My question is do you believe you have made an honest, objective assessment? Are your opinions fair? Have you looked at both sides?
Yes, I have examined Islam historically, politically and socially. I find that the principles of it and my value set are not congruent. Christianity, as I am culturally Christian, does match up well.
The reason I say this is that I am pretty sure you have not done that with Christianity, so I would naturally be suspicious if you had done this for Islam.
Well, let me state this. I have never lived in a truly Christian nation guided by and directed around Christian principles. The Christianity which we live around today is a mere husk (Christian holidays/churches etc) of what it was >100 years ago. I have however lived in a 99% Muslim nation (Turkey) which made a valiant attempt to become secular (Ataturk). Yet despite secularism still remains a very Muslim nation.
Other groups have suffered greatly despite Turkey's claim as a secular nation. Christians for example were at one time 150 years ago, a substantial minority, now they are all but gone save for a few select communities. Research it.
To the Muslim there will always be Dar Al Hard (House of War) Dar Al Islami (House of Peace). Secularism and Islam do not mix. Non Muslims and Muslims do not mix. This is the history of things. This is the reality of today.
Fun Fact: In the town that I lived there was a great big Mosque...built atop an Armenian Christian graveyard. Muslims do not play nice.