The OLDER Official Discussion Thread for the creation of Israel, the UN and the British Mandate

[P F Tinmore]

It doesn't matter. The reason for leaving is irrelevant. The right to return applies without regard to the reason for leaving.

Once you leave something it has been abandoned.

It is no longer yours.

The Palestinians are S.O.L.

They left.

They are morons.

Agreed. Add to the the consequence of war. By attacking Israel and losing, the term "to the victor belong the spoils" applies along with "possession is 9/10ths of the law".

The Palestinians haven't helped themselves by becoming a Death Cult. Their fellow Arab Muslims haven't helped the Palestinian people by supplying them with weapons and suicide belts rather than factories or allowing them it immigrate.

When did the Palestinians lose a war?

The Palestinians who left lost everything.

The Palestinians who stayed were smarter. Now they need to integrate into Israeli society.

His Majesty's government view with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, and will use their best endeavours to facilitate the achievement of this object, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country.

Of course this was just a letter that had no legal authority. The land did not belong to Britain so they had no authority to promise anything.

 

[Hollie]

Funny stuff. You cut and paste various revisions from wiki and expect to be taken seriously?

Wikipedia is a medium, not a source. Youtube is a medium, not a source.

Typical propaganda ploy. Ignore the issues, attack the source.

Typical tactic surrounding The Tinmore Vortex™.

Did you not notice that your wiki article announced revisions?

Yes. So?

Tell us about those revisions.

What about them?

What was revised?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Wikipedia is a medium, not a source. Youtube is a medium, not a source.

Typical propaganda ploy. Ignore the issues, attack the source.

Typical tactic surrounding The Tinmore Vortex™.

Did you not notice that your wiki article announced revisions?

Yes. So?

Tell us about those revisions.

What about them?

What was revised?

The new version is less legal history and more in current political affairs.

 

[P F Tinmore]

The Palestinians left of their own accord in 1948 then realized too late their own stupidity for doing so.

They have been trying to fight their way back in ever since.

Never going to happen.

It doesn't matter. The reason for leaving is irrelevant. The right to return applies without regard to the reason for leaving.

Once you leave something it has been abandoned.

It is no longer yours.

The Palestinians are S.O.L.

They left.

They are morons.

Not really. You need to read up.

 

[Hollie]

Typical tactic surrounding The Tinmore Vortex™.

Did you not notice that your wiki article announced revisions?

Yes. So?

Tell us about those revisions.

What about them?

What was revised?

The new version is less legal history and more in current political affairs.

It's great that you have wiki to re-write history.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Yes. So?

Tell us about those revisions.

What about them?

What was revised?

The new version is less legal history and more in current political affairs.

It's great that you have wiki to re-write history.

Editing Wikipedia (as Israel pays its operatives to do) does not change history.

What I posted are facts that you have not refuted.

 

[Penelope]

That is an excellent video, thank you. Thank goodness for the new historians and the truth. Seems like the West Bank is like Syria, but instead of ISIS they are the IDF.

We wonder what created Hezbollah, well many Shia lived in northern Israel who were made to leave by the Israelis and brutal ways. Those they are referred to as Palestinians they are, but they are Shias who lived in the some of the northern towns.

Shia villages in Palestine

From 1923 to 1948, there were seven villages in Mandatory Palestine for which the population was predominantly Shia Muslim (also known as Metawali). They were Tarbikha, Saliha, Malkiyeh, Nabi Yusha, Qadas, Hunin, and Abil al-Qamh.[1] These villages were transferred from the French to the British sphere as a result of the border agreement of 1923. All of them were depopulated during the 1948 Arab-Israeli War and their former locations are now in northern Israel.

Shia villages in Palestine - Wikipedia

I think the British thought the Jews would be able to live in a mixed society and allow others respect who lived there but no, just like they forced the British out they forcibly removed the Arabs, while some fled instead of being killed. Really glad the real history is coming out.

If one clicks on every town in the above wiki article, one can see how they used force to make the Arabs leave mostly Shia Muslims .

 

[Penelope]

Yes. So?

Tell us about those revisions.

What about them?

What was revised?

The new version is less legal history and more in current political affairs.

It's great that you have wiki to re-write history.

Isn't it, be sure to follow links. Not rewriting it, just getting rid of the Jewish bias , finally the truth comes out. Can't hide forever.

