and continues to provide whites with preferences others don't get. And coyote to say the only reason blacks make it is due to AA is factually incorrect, white racial preferences are fact. Affirmative Action was not just for blacks and whites have benefitted the most from the policy. Specifically white women.
White Women and Affirmative Action: Prime Beneficiaries and Opponents -
Now why is it up to me to tell you what whites need to be doing? I think that If you realize what was done in the past and are aware of the fact that racism exists today, you might start understanding how people like me say what I do. According to every white person I have met since I was in college 1979-1984, 1986-88, no white person descended from slave owners, none had anything to do with segregation, none of them have ever benefitted from being white, they all had it worse than blacks, and they have faced racism that makes Jim Crow look like Christmas. I was told in 1973 in 7th grade that racism was over, even as 2 days later I got into a fight with a white kid who decided I was the n word. So I think that after over 40 years of hearing excuses you have to understand why I might just be a little low on patience.
It is up to you, because you made the declaration that it needs to be done, so it is reasonable for me to ask what you think should be done.
I also think each person needs to be taken as an individual, and these conversations tend to make sweeping generalizations on both sides.
Does racism still exist in this country? Yes, it does, I won’t argue that. But many problems faced by black communities are caused by multiple and complex factors, which in some cases may not be racism but the legacy of racism perpetuated by economic disparities.
I agree with your statements on AA, that it wasn’t only blacks that benefited. The point I was making is people who use that argument completely minimize the contribution of merit, as if that person could not possibly have accomplished what he did on the basis of merit. And that same argument can be made for white privilege.
If you were to ask ME, as a white person, what “white people” should do, I would have a difficult time answering, because I am not seeing it through the same lens you do exactly.
I see a problem such as this for example: many poor neighborhoods tend to be lacking in good infrastructure, good schools, safe programs for youth, and they tend to be the places where industrial dumps and landfills get located, and other sorts of things that affect health and quality of life. Often these areas are predominately black, but not always. The people living there lack political power and funding. So...racism could be playing a role here but how would you address the issues? And the issues themselves faced by many poor communitees. Do you address it from the aspect of race? Or, do organize, publicize, attract attention and investment from a community perspective?
.
A person has to get an opportunity to work before they can say they didn't make it due to color but because of hard work. And this is the part you have missed Coyote, when you talk about how unfair it is for people to say certain things about whites.
I agree, but it is still unfair to make statements about white privalege not merit, being the main driving factor.