I think we should if they denounce ISIS, face court procedings for joining a terrorist organization, do their time and show no criminal activity, I would say take them back but keep an eye on them.
Any other opinions? Please do the poll.
U.S.-born ISIS bride thinks she 'deserves a second chance'
Try this for an example: Go to an extreme Christian fundamentalist(s) and do anything you can think of, to betray their beliefs that are in the "Old Testament." It simply isn't going to happen, no matter how hard you try.
Now, ratchet up that belief to a higher level and you have an ISIS member. Thoroughly indoctrinated in the teachings of hate and killing of "non-believers" via the Koran, since he/she was young enough to read the Koran and listen to his/her radical family, friends and religious teachers and you have a thoroughly brain-washed killer, complete with no remorse. He/she will kill you, your spouse, your kids and other loved ones, simply for not believing in the garbage preached in the Koran.
So, should you offer peace and a return to their non-Islamic nation, they will simply use taqiyya (lie/deception) to be able to return and look for more ways to undermine your non-Islamic nation.
Any individual that considers him/herself to be a "true" Muslim, uses "abrogation" when it comes to the Koran; the concept that Muhammad's latter teachings of hate and killing, supersede his earlier teachings of peace.
Bottom line, if they are a member of ISIS, the only solution is their death.
And, the only overall problem with this type of enemy is to cut off the head of the snake and in this case, it's the Koran and its teachings.