The Saigoon moaned: Rosie -
The idea of why Roudy might lie about his background is actually of little interest to me beyond humour value. If he wants to pretend to be an Iraqi-Iranian-American-Israeli-Insert-other he is welcome to try! Never claimed to be Israeli, sunshine. But the rest is true.
Lying about history I think is both more important and more serious. It is also easier to prove. Well you try hard, but I exposed your ignorance and lies
For instance - Roudy claimed several times the other day that the basis of Malaysian law is Sharia. Anyone with access to Google can confirm that Malaysian law is basd on UK common law - Sharia is only used in some states, and even then only in a limited role. There ya go distorting and lying again. YOU provided Malaysia as a shining example of modernity where Shariah law is not used, and I showed you that it is a dual system, whereby your own admission later, SHARIAH IS used, hence making it yet another SHARIAH SHITHOLE
He claimed there were mosques in Mecca when Mohammed died - again, I am sure most of us know the earliest mosques were in Medina - not in Mecca, some 300 kms away. The point being made was that Muslims claim that the Al aqsa mosque in Jerusalem is supposedly holy to them, because the Koran says when Mohammad died, his spirit rose to heaven from "the farthest mosque" (meaning al aqsa), and since there were NO mosques in Jerusalem at the time of Mohammads death, then IT COULD NOT HAVE BEEN THE AL AQSA. I mistakenly said Mecca when I meant Medina of which there were three mosques at the time. Shoot me.
He has claimed the word Palestine was not used before the Roman era - my sig line suggests this is out by some centuries.I have proven that Palestine referred to the land of the Philistines originally. You lied and said that Palestinian ARABS go back to the stone age, even named a few Israeli cities they can trace their roots going back 3000 years. WHICH ONLY APPLIES TO THE PHILISTINES. I have always claimed that after the Roman invasion of Israel, the land WAS RENAMED TO PALESTINE, THE PEOPLE THE ISRAELITES HAD DEFEATED. The Philistines ceased to exist as a group or people by 5th century AD. Apparently I wounded you so badly that you decided to devote your sig line to me, to save face. I am honored that you wear such a badge of defeat.
He has claimed Palestine nationalism only began in the 1960's - despite the fact newspapers from the 1920's discuss the rising tide of Palestinian nationalism. Some trace the origins of Palestinian nationalism back to riots from 1843, and these have been posted several times. Look up Palestinian nationalism or the state of Palestine, it actually began even later, in the 70's I believe. It is a fact that Arabs did not call themselves or consider themselves Palestinians until the mid 60's. I have provided quotes from Palestinian Arab leaders to that effect
He has claimed that Jews never 'collaborated' with Nazis - after being presented with quotes from two major Jewish historians using the word "collaboration" to describe the actions. Wrong again. I posted a link showing the close ties the Palestinian Arab Mufti of Jerusalem had with the Nazis, he fought for them, he declared himself a Nazi, created a Muslim Nazi army, met with hitler and himmler, and even successfully lobbied Hitler to kill an additional 400,000 Jews. You then compared this animal and put him on the same level as Jews who negotiated and tried to save Jewish lives from being sent to the death camps. You are SICK.
You can argue that one of two of these points are subjective - but in truth most are not. The are simple issues of facts versus fiction. Yes, my facts versus your fiction and WHINNG.
What is remkarable about Roudy's posting is an absolutely insistence on posting fiction, long after the facts have been posted, backed up and linked to reliable sources. What's remarkable is your continued accusations of things you are guilty of yourself.
Why does he do it? Because you are an ignorant fool and I enjoy making you look like one?
I have no idea. That was the first correct thing you said! Bravo!
