Robert Urbanek
Platinum Member
“The Big Ice Is Sick,” a Dec. 1 article in The New Yorker, laments the plight of Inuits in Greenland: Toxic chemicals are concentrated in the whale and bear meat they eat; tourism scares away the narwhales; and alcoholism plagues communities idled by lack of opportunities. So, what was the Inuit Eden like before the Danes came in and spoiled everything?
In years of abundance, there were surges in births; in years of famine, infanticides. Those people who weren’t central to the survival of the community—the elderly, the sick, widows, orphans—often disappeared out into the ice.
There you have it, an Inuit Green Deal. If you live in harmony with nature, you don’t need a welfare state: no universal health care, no Social Security, no food stamps. Any takers?
But seriously, if you assume humanity should be taken seriously, history just seems to be a cycle of one kind of negligence and cruelty replacing a different kind of negligence and cruelty, with people snatching moments of happiness when they can.
In years of abundance, there were surges in births; in years of famine, infanticides. Those people who weren’t central to the survival of the community—the elderly, the sick, widows, orphans—often disappeared out into the ice.
There you have it, an Inuit Green Deal. If you live in harmony with nature, you don’t need a welfare state: no universal health care, no Social Security, no food stamps. Any takers?
But seriously, if you assume humanity should be taken seriously, history just seems to be a cycle of one kind of negligence and cruelty replacing a different kind of negligence and cruelty, with people snatching moments of happiness when they can.