Adam's Apple
Senior Member
- Apr 25, 2004
- 4,092
- 452
- 48
Barbarity and Civility: Eyeing the Terror War with Clarity
Editorial from The New Hampshire Union-Leader
July 11, 2005
IMMEDIATELY after Thursday's bombings in London, some on the far left blamed Prime Minister Tony Blair, saying it was his fault for sending troops to Iraq. This is the same poisoned thinking that blamed America for the 9/11 attacks and equated the treatment of prisoners at Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay with the acts of terrorists and totalitarian regimes.
Humiliating prisoners and placing them in stress positions might be considered cruelty by some. But it is not in the same universe with decapitation, electric shock and mass murder.
Then there is the matter of victim selection. From the start, the Islamist terrorists operated under a broadened definition of "enemy" that covered civilians as well as military personnel. And so they brought down the Twin Towers, exploded passenger trains in Spain, blew up Shiite mosques in Iraq and bombed London commuters.
Not incidentally, this mirrors the treatment meted out by the Taliban and Saddam Hussein. Even so slight an offense as open disagreement is met with jail, torture or death.
By contrast, when American military personnel kill civilians, it is by accident, and it is followed by swift apologies and restitution.
As we debate whether glovelessly handling a Koran is a violation of the Geneva Conventions, terrorists plot the destruction of all Western civilization, or at least as many "infidel" non-believers as they can possibly wipe out.
The CIA reportedly kidnaps Osama Mustafa Hassan Nasr, a radical cleric, in Milan, and ships him to Saudi Arabia, and there is widespread outrage. Meanwhile, al-Qaida kidnaps and executes Egyptian envoy Ihab al-Sherif, and there is only a murmur of mild indignation.
That the fundamental differences between the actions of Western governments and the actions of the Islamist terrorists have to be continually pointed out is one of life's absurd realities. That many of the people who need to have it pointed out are Westerners themselves is doubly absurd.
http://www.theunionleader.com/articles_showa.html?article=57546
Editorial from The New Hampshire Union-Leader
July 11, 2005
IMMEDIATELY after Thursday's bombings in London, some on the far left blamed Prime Minister Tony Blair, saying it was his fault for sending troops to Iraq. This is the same poisoned thinking that blamed America for the 9/11 attacks and equated the treatment of prisoners at Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay with the acts of terrorists and totalitarian regimes.
Humiliating prisoners and placing them in stress positions might be considered cruelty by some. But it is not in the same universe with decapitation, electric shock and mass murder.
Then there is the matter of victim selection. From the start, the Islamist terrorists operated under a broadened definition of "enemy" that covered civilians as well as military personnel. And so they brought down the Twin Towers, exploded passenger trains in Spain, blew up Shiite mosques in Iraq and bombed London commuters.
Not incidentally, this mirrors the treatment meted out by the Taliban and Saddam Hussein. Even so slight an offense as open disagreement is met with jail, torture or death.
By contrast, when American military personnel kill civilians, it is by accident, and it is followed by swift apologies and restitution.
As we debate whether glovelessly handling a Koran is a violation of the Geneva Conventions, terrorists plot the destruction of all Western civilization, or at least as many "infidel" non-believers as they can possibly wipe out.
The CIA reportedly kidnaps Osama Mustafa Hassan Nasr, a radical cleric, in Milan, and ships him to Saudi Arabia, and there is widespread outrage. Meanwhile, al-Qaida kidnaps and executes Egyptian envoy Ihab al-Sherif, and there is only a murmur of mild indignation.
That the fundamental differences between the actions of Western governments and the actions of the Islamist terrorists have to be continually pointed out is one of life's absurd realities. That many of the people who need to have it pointed out are Westerners themselves is doubly absurd.
http://www.theunionleader.com/articles_showa.html?article=57546