Equating social security with programs like SNAP, housing assistance, etc. by lumping them all into the “government cheese” bucket is ignorant and disingenuous. If my wife and I invested the money we have paid into SS instead of giving it to the government, we would each have to live to well over 100 to even come close to breaking even. Remind us how people getting SNAP and other federal assistance programs have paid more into the system than we have. Do they pay even the same percentage in federal income taxes? Do they pay any at all after receiving things like child tax credits which are fully refundable. We don’t get any of these benefits and yet we pay more for them they those receiving them do. Now THAT is “government cheese.” And to top it all off, Democrats are ok with allowing anybody from any other country to come across our border and get a slice, despite paying NOTHING into our system. The foundation of your argument is deeply misguided.
This is the kind of stuff they must be teaching in Democratic Ideology 101 as
JoeB131 does the same thing, except he goes even further and calls it white people welfare. You know, because there are more white people in the country getting SS than black people. Of course that stands to reason as there are 5-6 times more white people than black people, but evidently that doesn’t matter. Faulty logic at its finest.
Wow, I'm living in your head rent-free, Cleetus. I'm so happy.
Anyway, Marener wasn't talking about Social Security; he was referring to issues like the government bailouts of banks in 2008, or what Trump wants to do now, spending $ 20 billion to bail out soybean farmers because the Chinese are refusing to buy our soybeans.
But, yes, there is plenty of White People Welfare. Not just that, more white people collect what we call the traditional welfare of SNAP, Section 8, TANF than people of color, but also the "White People Welfare" of Social Security, Medicare, Unemployment Insurance, and Veterans' benefits. The things we like to call "Entitlements", because like white people, we always feel we are "entitled" to something.
Now before you mewl about how "White people have paid into this all their lives".... um, not really.
Let's review, shall we?
First, most people on assistance are only on it for a short time, and a lot of them have at least one family member who has a job. Most of the rest are people who are retired or disabled.
Secondly, most people collecting "White People Welfare" (AKA Entitlements) didn't pay into it all their lives.
We can start with the obvious one. Social Security. Half of that is paid by employers. The other half is that 6% of your paycheck you pay in, but if you retire at 65 and live to be 72, you've gotten back everything you paid in. This is why Social Security is going broke. The average lifespan is now 78. It was only 62 when Social Security started. The boomers working kept it flush, but now they are retiring and it's going broke.
Medicare- You pay 1% of your lifetime earnings into it. One serious illness will wipe all of that out. It doesn't help that, because we don't have a single-payer system controlling costs (like all the other G-7 countries), medical inflation is three times the regular inflation rate.
Unemployment Insurance- Once again, you don't pay that, your employer does, and the pittance that is paid is usually wiped out if you are unemployed for more than a few weeks. It's okay if you have low unemployment, but when Republicans get in and cause the inevitable recession, those funds are wiped out completely.
Ah, and then we get Veteran's Benefits. Full disclosure: as a Vet, the only times I've used them are to pay for college (as a reservist) and to get a home loan. But here's the thing. You receive the same veterans' benefits whether you serve 30 years or 2 years. So on one is "Paying" into that.
So what is the difference? Middle Class Entitlements vs. Poor People Assistance. And because Americans are generally awful people, we have no problem with the former and resent the latter.