Muslims riot in New York.

[Churchill]

But I have access to experts and I have read their positions and looked at the facts on the ground. I certainly haven't intentionally dismissed (a priori) content so as to avoid the facts contained therein.

How did you select which experts to trust? what constitutes an expert anyway? Would you say a Holocaust survivor has a degree of expertise?

Because I don't know the expertise of anyone on wikipedia and when I looked through the footnotes and saw the selection of sources and read through them, I saw a pattern of bias.

Fair enough, so how did you identify the Genocide Project site as being edited by "experts"?

What "bias" did you see in the Wikipedia footnotes?

Then I looked at the background, scope and products (and reviews) of the material and writers on the Genocide Education Project and saw actual qualifications. Why would you rely on wikipedia? That's a bad habit.

You don't seem to understand the diference between citing a source and relying on a source.

evident to whom? I would suggest you read Badenheim, 1939.

Evident to you when reviewing the history of the Third Reich, look at the events that pertain to the persecution of Jews in Germany and tell me at what point in the timelind up to the end of WW2, did the Nazis activities become a genocide?

If you've read Badenheim then feel free to factor that in to your answer.

and what is "pre-Genocide"? Is that a technical term that applies to a specific range of time or do you mean it just as a generic, "all of history before a book used the word to describe an event"?

I thought it was obvious from what I wrote, for example I'd argue that Kristallnacht did not represent the transition from persecutuion to genocide.

I am forming the impression that an expert in your view must be someone who does not recognize that genocide is underway in Gaza. Its a precondition for you, selection bias is what they call that.

 

[Churchill]

There is no genocide taking place in palestine.

How do you know that? do you rely on expert opinion or your own judgement?

The war taking palestinian lives is caused by the unrelenting attacks on Jews by palestinians. As Golda Meir said "The fighting will stop when the palestinians love their children more than they hate Jews.

 

[Hollie]

The spectator article was written by a Zionist Israeli, you'll forgive me for questioning her impartiality, especially given her track record of advocating for the Israeli government which has been condemned in countless UN resolutions for all kinds of crimes.

Natasha Hausdorff - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

In a formal court on this question she'd rightly be expected to recuse herself from participation, so no I won't waste my time reading her propaganda piece.

Its easy to dig up articles denying genocide outside of a proper investigation.

It's easy to hurl the genocide slogan when you're a clueless moron.

 

[Churchill]

It's easy to hurl the genocide slogan when you're a clueless moron.

Ooh another expert, well let me ask you then, at what point in the history of the Third Reich did it become evident that genocide was underway, what date, what event tipped the needle from almost genocide to actual genocide?

For example was Kristallnacht the tipping point? or was it when some specific number of victims had been killed? or was it after some period of time? your opinion.

Look at the history of what the Nazis did, then tell me at what point did their treatment of Jews become actual geneocide?

 

[EvilCat Breath]

How do you know that? do you rely on expert opinion or your own judgement?

Both. I know what genocide is and palestine is NOT it. Palestine is a war. Unfortunately, the belief systems of palestinians cause them to harm their own women and children as a means to generate sympathy. They are like the man who beats his wife and says "Look at what you made me do." That is not genocide.

Palestinians are not a peaceful people. In their own words they love death. So, Thank You IDF for making their wishes come true.

‘We Love Death Like Our Enemies Love Life’ — Speaker at Funeral of Palestinian Terrorist

Illustrative: Palestinians in Jenin at the funeral of gunman Youssef Salah who was killed in an exchange of fire with …

www.algemeiner.com

 

[WEATHER53]

If you're no expert why do you vehemently disagree with those who say there is genocide taking place in Palestine? will you admit then that it might be?

Also why that list and not this one? why did you choose the list you did? I mean you're not an expert so how did you pick that list specifically?

List of genocides - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Also please tell me at what point in the history of the Third Reich did it become evident that genocide was underway, what date, what event tipped the needle from pre-genocide to actual genocide?

It’s another made up and misapplied lib loon term
Genocide is a persistent and long lived attempt to wipe out and wipe away a generation. Israel has killed about 0.5% of the total Muslim population
Stop lying and crying

 

[Hollie]

Doesn’t matter what you think. It only matters what people in power think- that’s why we don’t let them restrict religion.

I feel like you give away your freedom too easily.

I feel like you removed the freedom of children too easily with your vile grooming and mutilating surgeries.

 

[Jarlaxle]

How do you know that? do you rely on expert opinion or your own judgement?

She uses facts, numbers, and common sense. This is not the population curve during a genocide.

 

[Churchill]

Both. I know what genocide is and palestine is NOT it.

So your own judgement? you don't consider other people's opinions?

