I say yes Cafe.
Here's another reason:
He won't use his shot even when I explained why town would win if he used it today.
If he is so sure I am town by trusting me with sensitive info. that could of gotten him NK'd if I was scum, and SR and Cafe are town-there's only 2 choices left.
All he would of had to do is shoot Aye and if wrong, we'd lynch mathblade or vice versa. Town would win.
If all we did was lynch and it was a mislynch, the next day would be a NL and he can't use it.
I explained twice how he can't use it at lylo with only 3 people. He tried to say he could shoot one and hammer the other but it doesn't work like that. I explained it twice which is why Wake said if we needed to ask him we had to ask in game. But once one person dies, the game is decided by the two who are remaining. So he doesn't need to use it then.
So if he was a town dayvig, then he knows he wins by taking out the 2 possible scum now, today. But he kept making excuses and even now, rather than do that, he wants to be lynched.
Makes me think he doesn't have the PR to use.
I told him, that if it was Aye, she'd likely take out my two biggest defenders SR and House the next 2 nights if we mislynch and get to lylo. Then it would be lylo with me, Aye, math-they'd lynch me and we'd lose, or me, Cafe, Aye-and since Cafe didn't suspect Aye we could lose then too.
I told him I did not want that. It was way too risky. Yet he kept making excuses. If he had the PR, he'd use it correctly.
And now, going after SR? So what does he want if scum? SR lynched now? To make it to lylo with me and Aye so he can win?
My guess is he wanted me with him at lylo so he can win. And that's why he didn't want me to tell town.
I think the last is probably House guys. This is why things were not fitting together for me.
And let's not forget this: He claimed VT awhile back.