 

[Hollie]

Tell us about those revisions.

What about them?

What was revised?

The new version is less legal history and more in current political affairs.

It's great that you have wiki to re-write history.

Editing Wikipedia (as Israel pays its operatives to do) does not change history.

What I posted are facts that you have not refuted.

Funny stuff. You cut and pasted a wiki article that you admitted was edited. Now, you're reduced to conspiracy theories about "Israeli operatives" making those edits. Lastly, you're insisting the edited wiki article is fact, while promoting a conspiracy that Israeli operatives have made those edits

What a mess you've made.

 

[P F Tinmore]

What about them?

What was revised?

The new version is less legal history and more in current political affairs.

It's great that you have wiki to re-write history.

Editing Wikipedia (as Israel pays its operatives to do) does not change history.

What I posted are facts that you have not refuted.

Funny stuff. You cut and pasted a wiki article that you admitted was edited. Now, you're reduced to conspiracy theories about "Israeli operatives" making those edits. Lastly, you're insisting the edited wiki article is fact, while promoting a conspiracy that Israeli operatives have made those edits

What a mess you've made.

Wikipedia - Israel is paying internet workers to manipulate online content

 

[Divine Wind]

Agreed. Add to the the consequence of war. By attacking Israel and losing, the term "to the victor belong the spoils" applies along with "possession is 9/10ths of the law".

The Palestinians haven't helped themselves by becoming a Death Cult. Their fellow Arab Muslims haven't helped the Palestinian people by supplying them with weapons and suicide belts rather than factories or allowing them it immigrate.

When did the Palestinians lose a war?

When did they ever win one? Why are they the ones with a Death Cult society and the Israelis have a thriving, vibrant economy?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Agreed. Add to the the consequence of war. By attacking Israel and losing, the term "to the victor belong the spoils" applies along with "possession is 9/10ths of the law".

The Palestinians haven't helped themselves by becoming a Death Cult. Their fellow Arab Muslims haven't helped the Palestinian people by supplying them with weapons and suicide belts rather than factories or allowing them it immigrate.

When did the Palestinians lose a war?

When did they ever win one? Why are they the ones with a Death Cult society and the Israelis have a thriving, vibrant economy?

Israel is the mooch capital of the world.

 

[fanger]

ISRAEL SEEKS BUFFER ZONE ON BORDERS WITH SYRIA
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is seeking a buffer zone against Syria, Iran and Hezbollah on the borders with Syria to be part of any future deal to end the Syrian crisis, Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported on Friday.

According to the Israeli newspaper, Netanyahu proposed this issue during meetings with American and other coalition countries.

Netanyahu wants to prevent Iran and Hezbollah from establishing a foothold and he intends to undermine future attacks against Israel, noting that he had suggested international forces to supervise his proposed buffer zone.

Last Friday, the Israeli Maariv revealed that Netanyahu sent messages to the international parties involved in the talks about Syria’s future.

These messages, according to the Egyptian news website Moheet, suggested Israel’s desire to decrease its reliance on military attacks on Syria in exchange for reaching a silent agreement that Iran and Hezbollah do not approach the Armistice Line in the occupied Golan Heights.
Israel seeks buffer zone on borders with Syria

Not inside israel however

Comments
.
We already HAVE a buffer zone with Syria! It’s called the Golan Heights. We’ve bleated on for decades about how strategically important it was to keep that area for just such a reason. Whose fault is it that we then decided to populate this buffer zone with thousands upon thousands of civilians? We did EXACTLY the same thing in the West Bank! We captured it, occupied it and declared it of the utmost strategic importance to keep it as a buffer zone between poor defenseless Tel Aviv and the forces of the evil King of Jordan. We then promptly transferred and spent the next half century pouring 600,000 Israeli civilians into the EXACT same “buffer zone” right up to the banks of the Jordan River! So again I ask. Exactly whose fualt is it that we have no buffer zones left?

 

[P F Tinmore]

ISRAEL SEEKS BUFFER ZONE ON BORDERS WITH SYRIA
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is seeking a buffer zone against Syria, Iran and Hezbollah on the borders with Syria to be part of any future deal to end the Syrian crisis, Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported on Friday.

According to the Israeli newspaper, Netanyahu proposed this issue during meetings with American and other coalition countries.