Palestine is a war. Unfortunately, the belief systems of palestinians cause them to harm their own women and children as a means to generate sympathy. They are like the man who beats his wife and says "Look at what you made me do." That is not genocide.

Why do you think genocide can't take place during a war?

Palestinians are not a peaceful people.

None of them?

In their own words they love death.

When did every Palestinian tell you they love death?

So, Thank You IDF for making their wishes come true.

‘We Love Death Like Our Enemies Love Life’ — Speaker at Funeral of Palestinian Terrorist

Illustrative: Palestinians in Jenin at the funeral of gunman Youssef Salah who was killed in an exchange of fire with …

www.algemeiner.com

Oh is that what you meant!

That's interesting, very much like what Jews said in the Warsaw ghettos once:

Looks to me that a people who are facing genocide will act like that, will prefer death than allow the enemy to simply kill them withiut resistance.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2015/10/10/the-warsaw-ghetto-uprising-armed-jews-vs-nazis/

 

[Churchill]

She uses facts, numbers, and common sense. This is not the population curve during a genocide.

Great, so what is the population curve during a genocide?

 

[Hollie]

Ooh another expert, well let me ask you then, at what point in the history of the Third Reich did it become evident that genocide was underway, what date, what event tipped the needle from almost genocide to actual genocide?

For example was Kristallnacht the tipping point? or was it when some specific number of victims had been killed? or was it after some period of time? your opinion.

Look at the history of what the Nazis did, then tell me at what point did their treatment of Jews become actual geneocide?

Nothing at all to do with your heroes in Hamas invading Israel.

Your Nazi'esque fantasies derived from your Jew hatreds is a mental illness you need treatment for.

 

[EvilCat Breath]

It’s one and the same with Islamic countries.

So it’s both a religion and an ideology

And a political structure.

 

[WEATHER53]

Great, so what is the population curve during a genocide?

Going down dramatically

 

[Hollie]

Great, so what is the population curve during a genocide?

You made no case for any genocide. It's just a slogan you stole.

 

[Jarlaxle]

Great, so what is the population curve during a genocide?

Try this.

Note the drops in the curve, which Gaza LACKS.

 

[Churchill]

It’s another made up and misapplied lib loon term

The term was invented by a Jew in 1944, he pushed to establish the Genocide Convention, you might not have heard of it though.

Genocide is a persistent and long lived attempt to wipe out and wipe away a generation. Israel has killed about 0.5% of the total Muslim population

Wrong, the Genocide Convention makes no mention of percentages.

Stop lying and crying

Stop posting uneducated bilge.

 

[Senior]

If not Genocide, then at a minimum the Israeli's engaged in the mass murder of men, women, and children in Gaza.

As of 6 April 2026, at least 75,498 people (73,459+ Palestinians[4] and 2,039+ Israelis)[7][8][9][10] have been reported killed in the Gaza war according to the Gaza Health Ministry (GHM) and Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs, including 270 journalists and media workers,[11] 120 academics,[12] and over 560 humanitarian aid workers,[13] a number that includes 391 employees of UNRWA.[14] Scholars have estimated 80% of Palestinians killed were civilians.[6][5][15] A study by OHCHR, which verified fatalities from three independent sources, found that 70% of the Palestinians killed in residential buildings or similar housing were women and children.[16][17]

Casualties of the Gaza war - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Proportionality in International Humanitarian Law: A Principle and a Rule - Lieber Institute West Point

Proportionality in IHL takes the form both of a rule and a principle, yet the latter is broader in scope than the former.

lieber.westpoint.edu

 

[Churchill]

Try this.

What's that? the number killed per-age group?

Note the drops in the curve, which Gaza LACKS.

Well as I just told another ignoramus, the Genocide Convention doesn't rely on population curves to establish genocide.

Also the Nazis killed at most 50% of the world's population of Jews, the other 50% were beyond the reach of the Nazis so by your argument the Nazis did not and could not commit genocide (the destruction of the race), do you beleive that? I don't.

 

[Churchill]

Nothing at all to do with your heroes in Hamas invading Israel.

Your Nazi'esque fantasies derived from your Jew hatreds is a mental illness you need treatment for.

You're terrified of answering my question, that's understandable, you're uneducated and have no idea what genocide is nor even heard of the genocide convention.

Let's try again, at what point in the history of the Third Reich did it become evident that genocide was underway? 1939? 1940? 1941?...

 

[Churchill]

Going down dramatically

The population of Gaza has gone down dramatically. The normal rate of death in a population is around 0.9% year. Gaza had a population of about 2,200,000 before Oct 7th. There have been at least 75,000 killed which is 3.5% in two years so the death rate has doubled, by any standard that's dramatic.