Carter destroyed the economy
Reagan destroyed the Soviet Union
Bush Sr was a weak one termer who got stabbed in the back by Dems over taxes
Clinton got his dick sucked in the Oval Office and lied about it so he was impeached and disbarred
Bush had the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq
Obama?
Carter's the only POTUS since Hoover who never had a war, never dropped a bomb, never fired a shot.
Reagan
trickled down flooded the deficit trying to outrun the Soviet Union (which was still in place when he left)
Bush I invaded a sovereign country to play cop. Also threw up on Japanese PM...
Clinton weaseled the CFMA while no one was looking and TelComm 96 while no one was reporting...
Bush II -- pointless war and of course many contributions to the English nonlaguage
Obama got economy turned back upright, but foisted the ACA
So, mixed. I'd say economy was the more important of the two.