Netanyahu wants to prevent Iran and Hezbollah from establishing a foothold and he intends to undermine future attacks against Israel, noting that he had suggested international forces to supervise his proposed buffer zone.

Last Friday, the Israeli Maariv revealed that Netanyahu sent messages to the international parties involved in the talks about Syria’s future.

These messages, according to the Egyptian news website Moheet, suggested Israel’s desire to decrease its reliance on military attacks on Syria in exchange for reaching a silent agreement that Iran and Hezbollah do not approach the Armistice Line in the occupied Golan Heights.
Israel seeks buffer zone on borders with Syria

Not inside israel however

Comments
.
We already HAVE a buffer zone with Syria! It’s called the Golan Heights. We’ve bleated on for decades about how strategically important it was to keep that area for just such a reason. Whose fault is it that we then decided to populate this buffer zone with thousands upon thousands of civilians? We did EXACTLY the same thing in the West Bank! We captured it, occupied it and declared it of the utmost strategic importance to keep it as a buffer zone between poor defenseless Tel Aviv and the forces of the evil King of Jordan. We then promptly transferred and spent the next half century pouring 600,000 Israeli civilians into the EXACT same “buffer zone” right up to the banks of the Jordan River! So again I ask. Exactly whose fualt is it that we have no buffer zones left?

I knew the freeloaders would not put it on their own side of the border.

 

[Hollie]

Agreed. Add to the the consequence of war. By attacking Israel and losing, the term "to the victor belong the spoils" applies along with "possession is 9/10ths of the law".

The Palestinians haven't helped themselves by becoming a Death Cult. Their fellow Arab Muslims haven't helped the Palestinian people by supplying them with weapons and suicide belts rather than factories or allowing them it immigrate.

When did the Palestinians lose a war?

When did they ever win one? Why are they the ones with a Death Cult society and the Israelis have a thriving, vibrant economy?

Israel is the mooch capital of the world.

I'm guessing you're just playing dumb regarding the dedicated UN welfare fraud that continues the hoax of Pal'istanian Arabs.

 

[Hollie]

ISRAEL SEEKS BUFFER ZONE ON BORDERS WITH SYRIA
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is seeking a buffer zone against Syria, Iran and Hezbollah on the borders with Syria to be part of any future deal to end the Syrian crisis, Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported on Friday.

According to the Israeli newspaper, Netanyahu proposed this issue during meetings with American and other coalition countries.

Netanyahu wants to prevent Iran and Hezbollah from establishing a foothold and he intends to undermine future attacks against Israel, noting that he had suggested international forces to supervise his proposed buffer zone.

Last Friday, the Israeli Maariv revealed that Netanyahu sent messages to the international parties involved in the talks about Syria’s future.

These messages, according to the Egyptian news website Moheet, suggested Israel’s desire to decrease its reliance on military attacks on Syria in exchange for reaching a silent agreement that Iran and Hezbollah do not approach the Armistice Line in the occupied Golan Heights.
Israel seeks buffer zone on borders with Syria

Not inside israel however

Comments
.
We already HAVE a buffer zone with Syria! It’s called the Golan Heights. We’ve bleated on for decades about how strategically important it was to keep that area for just such a reason. Whose fault is it that we then decided to populate this buffer zone with thousands upon thousands of civilians? We did EXACTLY the same thing in the West Bank! We captured it, occupied it and declared it of the utmost strategic importance to keep it as a buffer zone between poor defenseless Tel Aviv and the forces of the evil King of Jordan. We then promptly transferred and spent the next half century pouring 600,000 Israeli civilians into the EXACT same “buffer zone” right up to the banks of the Jordan River! So again I ask. Exactly whose fualt is it that we have no buffer zones left?

Doesn't seem unreasonable to have separation between those Islamic terrorist enclaves.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Agreed. Add to the the consequence of war. By attacking Israel and losing, the term "to the victor belong the spoils" applies along with "possession is 9/10ths of the law".

The Palestinians haven't helped themselves by becoming a Death Cult. Their fellow Arab Muslims haven't helped the Palestinian people by supplying them with weapons and suicide belts rather than factories or allowing them it immigrate.

When did the Palestinians lose a war?

When did they ever win one? Why are they the ones with a Death Cult society and the Israelis have a thriving, vibrant economy?

Israel is the mooch capital of the world.

