What do you understand about FDR? Did FDR want a war with Japan? For answers, check here

[Mushroom]

The AVG were mercenaries, at least legally. FDR was giving China what assistance he could. The AVG didn’t enter combat until after Pearl.

"Mercenaries", just like the "People's Volunteer Army" in the Korean War were.

And for the first 5 months were concentrating on assembling their aircraft and preparing their facilities. The aircraft were not flown there, they were sent in crates and had to be assembled on site.

Everybody knows that was entirely a fiction, even then. They were all Navy, Army, and Marine Corps pilots. And after the war started, they were quickly inducted into the Army Air Corps. Other than a few like Greg Boyington, who heard that and quickly left to return to the US because he did not want to serve in the Army again.

 

[Mushroom]

You think that was FOR China? How stupid are you?

And this is rather typical for you. A denial, an insult, and nothing to support your claim.

Poopy, do not act like you are a child.

 

[Unkotare]

And this is rather typical for you. A denial, an insult, and nothing to support your claim.

...

"Nothing"? How ignorant of history can you be?

 

[AZrailwhale]

"Mercenaries", just like the "People's Volunteer Army" in the Korean War were.

And for the first 5 months were concentrating on assembling their aircraft and preparing their facilities. The aircraft were not flown there, they were sent in crates and had to be assembled on site.

Everybody knows that was entirely a fiction, even then. They were all Navy, Army, and Marine Corps pilots. And after the war started, they were quickly inducted into the Army Air Corps. Other than a few like Greg Boyington, who heard that and quickly left to return to the US because he did not want to serve in the Army again.

Yep they were. But they had been discharged and everyone in the AVG from wrench monkeys to Claire Chennault were paid by the Chinese government, NOT the USA. They were more like the Eagle Squadrons than the People’s Volunteer Army.

 

[Robert W]

Right. And the AVG was just a fantasy that never existed.

FDR was in war before the ships at Pearl harbor were bombed by Japan.

 

[Mushroom]

"Nothing"? How ignorant of history can you be?

Once again, nothing actually backing up your claim. How typical.

 

[Mushroom]

But they had been discharged and everyone in the AVG from wrench monkeys to Claire Chennault were paid by the Chinese government, NOT the USA.

Shell game. You are aware that the US also gave China that year over $145 million in cash and supplies, right? Up from $45 million the year before.

As I said, the same fiction China used a decade later in the Korean War. Everybody knew we were fighting the Chinese Army, just as Japan knew it was fighting US forces in the AVG. But for diplomatic reasons accepted the fiction so long as it was not the "US Military" in name.

 

[Unkotare]

Once again, nothing actually backing up your claim. How typical.

Really? The Chinese Exclusion Act? The rampant (and presidential) racism of the 1940s? Stop being stupid.

 

[Mushroom]

Really? The Chinese Exclusion Act? The rampant (and presidential) racism of the 1940s? Stop being stupid.

And what does an act established in 1882 have to do with 1941?

By that logic, Japan was our ally in WWI, therefore they could not be our enemy in WWII.

 

[Unkotare]

And what does an act established in 1882 have to do with 1941?

...

Because it was still in force, stupid.

 

[Unkotare]

....

By that logic, Japan was our ally in WWI, therefore they could not be our enemy in WWII.

Just like Italy, stupid?

 

[Mushroom]

Just like Italy, stupid?

Still not actually stating any evidence, and still just hurling insults.

Have a nice day, Poopy. Come back when you want to act like a grown-up and actually discuss issues and not your tantrums.

 

[Unkotare]

Just like Italy, stupid?

.

 

[Unkotare]

Because it was still in force, stupid.

.

 

[Unkotare]

Really? The Chinese Exclusion Act? The rampant (and presidential) racism of the 1940s? Stop being stupid.

.

 

[Mushroom]

.

Repeating your claims without any kind of reference or verification does not prove your point.

Holy hell, and you claim to be an educator. How in the hell were you able to make it through college without knowing the APA citation format?

Come on Poopy, you are going to have to do better than that.

 

[Unkotare]

Really? The Chinese Exclusion Act? The rampant (and presidential) racism of the 1940s? Stop being stupid.

.

 

[Unkotare]

Just like Italy, stupid?

.