Palestinians: When was Palestine established?

[rylah]

There haven't been any Dhimmis for a couple hundred years. Do you even know what that was about?

Except about each time Muslims try to establish a new caliphate - every two weeks or so...

The last caliphate to "abandon" Jizyah was the Ottoman rule,
which simply substituted it with another name, in addition
to another 4 dhimmi taxes imposed on Jews.

Not to mention the typical Baksheesh expected on top of that
in any interraction with the Muslim governors.

So indeed, do you know what that was about?

Paying Jizyah is a Sign of Kufr and Disgrace​

Allah said,

حَتَّى يُعْطُواْ الْجِزْيَةَ
(until they pay the Jizyah), if they do not choose to embrace Islam,

عَن يَدٍ
(with willing submission), in defeat and subservience,

وَهُمْ صَـغِرُونَ
(and feel themselves subdued.), disgraced, humiliated and belittled. Therefore, Muslims are not allowed to honor the people of Dhimmah or elevate them above Muslims, for they are miserable, disgraced and humiliated. Muslim recorded from Abu Hurayrah that the Prophet said,

Tafsir Surah At-Tawbah - 28 - Quran.com

Read Tafsir Ibn Kathir (abridged) for Ayah 28 of Surah At-Tawbah

quran.com

The Jizya tax was less than Muslims pay and was only paid by able bodied men who wanted to opt out of community defense. The reason it was LESS is because Muslims didn't want Christian and Jews to convert to Islam because they could save money.. That would be a form of coersion.

How do you know a Muslim supremacist,
and what they mean by demanding "freedom" and "equality"?

When they brag about Spain, and immediately launch into selling you
that forcing Jizyah on non-Muslim is a thing of "choice" and for your "protection".

And that is really "tolerance"...
towards non-Muslims of course.

So tell us surada,
since you think it was such an example tolerance and even social welfare,
and since the Muslims are mostly exempt from Israeli army, except those volunteering,

that we acquire the same level of that tolerance,
how high should be the Jizyah we impose on Muslims?

 

[Dogmaphobe]

I am not a Muslim or a male..

There were very few Jews in Palestine.. Read Ibn Battuta or Rabbi Benjamin Tudela or even the Ottoman census of 1840.

Yes, we have heard the story you want us to believe in regards to your being a female oil executive in 1950 living in the middle east, and a Christian to boot.!

We should be honored to have a 115 year old woman posting here, and one who was the only female oil exec living in the entirety of the middle east in 1950!!

 

[Sixties Fan]

I am not a Muslim or a male..

There were very few Jews in Palestine.. Read Ibn Battuta or Rabbi Benjamin Tudela or even the Ottoman census of 1840.

It has never been about numbers of people.

Europeans took over the new World. The indigenous are still the rightful owners of those lands, just as Jews are the rightful owners of the Land of Israel, where history can be verified through each and every invader, conquerors.

Now, when was a Palestinian Empire, etc ever established on the land?

 

[surada]

Yes, we have heard the story you want us to believe in regards to your being a female oil executive in 1950 living in the middle east, and a Christian to boot.!

We should be honored to have a 115 year old woman posting here, and one who was the only female oil exec living in the entirety of the middle east in 1950!!

You're an idiot. I was NEVER an oil executive. Look up Rabbi Benjamin Tudela.

 

[Dogmaphobe]

Is that right?

But don't you remember sitting around the dinner table as a kid reminiscing about the golden age when you were Dhimmi?

To listen to Surada, you would think every Jewish family does.

 

[Sixties Fan]

That's sad. Peace would be better for everyone.

Not for all the Palestinian leaders who are making a living off all the foolish donors who buy their "Poor Victim" serenade.

But since it is against Jews, those foolish donors give the money with pleasure.

 

[surada]

It has never been about numbers of people.

Europeans took over the new World. The indigenous are still the rightful owners of those lands, just as Jews are the rightful owners of the Land of Israel, where history can be verified through each and every invader, conquerors.

Now, when was a Palestinian Empire, etc ever established on the land?

Yes. What we did to the Native Americans is a shameful and dark episode in US history. Now we have international law that forbids colonizing conquered land.

Palestine never had an Empire and neither did Israel.

The Akkadians had an empire .. so did the Babylonians. Israel was just a whistle stop on the trade route.

 

[surada]

But don't you remember sitting around the dinner table as a kid reminiscing about the golden age when you were Dhimmi?

To listen to Surada, you would think every Jewish family does.

That's real stupid.. There haven't been any dhimmis in 200 years.

 

[Dogmaphobe]

You're an idiot. I was NEVER an oil executive. Look up Rabbi Benjamin Tudela.

Ah, and I forgot to mention how you said you had your own Palestinian houseboys to wait on you hand and foot!

 

[Dogmaphobe]

That's real stupid.. There haven't been any dhimmis in 200 years.

You must be getting senile now that you are 115.

You are the one who claimed that the Golden age for Jews was when they were living as dhimmis.

It must be getting difficult to keep all your stories straight by now.

 

[rylah]

Yes. What we did to the Native Americans is a shameful and dark episode in US history. Now we have international law that forbids colonizing conquered land.

Palestine never had an Empire and neither did Israel.

The Akkadians had an empire .. so did the Babylonians. Israel was just a whistle stop on the trade route.

And yet, of them all international law
recognizes the re-constitution of the Jewish civilization.

 

[Hollie]

The Jizya tax was much smaller than Zakat.