I'm guessing you're just playing dumb regarding the dedicated UN welfare fraud that continues the hoax of Pal'istanian Arabs.

Not at all. That is Israel's expense to the world.

 

[Hollie]

Agreed. Add to the the consequence of war. By attacking Israel and losing, the term "to the victor belong the spoils" applies along with "possession is 9/10ths of the law".

The Palestinians haven't helped themselves by becoming a Death Cult. Their fellow Arab Muslims haven't helped the Palestinian people by supplying them with weapons and suicide belts rather than factories or allowing them it immigrate.

When did the Palestinians lose a war?

When did they ever win one? Why are they the ones with a Death Cult society and the Israelis have a thriving, vibrant economy?

Israel is the mooch capital of the world.

I'm guessing you're just playing dumb regarding the dedicated UN welfare fraud that continues the hoax of Pal'istanian Arabs.

Not at all. That is Israel's expense to the world.

Indeed, "I blame the Jews" is a convenient excuse for Arab-Islamist incompetence and ineptitude.

Indeed, that excuse works for those like you who seek to shield Arabs-Islamics from the illuminating light that shines on the total lack of Arab-Islamist innovation, industry and commerce as compared to most of the planet.

Indeed, Arab-Islamist backwaters are an embarrassment.

Innovation in the Arab world. From zero to not much more

http://www.economist.com/news/middl...e-creative-stifling-region-zero-not-much-more

 

[theliq]

The Palestinians left of their own accord in 1948 then realized too late their own stupidity for doing so.

They have been trying to fight their way back in ever since.

Never going to happen.

It doesn't matter. The reason for leaving is irrelevant. The right to return applies without regard to the reason for leaving.

Once you leave something it has been abandoned.

It is no longer yours.

The Palestinians are S.O.L.

They left.

They are morons.

The Palestinians never abandoned anything,they were driven out by Jewish(Synthetic) Zionist Terrorists,SLAUGHTERED,MAIMED AND DISPOSSED,Your Fool.The Jews then razed Palestinian Towns and Villages,claiming to the next generation of Jews that all this occupied Palestinian Land was uninhabited....your understanding of History and Facts is Shameful to say the least....What YOU have agreed to and continue to LIE about is,that you think it OK to expel and murder a population of peaceful people with illegal people by Terrorism and Deceit...so by your own analogy...it is therefore OK for the Palestinians to reclaim their own Land by War and Terrorism.

Why when reading your post do the words "Moron and Imbecile"immediately come to mind.......Your knowledge of History is putting it mildly .....BOLLOCKS

as a parting note the majority of Jews in Israel are not a Semitic People at ALL but every PALESTINIAN IS.....FACT

WERE YOU LOOKING IN A MIRROR WHEN YOU ESPOUSED THAT "ALL PALESTINIANS WERE MORONS"...methinks you were...steven

 

[Divine Wind]

The Palestinians never abandoned anything,they were driven out by Jewish(Synthetic) Zionist Terrorists,SLAUGHTERED,MAIMED AND DISPOSSED,Your Fool.The Jews then razed Palestinian Towns and Villages,claiming to the next generation of Jews that all this occupied Palestinian Land was uninhabited....your understanding of History and Facts is Shameful to say the least....What YOU have agreed to and continue to LIE about is,that you think it OK to expel and murder a population of peaceful people with illegal people by Terrorism and Deceit...so by your own analogy...it is therefore OK for the Palestinians to reclaim their own Land by War and Terrorism.

Why when reading your post do the words "Moron and Imbecile"immediately come to mind.......Your knowledge of History is putting it mildly .....BOLLOCKS

as a parting note the majority of Jews in Israel are not a Semitic People at ALL but every PALESTINIAN IS.....FACT

WERE YOU LOOKING IN A MIRROR WHEN YOU ESPOUSED THAT "ALL PALESTINIANS WERE MORONS"...methinks you were...steven

That's the standard Jihadist antisemitic meme. Tell me, is it the Jews or the Palestinians that strap on suicide belts and blow up city buses full of noncombatants or markets?

The West is getting tired of this Islamic terrorist shit. It's only a matter of time, and I think we're close, that all the Western nations close in on radical Islam. Muslims should beware awakening a sleeping dragon and start cleaning their own house before the West collectively moves in and cleans it for them.