Those old farts paid into FICA most of their working lives. The I in FICA stands for INSURANCE. All they are doing is collecting on the policy that they paid for.
Don't blame the old folks because the Feds mismanaged an insurance program to the point that it is nearing bankruptcy. BTW, the premiums were mandatory! Does that ring a bell?
Ok. So why is Romney including them as part of the 47%, then?
About 10% of those that don't pay federal income tax are the elderly living on Social Security. So, Romney should have taken that into consideration. I see many of these elderly at my Church food bank where I volunteer and it breaks my heart.
The Social Security mandatory 'tax' was sold to the American public as a supplement to retirement, and was never intended to be the sole source of support. Unfortunately, many people went through life without saving a dime, counting on Social Security, and are now in serious trouble.
Romney knows that the Democrats will demagogue the Social Security issue, as they presently are, and a lot of the elderly will fall for the BS and not vote for him.