I suspect you're trying to put the best spin possible but we need to be honest.The jizya is a discriminatory tax or penalty assessed against non-islamics and has a long history in islamic fascism

 

[Hollie]

That's real stupid.. There haven't been any dhimmis in 200 years.

Not true. For a period of time, ISIS was able to impose the dhimmi status during their reign of Islamic justice in Syria.

Syrian Christians sign treaty of submission to Islamists

Threatened by al-Qaeda-affiliated extremists, community in northern city of Raqqa chooses 'dhimmitude' over conversion or death

www.google.com

 

[surada]

Except about each time Muslims try to establish a new caliphate - every two weeks or so...

The last caliphate to "abandon" Jizyah was the Ottoman rule,
which simply substituted it with another name, in addition
to another 4 dhimmi taxes imposed on Jews.

Not to mention the typical Baksheesh expected on top of that
in any interraction with the Muslim governors.

So indeed, do you know what that was about?

Paying Jizyah is a Sign of Kufr and Disgrace​

Allah said,

حَتَّى يُعْطُواْ الْجِزْيَةَ
(until they pay the Jizyah), if they do not choose to embrace Islam,

عَن يَدٍ
(with willing submission), in defeat and subservience,

وَهُمْ صَـغِرُونَ
(and feel themselves subdued.), disgraced, humiliated and belittled. Therefore, Muslims are not allowed to honor the people of Dhimmah or elevate them above Muslims, for they are miserable, disgraced and humiliated. Muslim recorded from Abu Hurayrah that the Prophet said,

Tafsir Surah At-Tawbah - 28 - Quran.com

Read Tafsir Ibn Kathir (abridged) for Ayah 28 of Surah At-Tawbah

quran.com

How do you know a Muslim supremacist,
and what they mean by demanding "freedom" and "equality"?

When they brag about Spain, and immediately launch into selling you
that forcing Jizyah on non-Muslim is a thing of "choice" and for your "protection".

And that is really "tolerance"...
towards non-Muslims of course.

So tell us surada,
since you think it was such an example tolerance and even social welfare,
and since the Muslims are mostly exempt from Israeli army, except those volunteering,

that we acquire the same level of that tolerance,
how high should be the Jizyah we impose on Muslims?

No one in the Arab world wants another caliphate except ISIS.. The last one was a dud. In fact the Emir of Mecca declared himself Caliph in 1924 and was chased off the Arabian peninsula by Ibn Saud.

 

[rylah]

No one in the Arab world wants another caliphate except ISIS..

Except for compulsive liars like you
and your deranged heroes?

Hamas promises:

"On this day, as we are witnessing all that is happening with the grace of Allah, we are looking forwards to two important things, which are within sight:

• Cleanse Palestine of the "filth of the Jews" by 2022
• From the River to the Sea - establishment of Caliphate

The last one was a dud. In fact the Emir of Mecca declared himself Caliph in 1924 and was chased off the Arabian peninsula by Ibn Saud.

Indeed, poor Arabian royals wanted to bite off the entire Middle East
now having to console with only 77% of the land intended for Jews,
and total failure of Arab states to govern anything in the Levant.

Maybe they should've demanded Spain,
and feel less ashamed in the defeat.

 

[surada]

Except for compulsive liars like you
and your deranged heroes?

Hamas promises:

"On this day, as we are witnessing all that is happening with the grace of Allah, we are looking forwards to two important things, which are within sight:

• Cleanse Palestine of the "filth of the Jews" by 2022
• From the River to the Sea - establishment of Caliphate

Indeed, poor Arabian royals wanted to bite off the entire Middle East
now having to console with only 77% of the land intended for Jews,
and total failure of Arab states to govern anything in the Levant.

Maybe they should've demanded Spain,
and feel less ashamed in the defeat.

You're an idiot, rylah.. Nobody in the ME wants another Caliphate. Why do you lie and spread fear and hatred?

 

[rylah]

You're an idiot, rylah.. Nobody in the ME wants another Caliphate. Why do you lie and spread fear and hatred?

In the meantime,
you can't refute a thing I've posted.

Is it the standard Jihadi tactic,
to mindlessly parrot the same debunked line
and accuse others for getting caught with your pants down?

Thousands of Palestinians Rally in Ramallah for Islamic Caliphate​

"The Islamic Caliphate will be restored only when Palestine is fully liberated. Palestine was occupied because of the collapse of the Islamic Caliphate. The issue of the caliphate has united the [Islamic] nation and it is the basic case for the liberation of Palestine and the implementation of Sharia for all Muslims under one [Muslim] ruler."

One moment, please...

www.wattan.net

 

[P F Tinmore]

Palestine evolved into a functioning society over thousands of years.

 

[surada]

Jews and Christians lived there also as dhimmi under Arab-Moslem fascism.

The inventor of islamism said two religions cannot exist on the peninsula.

LOL.. I have two decades of church and Sunday school in Arabia.

No dhimmis for 200 years.

 

[surada]

In the meantime,
you can't refute a thing I've posted.

Is it the standard Jihadi tactic,
to mindlessly parrot the same debunked line
and accuse others for getting caught with your pants down?

Thousands of Palestinians Rally in Ramallah for Islamic Caliphate​

"The Islamic Caliphate will be restored only when Palestine is fully liberated. Palestine was occupied because of the collapse of the Islamic Caliphate. The issue of the caliphate has united the [Islamic] nation and it is the basic case for the liberation of Palestine and the implementation of Sharia for all Muslims under one [Muslim] ruler."

One moment, please...

www.wattan.net

One guy? What is Wattan?